Giant planets and brown dwarf companions: the papers compared side by side

A real example: what you get

5 papers compared on 5 columns.

• Columns: Question, Method, Data, Main results, Limitations
• 25 of the 25 cells with their passage of the paper
• 3 points where they agree
• 4 points where they disagree
• 5 questions none of them addresses
• Cells you correct by hand, CSV export, a chat with the papers

The first results

1. Combining TTVs, RVs, and astrometry to characterize distant giant companions of transiting hot Jupiters: Application to WASP-4 Question: Characterize the distant giant companion WASP-4 c and determine whether the transit-timing behavior of WASP-4 b indicates orbital decay.
2. The COBREX archival survey: improved constraints on the occurrence rate of wide-orbit substellar companions. I. A uniform re-analysis of 400 stars from the GPIES survey Question: Improve direct-imaging sensitivity and constrain the occurrence of wide-orbit giant planets and brown dwarf companions through a uniform archival reanalysis.
3. A Model to Map Brown Dwarf Companions to White Dwarfs in Partial Secondary Eclipse Question: Determine whether partial secondary eclipses can reveal spatial emission patterns on brown dwarf companions to white dwarfs, including latitude-dependent atmospheric circulation.
4. Expanding the Volatile Abundance Inventory for High-Priority K-Dwarf JWST Exoplanet Systems Question: Measure carbon and oxygen elemental and isotopic abundances in six K-dwarf exoplanet hosts to establish chemical reference points for planetary atmospheric studies.
5. The anomalously large transiting planet around Boyajian's star: evidence for a circumplanetary ring Question: Test whether a circumplanetary ring can explain the apparently oversized giant-planet candidate around Boyajian’s star without requiring an anomalously large planetary radius.

See a complete example, explained step by step →