From the weekly letter · 16 November 2026

Why cover this story this week?

Favoritism with a competitive purpose

A sympathetic judge might simply appreciate a compatriot’s style. A strategic judge would also consider whom that athlete needs to beat. A new figure-skating preprint finds patterns consistent with the latter: judges award a compatriot premium while penalizing close rivals, and the rival penalty grows with the compatriot’s placement chances before fading when she falls out of contention.

The researchers use judging data and variation in a randomly drawn start order. The compatriot premium declines along that order; before 2022/23, it also increases when close rivals have judges of their own nationality on the panel. A counterfactual analysis suggests these biases can alter close competitions. The broader lesson concerns expert panels everywhere: favoritism may depend not just on personal ties, but on the competitive situation in which experts make their decisions.

Editorial context written by AI from abstracts, not independent scientific validation. The kit and its verified quotes rely on the source paper, not on this letter.

Read the full letter →

Talk about a paper in public without overstating it: yours, one you are asked to comment on, or one you write about as a journalist.

  • Your paper: a draft release for your press office, the questions journalists will ask with what the paper lets you answer, the likely misreadings, a lay summary and a short thread.
  • Asked to comment: what the paper shows and does not, its strengths and weaknesses with their passages, and what would settle its main claim.
  • Writing about it as a journalist: reporting angles, the wording to check before publication, and the questions to ask the authors.
  • For everyone: findings with their passages checked word for word, the novelty set against the closest earlier papers, a hype check, figures with their credit, and researchers for an outside view who have not signed with the authors.

Discover Premium+ See an example kit