AI summary · arXiv: 2203.01827v3 · cs.SI

Democratic Governance and International Research Collaboration: A Longitudinal Analysis of the Global Science Network

Travis A. Whetsell
Original paper · DOI 10.1371/journal.pone.0287058 Submitted to arXiv on 27 Feb. 2022 Published in PLOS ONE (13 Jun. 2023) License: NONEXCLUSIVE-DISTRIB 1.0

How to read this summary? Illustrated guide

The essentials

  • The relationship between democracy and science has been debated through philosophical conjecture and single country case studies
  • Limited global scale empirical research exists on the topic
  • Travis A. Whetsell explores country-level factors that affect the dynamics of the global scientific research collaboration network, with a focus on structural associations between democratic governance and international research collaboration ties
  • Longitudinal data from 2008 to 2017 from various sources such as the Varieties of Democracy Institute, World Bank Indicators, Scopus, and Web of Science bibliometric data was used for analysis
  • Positive significant effects of democratic governance on international research collaboration were found
  • Homophily between countries with similar levels of democratic governance was observed
  • Exogenous economic, population, and geo-political factors play a crucial role in shaping international research collaborations
  • Endogenous network factors such as preferential attachment and transitivity also play a crucial role in determining the strength of these collaborations

Key points written by AI: they may contain errors, check them against the paper.

AI-generated keywords: Democracy Science Global Research Collaboration Network Factors Longitudinal Data

Read further

  • Comprehensive Summary
  • Layman's Summary
  • Blog article
  • Original abstract
The relationship between democracy and science has long been debated through philosophical conjecture and single country case studies. However, limited global scale empirical research exists on the topic. In this study, Travis A. Whetsell explores country-level factors that affect the dynamics of the global scientific research collaboration network, with a focus on structural associations between democratic governance and the formation, persistence, and strength of international research collaboration ties. Using longitudinal data from 2008 to 2017 from various sources such as the Varieties of Democracy Institute, World Bank Indicators, Scopus, and Web of Science bibliometric data, Whetsell employs temporal and weighted exponential random graph models (ERGM) for analysis. The results suggest positive significant effects of democratic governance on international research collaboration and homophily between countries with similar levels of democratic governance. Moreover, the study highlights the importance of exogenous economic, population, and geo-political factors in shaping international research collaborations. Endogenous network factors such as preferential attachment and transitivity also play a crucial role in determining the strength of these collaborations. Overall, this study provides valuable insights into how democratic governance impacts international scientific collaborations at a global level. It reveals how various external and internal factors shape these collaborations over time by providing evidence for positive effects of democratic governance on international research collaboration networks as well as highlighting other influential factors involved in their formation.

Was this synthesis useful?

Score: 0

Why do we need votes?

Votes are used to determine whether we need to re-run our summarizing tools. If the count reaches -10, our tools can be restarted.

Figures and plots

Ask about a figure by number or use its question button to request visual analysis. Up to two figures and four image panels per question. Values read from plots are approximate; check the original data.

AI assistant instructions?

Tools for this paper

Explain it differently 1 free rewrite left today
Save to a collection Group papers in collections to compare them, chat with them and export them. Continue with Google Create a free account Log in

Advanced tools Premium

For researchers who follow a field closely: citation alerts, journal-club slides, version comparison and Zotero export. Discover Premium

Zotero Zotero guide
Citation alerts 15 papers already cite it: be emailed each new one. Citation alerts guide
Who works on it?

Among the 31 papers around this one, the name that comes back most: Travis A. Whetsell (4 papers)

2 more people sign several of them. The full map adds their institutions and approaches, from the papers of the last years.

Continue with Google Create a free account: your first map is free
Weekly letter The latest letter of its field, "Computing beyond AI this week" of 16 November 2026: Computing beyond AI this week: The costs hidden in our maps, networks and algorithms · Receive one by email for free

Papers around this one

See them on a map

Ranked by how close their title and abstract are to this paper’s. Select some to read them together.

Closest papers

  1. Very close Builds on this paper Cites this paper Uses this paper in depth
    Academic Freedom and International Research Collaboration: A Longitudinal Analysis of Global Network Evolution
    Travis A. Whetsell, Jen Sidorova · 2024 · arXiv.org · preprint, not peer reviewed · cited 4 times · Not summarized yet

    Academic Freedom and International Research Collaboration examines academic freedom’s effects on global collaboration and cites this study on democratic governance.

    Abstract

    The topic of academic freedom has come to the fore as nations around the world experience a wave of democratic backsliding. Institutions of higher education are often targets of autocrats who seek to suppress intellectual sources of social and political resistance. At the same time, international collaboration in scientific research continues unabated, and the network of global science grows larger and denser every year. This research analyzes the effects of academic freedom on international research collaboration (IRC) in a sample of 166 countries. Global international collaboration data are drawn from articles in Web of Science across a 30-year time frame (1993-2022) and are used to constr…

  2. Close Same question
    Macro-level collaboration network analysis and visualization with Essential Science Indicators: A case of social science
    Dong-Hui Yang, Yan Wang, Tian Yu et al. · 2020 · Malaysian Journal of Library & Information Science · cited 11 times · Not summarized yet

    Macro-level collaboration network analysis maps cross-national co-authorship networks, focusing on social-science collaboration rather than democratic governance.

    Abstract

    Cross-national collaboration has been shaped by internationalization of scientific relationships. To study the synergic network of high quality research patterns, this paper collects a total of 300 top 50 items, in each indicator from the big database, Essential Science Indicators, which lists top-ranking papers, scientists and institutions from 2005 to 2015. First, the country level relations of co-authorship addresses in five indicator variables are extracted in the field of social sciences to build international collaboration networks. The social network analysis (SNA) method was applied to calculate the metrics of vertices, edges, average degree, average shortest path, diameter, clusteri…

  3. Close Same question Cited by this paper Used in depth by this paper
    OUP accepted manuscript
    Travis A. Whetsell, K. Jonkers, A. Dimand et al. · 2019 · Science and Public Policy · cited 16 times · Not summarized yet

    OUP accepted manuscript tests how democratic governance relates to scientific performance, whereas this study examines its association with international collaboration ties.

    Abstract

    Scholars have long hypothesized that democratic forms of government are more compatible with scientific advancement. However, empirical analysis testing the democracy-science compatibility hypothesis remains underdeveloped. This article explores the effect of democratic governance on scientific performance using panel data on 124 countries between 2007 and 2017. We find evidence supporting the democracy-science hypothesis. Further, using both internal and external measures of complexity, we estimate the effects of complexity as a moderating factor between the democracy-science connection. The results show differential main effects of economic complexity, globalization, and international coll…

  4. Close Same question Cites this paper
    Co-evolution of the global research collaboration network and the performance of nations in science and technology
    Travis A. Whetsell, Jeongyoon Jane Yang · 2026 · arXiv.org · preprint, not peer reviewed · Not summarized yet

    Co-evolution of the global research collaboration network studies international collaboration alongside national science performance using longitudinal network data.

    Abstract

    Researchers have long suspected that international research collaboration (IRC) and scientific and technological (S&T) performance are subject to reciprocal causality, yet the endogenous co-evolution of these twin phenomena has yet to be tested by large-scale empirical analysis. This study tests these effects simultaneously using a longitudinal co-evolution model on three decades of global network and national performance data. Stochastic actor-oriented models (SAOM) are used to analyze data on 172 countries from 1993 to 2022. Yearly IRC networks are constructed from Web of Science's XML database, and performance data are gathered from Elsevier's fractional field-weighted citation impact (FW…

  5. Close Groundwork for this paper Cited by this paper
    Network Structure, Self-Organization and the Growth of International Collaboration in Science.Research Policy, 34(10), 2005, 1608-1618.
    C. Wagner, L. Leydesdorff · 2005 · cited 1,117 times · Not summarized yet

    Network Structure, Self-Organization and the Growth of International Collaboration in Science analyzes preferential attachment in international co-authorship networks, a network mechanism used in this study.

    Abstract

    Different approaches have been used to analyse international collaboration in science but none can fully explain its rapid growth. Using international co-authorships, we test the hypothesis that international collaboration is a self-organising network. Applying tools from network analysis, the paper shows that the growth of international co-authorships can be explained based on the organising principle of preferential attachment, although the attachment mechanism deviates from an ideal power-law. Several explanations for the deviation are explored, including that of the influence of institutional constraints on the mechanism of self-organisation.

  6. Close Same question Cites this paper
    Global Shifts in Scientific Production: The Decline of Academic Freedom and the Impact on International Collaboration
    Rickard Danell · 2025 · Europaeum review · cited 5 times · Not summarized yet

    Global Shifts in Scientific Production examines political change, academic freedom, and international collaboration in global science.

    Abstract

    This article investigates the evolving dynamics of global scientific production and collaboration from 2000 to 2022, focusing on the impact of geopolitical changes on academic freedom and international research collaboration. Historically dominated by Western liberal democracies, the global scientific landscape has seen a significant shift with the rise of emerging economies, particularly within the BRICS group. This transition reflects broader changes in wealth distribution and scientific output, with China emerging as the largest scientific system. The analysis employs bibliometric indicators and political metrics, including the V-Dem’s Liberal Democracy Index and the Academic Freedom Inde…

  7. Close Shared data, tool or method Cited by this paper
    Detecting and analyzing research communities in longitudinal scientific networks
    Valerio Leone Sciabolazza, R. Vacca, Therese Kennelly Okraku et al. · 2017 · PLoS ONE · cited 36 times · Not summarized yet

    Detecting and analyzing research communities in longitudinal scientific networks develops methods for analyzing collaboration communities over time.

    Abstract

    A growing body of evidence shows that collaborative teams and communities tend to produce the highest-impact scientific work. This paper proposes a new method to (1) Identify collaborative communities in longitudinal scientific networks, and (2) Evaluate the impact of specific research institutes, services or policies on the interdisciplinary collaboration between these communities. First, we apply community-detection algorithms to cross-sectional scientific collaboration networks and analyze different types of co-membership in the resulting subgroups over time. This analysis summarizes large amounts of longitudinal network data to extract sets of research communities whose members have cons…

  8. Close* Same question Cites this paper
    Unpacking the dynamics of international research collaboration network: structural effects and dyadic effects
    Qin-Chang Gui, Wei Xu, Shidan Jiang et al. · 2025 · Technology and Society · cited 7 times · Not summarized yet

    Unpacking the dynamics of international research collaboration network examines structural and dyadic effects shaping international collaboration ties.

Prior work it builds on

  1. Related* Groundwork for this paper Used in depth by this paper
    Endogenous networks and international cooperation
    Max Gallop · 2016 · Journal of Peace Research · cited 16 times · Not summarized yet

    Endogenous networks and international cooperation is cited as prior work relevant to this study’s analysis of network formation.

  2. Close Broader context
    Benefits, Motivations, and Challenges of International Collaborative Research: A Sociology of Science Case Study
    Jennifer Dusdal, Justin J. W. Powell · 2021 · Science and Public Policy · cited 203 times · Not summarized yet

    Benefits, Motivations, and Challenges of International Collaborative Research studies team members’ experiences and the challenges of sustaining international research projects.

    Abstract

    Contemporary science is marked by expanding and diverse forms of teamwork. Collaboration across organizational and cultural boundaries extends the possibilities of discovery. International collaborative research projects often provide findings beyond what one team could achieve alone. Motivated to maintain existing relationships and grow their scientific network, researchers increasingly collaborate, despite often unrecognized or underappreciated costs, since such projects are challenging to manage and carry out. Rarely studied in-depth and longitudinally, the perspectives of scientific team members are crucial to better understand the dynamics of durable collaboration networks. Thus, this r…

  3. Close* Broader context
    The Social Capital of Global Ties in Science: The Added Value of International Collaboration
    J. Melkers, Agrita Kiopa · 2010 · Review of Policy Research · cited 92 times · Not summarized yet

    The Social Capital of Global Ties in Science examines the added value of international collaboration, a broader question about global scientific ties.

  4. Close* Broader context
    Why Democracies Cooperate More: Electoral Control and International Trade Agreements
    Edward D. Mansfield, Helen V. Milner, B. Rosendorff · 2002 · International Organization · cited 789 times · Not summarized yet

    Why Democracies Cooperate More explains democratic cooperation in international trade agreements rather than scientific collaboration.

  5. Related Broader context
    What science can do for democracy: a complexity science approach
    Tina Eliassi-Rad, H. Farrell, D. García et al. · 2020 · Humanities and Social Sciences Communications · cited 19 times · Not summarized yet

    What science can do for democracy applies complexity science to democratic instability, rather than studying democracy’s association with science networks.

    Abstract

    Political scientists have conventionally assumed that achieving democracy is a one-way ratchet. Only very recently has the question of “democratic backsliding” attracted any research attention. We argue that democratic instability is best understood with tools from complexity science. The explanatory power of complexity science arises from several features of complex systems. Their relevance in the context of democracy is discussed. Several policy recommendations are offered to help (re)stabilize current systems of representative democracy.

Papers that cite it

  1. Related Same method, another problem
    Network relations among open government data stakeholders: a structural social capital and ERGM analysis
    Fuchuan Mo, Xiaojuan Zhang, Cuicui Feng et al. · 2024 · Online information review (Print) · cited 8 times · Not summarized yet

    Network relations among open government data stakeholders uses ERGM to analyze mechanisms shaping a collaboration network in a different setting.

    Abstract

    PurposeThe objective of this research is to methodically categorize the various types of Open Government Data (OGD) stakeholders, and to elucidate the intricate network relationships among OGD stakeholders, along with the underlying mechanisms that shape their formation.Design/methodology/approachTo comprehend the collaboration mechanism of stakeholders in the OGD ecosystem, the authors constructed an OGD multi-stakeholder relationship network by using data from the Shandong Province Data Application Innovation and Entrepreneurship Competition. Based on the structural social capital theory and exponential random graph model (ERGM), an analytical framework was established to explore the forma…

  2. Related Same method, another problem
    Uncovering collaborative patterns and transition dynamics in R&D projects: a longitudinal analysis of EU Framework Programmes
    Andrea Ancona, Roy Cerqueti, G. Vagnani · 2026 · Industrial and Corporate Change · cited 1 time · Not summarized yet

    Uncovering collaborative patterns and transition dynamics analyzes changing collaboration networks over time, but studies EU research-program participation.

    Abstract

    Policymakers have increasingly supported collaborative R&D, recognizing its role in enhancing the innovation performance and scientific reputation of organizations. This paper proposes a three-step procedure to examine collaborative patterns and participation dynamics over consecutive research programs by integrating Social Network Analysis and statistical methods. First, participants in R&D projects are ranked based on their centrality in the collaborative network. Second, transition probabilities between classes of centrality across consecutive programs are estimated. Third, the Markovian nature of collaborative patterns, which is controversial across methodological, theoretical, and empir…

  3. Related Same question
    The altering landscape of US–China science collaboration: from convergence to divergence
    K. Kitajima, Keisuke Okamura · 2023 · Humanities and Social Sciences Communications · cited 11 times · Not summarized yet

    The altering landscape of US–China science collaboration studies changing international research collaboration, focusing on one country pair.

    Abstract

    International research collaboration has exhibited a significant trend towards convergence in recent decades. The US and China have notably intensified their collaboration across diverse scientific disciplines, solidifying their status as the leading contributors to global scientific knowledge production. However, recent reports indicate a potential decline in their collaboration, despite the overall trend of increasing global scientific convergence. Understanding the intricate interplay between collaboration and disparity within the US–China relationship is vital for academics and policymakers, as it can provide insights into the future trajectory of global science collaboration. Despite it…

  4. Related Same method, another problem
    Sustainable Governance of the Global Rare Earth Industry Chains: Perspectives of Geopolitical Cooperation and Conflict
    Chun-Xiang Liu, Feng-Xiu Zhou, Jia-Yi Jiang et al. · 2025 · Sustainability · cited 12 times · Not summarized yet

    Sustainable Governance of the Global Rare Earth Industry Chains uses temporal ERGMs to model geopolitical cooperation and trade networks, not research collaboration.

    Abstract

    As critical strategic mineral resources underpinning high-tech industries and national defense security, rare earth elements have become a central focus of international competition, with their global industrial chain configuration deeply intertwined with geopolitical dynamics. Leveraging a novel multilateral database encompassing 140 countries’ geopolitical relationships and rare earth trade flows (2001–2023), this study employs social network analysis and temporal exponential random graph models (TERGMs) to decode structural interdependencies across upstream mineral concentrates, midstream smelting, and downstream permanent magnet sectors. Empirical results show that topological density tr…

  5. Related Broader context
    Science and the nation-state: What China’s experience reveals about the role of policy in science
    Caroline S. Wagner · 2024 · Science and Public Policy · cited 9 times · Not summarized yet

    Science and the nation-state discusses democracy, government policy, and science through China’s experience rather than global collaboration networks.

    Abstract

    China’s rapid rise and spectacular growth in science capacity reopens a discussion about the relationship between science and the nation-state. Literature suggests that science thrives within a democratic system and that scientific activities tend to have a liberalizing effect on governments. Neither of these phenomena appears evident in China’s case. Three policies, present in the earliest days of the growth of modern science, ones in common with other nations, factor into China’s science policy: (1) policies enabling protection of intellectual property, (2) encouraging mobility and skills development, and (3) government procurement of science and technology, especially through military pur…

How are these papers found?

We compare the title and abstract of this paper with those of every paper summarized on this site, and with the papers Semantic Scholar recommends, those it cites and those citing it (for a much-cited paper, its most recent citations and, from OpenAlex, the most cited ones). Among the prior work and the follow-ups, the papers that use each other in depth, a method it uses and the much-cited follow-ups come a little higher. The levels (very close, close, related) come from the similarity of the texts, not from a judgment of quality; * marks a paper without an abstract, compared by its title. The sentence under a paper is written by an AI from the two abstracts: check it in the papers. A paper marked not relevant by three readers leaves the list.

Updated on 6 November 2026.

The illustrated guide to the papers around a paper

The previous summary was created more than a year ago and can be re-run (if necessary) by clicking on the Run button below.

Disclaimer: The AI-based summarization tool and virtual assistant provided on this website may not always provide accurate and complete summaries or responses. We encourage you to carefully review and evaluate the generated content to ensure its quality and relevance to your needs.