Saturn's Interior After the Cassini Grand Finale

Authors: J. J. Fortney, B. Militzer, C. R. Mankovich, R. Helled, S. M. Wahl, N. Nettelmann, W. B. Hubbard, D. J. Stevenson, L. Iess, M. S. Marley, N. Movshovitz

arXiv: 2304.09215v1 - DOI (astro-ph.EP)
Submitted to arXiv on 18 Apr. 2023
License: CC BY 4.0
Abstract

We present a review of Saturn's interior structure and thermal evolution, with a particular focus on work in the past 5 years. Data from the Cassini mission, including a precise determination of the gravity field from the Grand Finale orbits, and the still ongoing identification of ring wave features in Saturn's C-ring tied to seismic modes in the planet, have led to dramatic advances in our understanding of Saturn's structure. Models that match the gravity field suggest that differential rotation, as seen in the visible atmosphere, extends down to at least a depth of 10,000 km (1/6$^{\rm th}$ the planet's radius). At greater depths, a variety of different investigations all now point to a deep Saturn rotation rate of 10 hours and 33 minutes. There is very compelling evidence for a central heavy element concentration (``core''), that in most recent models is 12-20 Earth masses. Ring seismology strongly suggests that the core is not entirely compact, but is dilute (mixed in with the overlying H/He), and has a substantial radial extent, perhaps out to around one-half of the planet's radius. A wide range of thermal evolution scenarios can match the planet's current luminosity, with progress on better quantifying the helium rain scenario hampered by Saturn's poorly known atmospheric helium abundance. We discuss the relevance of magnetic field data on understanding the planet's current interior structure. We point towards additional future work that combines seismology and gravity within a framework that includes differential rotation, and the utility of a Saturn entry probe.

The papers around it, by date and closeness

Higher is closer to this paper; left is older. Lines join papers close to each other: groups of lines are sub-topics. Select a point to see why it is there. Back to the summary of this paper

How to read this map? Illustrated guide

Closest papers Prior work it builds on Papers that cite it

Papers around this one

Ranked by how close their title and abstract are to this paper’s. Select some to read them together.

Closest papers

  1. Very close Cited by this paper Used in depth by this paper A method it uses
    Understanding Saturn’s interior from the Cassini Grand Finale gravity measurements
    Dong-Dong Ni · 2020 · Astronomy & Astrophysics · cited 13 times · Not summarized yet
    Abstract

    Context. Measurements of Saturn’s gravity field by Cassini Grand Finale have been acquired with high precision. It has been demonstrated that the even gravitational harmonics J6–J10 have larger absolute values than the predictions by typical rigid-body interior models. A four-layer structure model, proposed to interpret Juno’s gravity measurements for Jupiter, has been applied to Saturn, but great attention was paid to the depth of zonal flows in order to interpret the large absolute values of J6–J10. Aims. We aim to understand the internal structure and interior composition of Saturn with a similar model for Jupiter. The additional uncertainties in Saturn’s structure and composition are inv…

  2. Very close Cited by this paper Used in depth by this paper A method it uses
    A diffuse core in Saturn revealed by ring seismology
    C. Mankovich, J. Fuller · 2021 · Nature Astronomy · cited 114 times · Not summarized yet
    Abstract

    The best constraints on the internal structures of giant planets have historically originated from measurements of their gravity fields1–3. These data are inherently mostly sensitive to a planet’s outer regions, stymieing efforts to measure the mass and compactness of the cores of Jupiter2,4,5 and Saturn6,7. However, studies of Saturn’s rings have detected waves driven by pulsation modes within the planet8–11, offering independent seismic probes of Saturn’s interior12–14. The observations reveal gravity-mode pulsations, which indicate that part of Saturn’s deep interior is stable against convection13. Here, we compare structural models with gravity and seismic measurements from Cassini to sh…

  3. Very close Cited by this paper Used in depth by this paper A method it uses
    Models of Saturn's Interior Constructed with an Accelerated Concentric Maclaurin Spheroid Method
    B. Militzer, S. Wahl, W. Hubbard · 2019 · Astrophysical Journal · cited 66 times · Not summarized yet
    Abstract

    The Cassini spacecraft’s Grand Finale orbits provided a unique opportunity to probe Saturn’s gravity field and interior structure. Doppler measurements yielded unexpectedly large values for the gravity harmonics J6, J8, and J10, which cannot be matched using planetary interior models that assume uniform rotation. Instead we present a suite of models that assume the planet’s interior rotates on cylinders, which allows us to match all the observed even gravity harmonics. For every interior model, the gravity field is calculated self-consistently with high precision using the Concentric Maclaurin Spheroid method. We present an acceleration technique for this method, which drastically reduces th…

  4. Very close Cited by this paper
    Saturn’s Probable Interior: An Exploration of Saturn’s Potential Interior Density Structures
    N. Movshovitz, J. Fortney, C. Mankovich et al. · 2019 · Astrophysical Journal · cited 36 times · Not summarized yet
    Abstract

    The gravity field of a giant planet is typically our best window into its interior structure and composition. Through comparison of a model planet’s calculated gravitational potential with the observed potential, inferences can be made about interior quantities, including possible composition and the existence of a core. Necessarily, a host of assumptions go into such calculations, making every inference about a giant planet’s structure strongly model dependent. In this work, we present a more general picture by setting Saturn’s gravity field, as measured during the Cassini Grand Finale, as a likelihood function driving a Markov Chain Monte Carlo exploration of the possible interior density …

  5. Very close Cited by this paper
    Cassini Ring Seismology as a Probe of Saturn’s Interior. I. Rigid Rotation
    C. Mankovich, M. Marley, J. Fortney et al. · 2018 · Astrophysical Journal · cited 87 times · Not summarized yet
    Abstract

    Seismology of the gas giants holds the potential to resolve long-standing questions about their internal structure and rotation state. We construct a family of Saturn interior models constrained by the gravity field and compute their adiabatic mode eigenfrequencies and corresponding Lindblad and vertical resonances in Saturn’s C ring, where more than 20 waves with pattern speeds faster than the ring mean motion have been detected and characterized using high-resolution Cassini Visual and Infrared Mapping Spectrometer stellar occultation data. We present identifications of the fundamental modes of Saturn that appear to be the origin of these observed ring waves, and we use their observed patt…

  6. Very close Cited by this paper
    Saturn's Deep Atmospheric Flows Revealed by the Cassini Grand Finale Gravity Measurements
    E. Galanti, Y. Kaspi, Y. Miguel et al. · 2019 · Geophysical Research Letters · cited 67 times · Not summarized yet
    Abstract

    How deep do Saturn's zonal winds penetrate below the cloud level has been a decades‐long question, with important implications not only for the atmospheric dynamics but also for the interior density structure, composition, magnetic field, and core mass. The Cassini Grand Finale gravity experiment enables answering this question for the first time, with the premise that the planet's gravity harmonics are affected not only by the rigid body density structure but also by its flow field. Using a wide range of rigid body interior models and an adjoint based optimization for the flow field using thermal wind balance, we calculate the flow structure below the cloud level and its depth. We find that…

  7. Very close Cited by this paper Used in depth by this paper
    Saturn ring seismology: Evidence for stable stratification in the deep interior of Saturn
    J. Fuller · 2014 · Icarus · cited 112 times · Not summarized yet
    Abstract

    Abstract Seismology allows for direct observational constraints on the interior structures of stars and planets. Recent observations of Saturn’s ring system have revealed the presence of density waves within the rings excited by oscillation modes within Saturn, allowing for precise measurements of a limited set of the planet’s mode frequencies. We construct interior structure models of Saturn, compute the corresponding mode frequencies, and compare them with the observed mode frequencies. The fundamental mode frequencies of our models match the observed frequencies (of the largest amplitude waves) to an accuracy of ∼1%, confirming that these waves are indeed excited by Saturn’s f-modes. The …

  8. Very close Cited by this paper A method it uses
    Empirical models of pressure and density in Saturn's interior: Implications for the helium concentration, its depth dependence, and Saturn's precession rate
    R. Helled, G. Schubert, J. Anderson · 2008 · Icarus · cited 30 times · Not summarized yet
    Abstract

    Abstract We present ‘empirical’ models (pressure vs. density) of Saturn's interior constrained by the gravitational coefficients J 2 , J 4 , and J 6 for different assumed rotation rates of the planet. The empirical pressure–density profile is interpreted in terms of a hydrogen and helium physical equation of state to deduce the hydrogen to helium ratio in Saturn and to constrain the depth dependence of helium and heavy element abundances. The planet's internal structure (pressure vs. density) and composition are found to be insensitive to the assumed rotation rate for periods between 10h:32m:35s and 10h:41m:35s. We find that helium is depleted in the upper envelope, while in the high pressur…

Prior work it builds on

  1. Close Used in depth by this paper A method it uses
    Evidence for a Dichotomy in the Interior Structures of Jupiter and Saturn from Helium Phase Separation
    C. Mankovich, J. Fortney · 2019 · Astrophysical Journal · cited 53 times · Not summarized yet
    Abstract

    We examine the comparative thermal evolution of Jupiter and Saturn, applying recent theoretical results for helium’s immiscibility in fluid metallic hydrogen. The redistribution of helium in their interiors proceeds very differently for the two planets. We confirm that, based on Jupiter’s atmospheric helium depletion as observed in situ by the Galileo entry probe, Jupiter’s interior helium has differentiated modestly, and we present models reconciling Jupiter’s helium depletion, radius, and heat flow at the solar age. Jupiter’s recently revised Bond albedo implies a higher intrinsic flux for the planet, accommodating more luminosity from helium differentiation, such that mildly superadiabati…

  2. Close Used in depth by this paper A method it uses
    The Concentric Maclaurin Spheroid method with tides and a rotational enhancement of Saturn's tidal response
    S. Wahl, W. Hubbard, B. Militzer · 2016 · Icarus · cited 32 times · Not summarized yet
    Abstract

    Abstract We extend to three dimensions the Concentric Maclaurin Spheroid method for obtaining the self-consistent shape and gravitational field of a rotating liquid planet, to include a tidal potential from a satellite. We exhibit, for the first time, an important effect of the planetary rotation rate on tidal response of gas giants, whose shape is dominated by the centrifugal potential from rapid rotation. Simulations of planets with fast rotation rates like those of Jupiter and Saturn, exhibit significant changes in calculated tidal love numbers knm when compared with non-rotating bodies. A test model of Saturn fitted to observed zonal gravitational multipole harmonics yields k 2 = 0.413 ,…

  3. Close A method it uses
    A COMPARISON OF THE INTERIORS OF JUPITER AND SATURN
    T. Guillot · 1999 · Planetary and Space Science · cited 259 times · Not summarized yet
    Abstract

    Abstract Interior models of Jupiter and Saturn are calculated and compared in the framework of the three-layer assumption, which rely on the perception that both planets consist of three globally homogeneous regions: a dense core, a metallic hydrogen envelope, and a molecular hydrogen envelope. Within this framework, constraints on the core mass and abundance of heavy elements (i.e. elements other than hydrogen and helium) are given by accounting for uncertainties on the measured gravitational moments, surface temperature, surface helium abundance, and on the inferred protosolar helium abundance, equations of state, temperature profile and solid/differential interior rotation. Results obtain…

  4. Close* Used in depth by this paper A method it uses
    H/He demixing and the cooling behavior of Saturn
    Robert Püstow, N. Nettelmann, W. Lorenzen et al. · 2016 · Icarus · cited 47 times · Not summarized yet
  5. Close
    Kronoseismology III: Waves in Saturn’s inner C ring
    R. French, C. McGhee-French, P. Nicholson et al. · 2019 · Icarus (New York, N.Y. 1962) · cited 29 times · Not summarized yet
    Abstract

    Abstract We investigate waves driven in Saturn’s rings by planetary normal modes, concentrating on the previously unexplored inner C ring. In this region, the known waves all have exceptionally short wavelengths, which has proven problematic for previous studies that depended on the accurate estimate of wave phases for wave identification. However, detailed study of over 200 stellar and radio occultations observed by Cassini, involving measurements of ∼ 65 circular ring features, has resulted in a radius scale for the rings which has absolute errors of ∼ 250 m and internal (relative) uncertainties of ∼ 150 m (French et al., 2017). This permits us to measure the phases of waves with wavelengt…

Papers that cite it

  1. Close
    The Fuzzy Cores of Jupiter and Saturn
    R. Helled, David J. Stevenson · 2024 · AGU Advances · cited 10 times · Not summarized yet
    Abstract

    New interior models of Jupiter and Saturn suggest that both planets have “fuzzy cores.” These cores should be viewed as central regions that are enriched with heavy elements but are not distinct from the rest of the deep interior. These cores may contain large amounts of hydrogen and helium though small pure heavy‐element cores may also exist. New measurements along with advanced planetary modeling have revolutionized the way we think about the interiors of giant planets and provide important constraints for planet formation and evolution theories. These developments are also relevant for the characterization of giant exoplanets.

  2. Related Uses this paper in depth
    Atmospheric Helium Abundances in the Giant Planets
    N. Nettelmann, Marina Cano Amoros, N. Tosi et al. · 2024 · Space Science Reviews · cited 3 times · Not summarized yet
    Abstract

    Noble gases are accreted to the giant planets as part of the gas component of the planet-forming disk. While heavier noble gases can separate from the evolution of the hydrogen-rich gas, helium is thought to remain at the protosolar H/He ratio Yproto∼0.27\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$Y_{\mathrm{proto}}\sim 0.27$\end{document}–0.28. However, spacecraft observations revealed a depletion in helium in the atmospheres of Jupiter, Saturn, and Uranus. For the gas giants, this is commonly seen as indicat…

  3. Related
    Hydrogen-helium immiscibility boundary in gas-giant planetary interiors from machine-learning molecular dynamics
    Xiao-Yu Wang, Sebastien Hamel, Bing-Qing Cheng · 2026 · Nature Communications · Not summarized yet
    Abstract

    The location of the hydrogen-helium (H/He) immiscibility boundary controls whether and where helium rain occurs in giant planets, yet it remains uncertain because high-pressure experiments are challenging and ab initio simulations are limited in system size and simulation time. We map this boundary by computing composition-dependent chemical potentials from large-scale molecular dynamics driven by machine learning potentials trained on three density functional approximations (PBE, vdW-DF, and the hybrid HSE). Across the pressure range of 100-1000 GPa, the demixing temperatures are typically ~ 2000 K lower than previous ab initio simulations using small system sizes, and this discrepancy is l…

  4. Related
    Role of partial stable stratification on the onset of rotating magnetoconvection with a uniform vertical field
    Tirtharaj Barman, S. Sahoo · 2025 · Not summarized yet
    Abstract

    This study examines the onset of rotating magnetoconvection under an axially imposed magnetic field in the presence of partial thermal stable stratification. Three stratification models-fully unstable, weakly stable, and strongly stable-are analyzed across Ekman numbers $E = 10^{-3}, 10^{-4}$, and $10^{-5}$ (rotation rates) and Roberts numbers $q = 0.01, 1$ and $10$ (diffusivity ratios). Magnetic back-reaction is explored by varying the Elsasser number ($\Lambda$) from 0 to 10. Symmetry-breaking effects of stable layer are assessed via an asymmetry index. Additionally, local scaling laws are derived for onset parameters and convective penetration is quantified numerically. Results show that …

How are these papers found?

We compare the title and abstract of this paper with those of every paper summarized on this site, and with the papers Semantic Scholar recommends, those it cites and those citing it (for a much-cited paper, its most recent citations and, from OpenAlex, the most cited ones). Among the prior work and the follow-ups, the papers that use each other in depth, a method it uses and the much-cited follow-ups come a little higher. The levels (very close, close, related) come from the similarity of the texts, not from a judgment of quality; * marks a paper without an abstract, compared by its title. The sentence under a paper is written by an AI from the two abstracts: check it in the papers. A paper marked not relevant by three readers leaves the list.

Updated on 6 November 2026.

The illustrated guide to the papers around a paper