AI summary · DOI: 10.64898/2026.11.05.764581 · bioRxiv: Ecology

Two decades of EU pesticide substitution have not reduced impacts on stream invertebrates

J. Gröning, M. Liess
Original paper Published on 09 Nov. 2026 bioRxiv preprint License: CC BY 4.0 Also in: fr

How to read this summary? Illustrated guide

The essentials

Across 152 German agricultural streams, pesticide toxic pressure and related invertebrate impairment did not decline from 1998 to 2021 despite successive chemical substitutions.

Based on the abstract only: check the details in the original paper.

Question

The study tests whether withdrawing hazardous pesticides and replacing them with alternatives has reduced harm to stream invertebrates under the EU pesticide regulatory framework. It asks whether pesticide exposure and ecological effects changed over time.

Method

The authors analyzed a 23-year record of event-driven pesticide exposure and stream-invertebrate communities from 152 German agricultural streams sampled between 1998 and 2021. They assessed trends in pesticide toxic pressure and pesticide-related invertebrate impairment, including changes in the chemicals driving toxicity.

Findings

  • Result Neither pesticide toxic pressure nor pesticide-related invertebrate impairment showed a detectable decline over the study period.
    See the passage in the paper
    Neither pesticide toxic pressure nor pesticide-related invertebrate impairment showed a detectable decline over time
  • Result An improvement equivalent to one ecological status class can be excluded.
    See the passage in the paper
    an improvement equivalent to one ecological status class can be excluded.
  • Result The dominant toxicity drivers shifted from organophosphates to neonicotinoids and then to pyrethroids, while the relationship between toxic pressure and community effects remained consistent.
    See the passage in the paper
    Dominant toxicity drivers shifted from organophosphates to neonicotinoids and subsequently to pyrethroids, yet the relationship between toxic pressure and community effects remained consistent despite their distinct modes of action.
  • Authors’ interpretation The authors attribute sustained toxic pressure to chemical substitution, prolonged approval periods, and exposure to substances no longer authorised as plant protection products.
    See the passage in the paper
    Sustained toxic pressure reflected three mechanisms: successive chemical substitution, prolonged approval periods, and continued exposure to substances no longer authorised as plant protection products.
  • Authors’ interpretation Substitution changed the chemicals harming streams but not the overall level of harm.
    See the passage in the paper
    Substitution thus changed which chemicals harm streams, not how much.

Limitations

  • The evidence is specific to sampled German agricultural streams and does not establish trends for other settings.
  • The study covers pesticide exposure and invertebrate communities over the 1998–2021 sampling period.

Why it matters

The authors argue that pesticide substitution alone has not delivered reduced ecological harm in these streams. They call for measured field outcomes to serve as the benchmark for pesticide regulation.

Written by AI from the paper. Passages are checked word for word against the text we analysed; the rest may contain errors.

AI-generated keywords: pesticides; stream invertebrates; toxic pressure; ecological impairment; pesticide regulation

Read further

  • Comprehensive Summary
  • Layman's Summary
  • Blog article
  • Original abstract
The paper examines whether replacing hazardous pesticides with newer or supposedly safer alternatives has reduced harm to stream invertebrates under the European Union’s pesticide regulatory framework. The authors analyze 23 years of pesticide exposure and ecological data from 152 German agricultural streams sampled between 1998 and 2021. Because sampling was event-driven, the study could assess pesticide exposure associated with specific events rather than relying solely on routine measurements. The authors tracked pesticide toxic pressure and pesticide-related impairment in stream-invertebrate communities. The abstract does not explain how these measures were calculated, how many samples were collected, or which covariates and statistical models were used. It reports no numerical estimates or confidence intervals for the trends. Neither toxic pressure nor pesticide-related impairment showed a detectable decline during the study period. The authors also report that an improvement equivalent to one ecological status class can be ruled out. Thus, the findings do more than show a lack of evidence for a large improvement: according to the abstract, they exclude an improvement of that magnitude. Although overall toxic pressure and impairment remained stable, the pesticide groups most responsible for toxicity changed over time. Organophosphates were initially the dominant toxicity drivers, followed by neonicotinoids and then pyrethroids. Despite their different modes of action, the relationship between toxic pressure and community effects remained consistent. The shift in dominant chemicals therefore did not correspond to a weaker association between pesticide exposure and ecological harm. The authors attribute persistent toxic pressure to the successive replacement of one chemical group with another, prolonged approval periods, and continued exposure to substances no longer authorised as plant protection products. They conclude that substitution changed which pesticides harmed streams without reducing the overall extent of harm. Accordingly, they argue that pesticide regulation should be evaluated against measured environmental outcomes rather than the assumption that withdrawing and replacing substances will necessarily reduce ecological impacts. The findings apply to the German agricultural streams studied between 1998 and 2021; the abstract does not establish whether they extend to other regions, habitats, or regulatory systems. Because the full paper was not provided, it is not possible to assess the representativeness of the streams, the exposure and biological indicators, potential confounding factors, or the uncertainty surrounding the reported trends. The study is described as observational, so the abstract supports an association between persistent toxic pressure and persistent impairment but does not establish the causal contribution of each regulatory mechanism. Overall, the reported evidence challenges the assumption that pesticide substitution alone produces measurable ecological improvement.

Was this synthesis useful?

Score: 0

Why do we need votes?

Votes are used to determine whether we need to re-run our summarizing tools. If the count reaches -10, our tools can be restarted.

Ask questions about this paper to our AI assistant

How to chat with this paper? Illustrated guide

You can also chat with multiple papers at once here.

Figures and plots

Ask about a figure by number or use its question button to request visual analysis. Up to two figures and four image panels per question. Values read from plots are approximate; check the original data.

AI assistant instructions?

Tools for this paper

Explain it differently 1 free rewrite left today
Save to a collection Group papers in collections to compare them, chat with them and export them. Continue with Google Create a free account Log in

Advanced tools Premium

For researchers who follow a field closely: citation alerts, journal-club slides, version comparison and Zotero export. Discover Premium

Zotero Zotero guide
Citation alerts Citation alerts guide
Who works on it?

Among the 23 papers around this one, the name that comes back most: M. Liess (3 papers)

4 more people sign several of them. The full map adds their institutions and approaches, from the papers of the last years.

Continue with Google Create a free account: your first map is free
Weekly letter Presented in "Climate and Earth this week" of 16 November 2026. Climate and Earth this week: What changes, what persists, and what we miss · Receive one by email for free

Papers around this one

See them on a map

Ranked by how close their title and abstract are to this paper’s. Select some to read them together.

Closest papers

  1. Close Same question Cited by this paper Used in depth by this paper
    Pesticides are the dominant stressors for vulnerable insects in lowland streams.
    M. Liess, L. Liebmann, Philipp Vormeier et al. · 2021 · Water Research · cited 192 times · Not summarized yet

    The study identifies pesticide pollution as a major cause of vulnerable insect declines in German lowland streams, complementing the paper’s long-term analysis of pesticide impacts.

    Abstract

    Despite elaborate regulation of agricultural pesticides, their occurrence in non-target areas has been linked to adverse ecological effects on insects in several field investigations. Their quantitative role in contributing to the biodiversity crisis is, however, still not known. In a large-scale study across 101 sites of small lowland streams in Central Europe, Germany we revealed that 83% of agricultural streams did not meet the pesticide-related ecological targets. For the first time we identified that agricultural nonpoint-source pesticide pollution was the major driver in reducing vulnerable insect populations in aquatic invertebrate communities, exceeding the relevance of other anthrop…

  2. Close Broader context Cited by this paper
    Applied pesticide toxicity shifts toward plants and invertebrates, even in GM crops
    R. Schulz, S. Bub, L. Petschick et al. · 2021 · Science · cited 267 times · Not summarized yet

    Schulz et al. track pesticide toxicity trends and find rising toxicity to insects and aquatic invertebrates, providing broader context for the paper’s stream-level results.

    Abstract

    A shifting burden In 1962, Rachel Carson's Silent Spring was published, and the world was forced to take notice of the unintended impacts of pesticides on wildlife. Since then, there has been a perceived reduction in the amount of pesticides used and a shift in the kinds of pesticides available. Schulz et al. looked at the type, amount, and toxicity of pesticides applied over the last 25 years. They found that despite decreasing total amounts applied and decreased impacts on vertebrates, toxicity—in particular to insects and aquatic invertebrates—has increased substantially. Science, this issue p. 81 Pesticide toxicity to nontarget invertebrates has increased over time. Pesticide impacts are…

  3. Close Review
    Sustainable Mitigation of Pesticide Impacts in Insect Pest Management: A Review
    Lutfi Muzaqi, R. S. Dinurrosifa, Agustin Citra Dwi Handoko et al. · 2026 · Indian Journal of Entomology · Not summarized yet

    The review synthesizes pesticide impacts and mitigation strategies across agricultural and other management settings.

    Abstract

    Repeated insecticide use can accelerate resistance, contaminate food and water, and disrupt organisms that support pest regulation. This review synthesized 80 peer-reviewed studies published in 2024-2025 on pesticide impacts and practical mitigation in agricultural, stored-product and vector-management systems. The evidence consistently showed that no single alternative can replace conventional insecticides across production contexts. The most defensible pathway is locally adapted integrated pest management that combines economic thresholds, selective compounds, conservation of natural enemies, microbial and botanical products, precision delivery, residue monitoring, resistance diagnostics a…

  4. Close Same question Cited by this paper
    Temporal scales of pesticide exposure and risks in German small streams.
    Philipp Vormeier, Verena C. Schreiner, L. Liebmann et al. · 2023 · Science of the Total Environment · cited 29 times · Not summarized yet

    The study measures event-driven pesticide toxicity in German agricultural streams, examining temporal exposure patterns relevant to the paper’s stream monitoring.

    Abstract

    Following agricultural application, pesticides can enter streams through runoff during rain events. However, little information is available on the temporal dynamics of pesticide toxicity during the main application period. We investigated pesticide application and large scale in-stream monitoring data from 101 agricultural catchments obtained from a Germany-wide monitoring from April to July in 2018 and 2019. We analysed temporal patterns of pesticide application, in-stream toxicity and exceedances of regulatory acceptable concentrations (RAC) for over 70 pesticides. On a monthly scale from April to July, toxicity to invertebrates and algae/aquatic plants (algae) obtained with event-driven …

  5. Close Same method, another problem Cited by this paper
    Indication of pesticide effects and recolonization in streams.
    Saskia Knillmann, Polina Orlinskiy, Oliver Kaske et al. · 2018 · Science of the Total Environment · cited 66 times · Not summarized yet

    The study revises the SPEARpesticides bioindicator to account for refuge taxa when detecting pesticide effects on stream invertebrate communities.

    Abstract

    The agricultural use of pesticides leads to environmentally relevant pesticide concentrations that cause adverse effects on stream ecosystems. These effects on invertebrate community composition can be identified by the bio-indicator SPEARpesticides. However, refuge areas have been found to partly confound the indicator. On the basis of three monitoring campaigns of 41 sites in Central Germany, we identified 11 refuge taxa. The refuge taxa, mainly characterized by dispersal-based resilience, were observed only nearby uncontaminated stream sections and independent of the level of pesticide pressure. Through incorporation of this information into the revised SPEARpesticides indicator, the comm…

  6. Close Same question Cited by this paper
    Pesticide risk assessment in European agriculture: Distribution patterns, ban-substitution effects and regulatory implications.
    Luisa Gensch, Kerstin Jantke, Livia Rasche et al. · 2024 · Environmental Pollution · cited 80 times · Not summarized yet

    The study estimates European pesticide loads and evaluates how bans affect them, addressing pesticide substitution and regulatory consequences at a broader scale.

    Abstract

    This study estimates the risks of agricultural pesticides on non-target organisms and the environment by combining detailed pesticide application data for 2015 with the Danish risk indicator Pesticide Load. We quantify and map the pesticide load of 59 pesticides on 28 crops and pastures in the EU. Furthermore, we investigate how recent bans on 14 pesticides in the EU could reduce pesticide use and load. Key findings show that the highest pesticide loads per hectare occur in Cyprus and the Netherlands due to high application rates and a high proportion of vegetable production. Chlorpyrifos caused the highest pesticide load per hectare on more than half of the assessed crops before its ban. Th…

  7. Close* Same question Cited by this paper
    Effects of pesticides on community structure and ecosystem functions in agricultural streams of three biogeographical regions in Europe.
    R. B. Schäfer, T. Caquet, K. Siimes et al. · 2007 · Science of the Total Environment · cited 414 times · Not summarized yet

    The study examines pesticide effects on community structure and ecosystem functions in agricultural streams across European regions.

  8. Close Same question
    France’s Pesticide Load Index: Decreasing Ecotoxicity, Persistent Human Toxicity, Rising Concern For Environmental Fate
    Thomas Perrot, C. Fontaine, Niklas Möhring · 2026 · Peer Community Journal · Not summarized yet

    The study tracks pesticide risk trends in France using the Pesticide Load Index, covering ecotoxicity alongside human health and environmental fate.

    Abstract

    Pesticide use has strong adverse effect on biodiversity, ecosystem functioning and human health . Numerous policies have been proposed to reduce their use and associated risk but evaluations of changes in pesticide risk over time and space are still rare. Here, we evaluate temporal and spatial trends of pesticide risks in France between 2012-2022 using the Pesticide Load Index. The Pesticide Load Index assesses ecotoxicity, human health and fate risks of pesticides, and has been previously employed in Denmark and the UK. The Pesticide Load Index was evaluated accounting for 293 different active substances and 2977 commercial products (99% of sold pesticides mass). We found that pesticide ris…

Prior work it builds on

  1. Close Same question
    Multiple lines of evidence point to pesticides as stressors affecting invertebrate communities in small streams in five United States regions.
    L. Nowell, P. Moran, Ian R. Waite et al. · 2024 · Science of the Total Environment · cited 15 times · Not summarized yet

    The study assesses pesticides among stressors affecting stream invertebrate communities across five United States regions using multiple lines of evidence.

    Abstract

    Multistressor studies were performed in five regions of the United States to assess the role of pesticides as stressors affecting invertebrate communities in wadable streams. Pesticides and other chemical and physical stressors were measured in 75 to 99 streams per region for 4 weeks, after which invertebrate communities were surveyed (435 total sites). Pesticides were sampled weekly in filtered water, and once in bed sediment. The role of pesticides as a stressor to invertebrate communities was assessed by evaluating multiple lines of evidence: toxicity predictions based on measured pesticide concentrations, multivariate models and other statistical analyses, and previously published mesoco…

  2. Close* Broader context
    Partitioning and ecotoxicological effects of pyrethroids in streams – Dissolved fraction mediates invertebrate toxicity
    J. Gröning, Alexander Böhme, Mara Römerscheid et al. · 2026 · Journal of Hazardous Materials Advances · cited 2 times · Not summarized yet

    The study examines how pyrethroid partitioning in streams relates to invertebrate toxicity, a mechanism relevant to one toxicity driver identified in the paper.

  3. Related Same method, another problem
    Calibration of the SPEARpesticides bioindicator for cost-effective pesticide monitoring in East African streams
    Akbar A. Ganatra, F. Kandie, U. Fillinger et al. · 2021 · Environmental Sciences Europe · cited 10 times · Not summarized yet

    The study calibrates SPEARpesticides for East African streams to assess pesticide-related changes in macroinvertebrate communities.

    Abstract

    Background Pesticides are washed from agricultural fields into adjacent streams, where even short-term exposure causes long-term ecological damage. Detecting pesticide pollution in streams thus requires the expensive monitoring of peak concentrations during run-off events. Alternatively, exposure and ecological effects can be assessed using the SPEAR pesticides bioindicator that quantifies pesticide-related changes in the macroinvertebrate community composition. SPEAR pesticides has been developed in Central Europe and validated in other parts of Europe, Australia and South America; here we investigated its performance in East African streams. Results With minimal adaptations of the SPEAR pe…

  4. Related* Groundwork for this paper
    The footprint of pesticide stress in communities--species traits reveal community effects of toxicants.
    M. Liess, Ralf B. Schäfer, Carola A. Schriever · 2008 · Science of the Total Environment · cited 211 times · Not summarized yet

    The study uses species traits to identify community effects of toxicants, providing a basis for interpreting pesticide-related changes in stream communities.

  5. Related* Same question
    Response of macroinvertebrate communities to temporal dynamics of pesticide mixtures: A case study from the Sacramento River watershed, California.
    Ming-Chih Chiu, L. Hunt, V. Resh · 2016 · Environmental Pollution · cited 28 times · Not summarized yet

    The study examines how temporal pesticide-mixture dynamics relate to macroinvertebrate community responses in a California watershed.

How are these papers found?

We compare the title and abstract of this paper with those of every paper summarized on this site, and with the papers Semantic Scholar recommends, those it cites and those citing it (for a much-cited paper, its most recent citations and, from OpenAlex, the most cited ones). Among the prior work and the follow-ups, the papers that use each other in depth, a method it uses and the much-cited follow-ups come a little higher. The levels (very close, close, related) come from the similarity of the texts, not from a judgment of quality; * marks a paper without an abstract, compared by its title. The sentence under a paper is written by an AI from the two abstracts: check it in the papers. A paper marked not relevant by three readers leaves the list.

Updated on 16 November 2026.

The illustrated guide to the papers around a paper

Disclaimer: The AI-based summarization tool and virtual assistant provided on this website may not always provide accurate and complete summaries or responses. We encourage you to carefully review and evaluate the generated content to ensure its quality and relevance to your needs.