Dissolving the Fermi Paradox
Authors: Anders Sandberg, Eric Drexler, Toby Ord
Abstract
The Fermi paradox is the conflict between an expectation of a high {\em ex ante} probability of intelligent life elsewhere in the universe and the apparently lifeless universe we in fact observe. The expectation that the universe should be teeming with intelligent life is linked to models like the Drake equation, which suggest that even if the probability of intelligent life developing at a given site is small, the sheer multitude of possible sites should nonetheless yield a large number of potentially observable civilizations. We show that this conflict arises from the use of Drake-like equations, which implicitly assume certainty regarding highly uncertain parameters. We examine these parameters, incorporating models of chemical and genetic transitions on paths to the origin of life, and show that extant scientific knowledge corresponds to uncertainties that span multiple orders of magnitude. This makes a stark difference. When the model is recast to represent realistic distributions of uncertainty, we find a substantial {\em ex ante} probability of there being no other intelligent life in our observable universe, and thus that there should be little surprise when we fail to detect any signs of it. This result dissolves the Fermi paradox, and in doing so removes any need to invoke speculative mechanisms by which civilizations would inevitably fail to have observable effects upon the universe.
The papers around it, by date and closeness
Higher is closer to this paper; left is older. Lines join papers close to each other: groups of lines are sub-topics. Select a point to see why it is there. Back to the summary of this paper
Papers around this one
Ranked by how close their title and abstract are to this paper’s. Select some to read them together.
Closest papers
-
A joint analysis of the Drake equation and the Fermi paradoxN. Prantzos · 2013 · International Journal of Astrobiology · cited 36 times · Not summarized yet
A joint analysis locates conditions under which the Drake equation and the Fermi paradox hold, while this paper asks whether parameter uncertainty dissolves the paradox.
Abstract
Abstract I propose a unified framework for a joint analysis of the Drake equation and the Fermi paradox, which enables a simultaneous, quantitative study of both of them. The analysis is based on a simplified form of the Drake equation and on a fairly simple scheme for the colonization of the Milky Way. It appears that for sufficiently long-lived civilizations, colonization of the Galaxy is the only reasonable option to gain knowledge about other life forms. This argument allows one to define a region in the parameter space of the Drake equation, where the Fermi paradox definitely holds (‘Strong Fermi paradox’).
-
The Fermi Paradox and the Great Filter: Evaluating Possible Barriers to the Emergence and Survival of Intelligent CivilisationsCharvi Handa, Raghu Raja Mehra · 2026 · International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR) · Not summarized yet
The review surveys the Fermi paradox and evaluates the Great Filter as a proposed resolution, whereas this paper resolves it through uncertainty in Drake-equation parameters.
Abstract
: The galaxy contains hundreds of billions of stars, most of them older than the Sun, and a large fraction are now known to host planets. Even a slow programme of interstellar expansion should have carried a single civilisation across the galaxy in a few tens of millions of years-a short interval on cosmic timescales. Yet no confirmed sign of any other technological civilisation has ever been detected. This contradiction between reasonable expectation and observed silence is the Fermi Paradox. This paper reviews the paradox and evaluates one of its most influential proposed resolutions: the Great Filter hypothesis, which argues that at least one step on the path from lifeless matter to a lon…
-
Life Before Fermi - Back to the Solar SystemD. Clements · 2018 · arXiv: Earth and Planetary Astrophysics · preprint, not peer reviewed · cited 1 time · Not summarized yet
The review examines requirements for life and potential habitats in the Solar System, broadening the astrobiological context for questions about extraterrestrial life.
Abstract
The existence of intelligent, interstellar traveling and colonising life is a key assumption behind the Fermi Paradox. Until recently, detecting signs of life elsewhere has been so technically challenging as to seem almost impossible. However, new observational insights and other developments mean that signs of life elsewhere might realistically be uncovered in the next decade or two. We here review what are believed to be the basic requirements for life, the history of life on Earth, and then apply this knowledge to potential sites for life in our own Solar System. We conclude that the necessities of life - liquid water and sources of energy - are in fact quite common in the Solar System, b…
-
Formulation and Resolutions of the Red Sky ParadoxDavid Kipping · 2021 · PNAS 118 (2021) e2026808118 · cited 8 times · AI summary available
The paper formulates a Bayesian version of the Red Sky paradox about observers around Sun-like stars, applying probability reasoning to a different cosmic puzzle.
Abstract
Most stars in the Universe are red dwarfs. They outnumber stars like our Sun by a factor of 5 and outlive them by another factor of 20 (population-weighted mean). When combined with recent observations uncovering an abundance of temperate, rocky planets around these diminutive stars, we're faced with an apparent logical contradiction - why don't we see a red dwarf in our sky? To address this "Red Sky paradox", we formulate a Bayesian probability function concerning the odds of finding oneself around a F/G/K-spectral type (Sun-like) star. If the development of intelligent life from prebiotic chemistry is a universally rapid and ensured process, the temporal advantage of red dwarfs dissolves s…
-
Implications of the Pessimistic Lower Limit on the Drake EquationM. Baak, H. Snoek · 2026 · Not summarized yet
The paper examines how Earth’s observed life informs Drake-equation estimates, addressing uncertainty about life elsewhere that this paper also analyzes.
Abstract
The observation of life on Earth is generally accepted to be uninformative concerning the probability of life on other Earth-like planets, a belief first formalized by Brandon Carter and based on the selection effect of our existence. In a similar way, the Drake equation is either presented as estimate of the total number of active, communicative, extraterrestrial civilizations in our Galaxy ($n^g_{\rm civ}$), i.e. excluding humanity, or humanity is included in the estimate but judged to be an uninformative data point. Daniel Whitmire has recently challenged the Carter abiogenesis argument, claiming the logic behind it is flawed, as the conditional likelihoods used by Carter in Bayes'theorem…
-
Artificial versus biological intelligence in the Cosmos: clues from a stochastic analysis of the Drake equationA. De Visscher · 2020 · International Journal of Astrobiology · cited 5 times · Not summarized yet
The stochastic analysis applies uncertainty-aware Drake-equation modeling to compare artificial and biological intelligence, rather than estimating whether other civilizations exist.
Abstract
Abstract The Drake equation has been used many times to estimate the number of observable civilizations in the galaxy. However, the uncertainty of the outcome is so great that any individual result is of limited use, as predictions can range from a handful of observable civilizations in the observable universe to tens of millions per Milky Way-sized galaxy. A statistical investigation shows that the Drake equation, despite its uncertainties, delivers robust predictions of the likelihood that the prevalent form of intelligence in the universe is artificial rather than biological. The likelihood of artificial intelligence far exceeds the likelihood of biological intelligence in all cases inves…
-
Searching for a standard Drake equationM. Molina, José Antonio · 2019 · arXiv: Popular Physics · preprint, not peer reviewed · cited 2 times · Not summarized yet
The paper revises the Drake equation’s formulation for estimating extraterrestrial civilizations, the model whose uncertain parameters this paper examines.
Abstract
In the 20th century the scientific search for extraterrestrial intelligence began, and the Drake equation was proposed to estimate the number of extraterrestrial species humanity could attempt to detect, N. This paper discusses the need to update and standardize this equation. A new and more accurate expression is deduced which contains the classic equation as a particular case, and its advantages are discussed. A necessary condition is also stated for its use in scientific contexts: if N is defined as the total number of civilizations like ours then N = 1, given that we exist, and consequently the working hypothesis of the SETI project can be expressed as N>1. In this case, the Drake equati…
-
A numerical testbed for hypotheses of extraterrestrial life and intelligenceD. Forgan · 2008 · International Journal of Astrobiology · cited 43 times · Not summarized yet
The numerical testbed uses Monte Carlo realizations of stellar, planetary, and biological variation to study extraterrestrial intelligence, rather than modeling uncertain transitions analytically.
Abstract
Abstract The search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI) has been heavily influenced by solutions to the Drake Equation, which returns an integer value for the number of communicating civilizations resident in the Milky Way, and by the Fermi Paradox, glibly stated as: ‘If they are there, where are they?’. Both rely on using average values of key parameters, such as the mean signal lifetime of a communicating civilization. A more accurate answer must take into account the distribution of stellar, planetary and biological attributes in the galaxy, as well as the stochastic nature of evolution itself. This paper outlines a method of Monte Carlo realization that does this, and hence allows a…
Prior work it builds on
-
The Log Log Prior for the Frequency of Extraterrestrial IntelligencesB. Lacki · 2016 · arXiv: Earth and Planetary Astrophysics · preprint, not peer reviewed · cited 11 times · Not summarized yet
The paper assigns a Bayesian prior to the frequency of extraterrestrial intelligence, addressing uncertainty in how often intelligence arises.
Abstract
It is unclear how frequently life and intelligence arise on planets. I consider a Bayesian prior for the probability P(ETI) that intelligence evolves at a suitable site, with weight distributed evenly over ln(1 - ln P(ETI)). This log log prior can handle a very wide range of P(ETI) values, from 1 to 10^(-10^122), while remaining responsive to evidence about extraterrestrial societies. It is motivated by our uncertainty in the number of conditions that must be fulfilled for intelligence to arise, and it is related to considerations of information, entropy, and state space dimensionality. After setting a lower limit to P(ETI) from the number of possible genome sequences, I calculate a Bayesian…
-
Where is everybody? an account of Fermi's questionE. M. Jones · 1985 · cited 59 times · Not summarized yet
The account discusses Fermi’s question about absent extraterrestrial civilizations, the paradox this paper aims to dissolve.
-
THE Ĝ INFRARED SEARCH FOR EXTRATERRESTRIAL CIVILIZATIONS WITH LARGE ENERGY SUPPLIES. I. BACKGROUND AND JUSTIFICATIONJ. Wright, B. Mullan, S. Sigurdsson et al. · 2014 · The Astrophysical Journal · cited 92 times · Not summarized yet
The paper motivates infrared searches for alien energy use and discusses arguments about galaxy-spanning civilizations, addressing observational silence through SETI context.
Abstract
We motivate the Ĝ infrared search for extraterrestrial civilizations with large energy supplies. We discuss some philosophical difficulties of the search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI), and how communication SETI circumvents them. We review “Dysonian SETI,” the search for artifacts of alien civilizations, and find that it is highly complementary to traditional communication SETI; the two together might succeed where either one alone has not. We discuss the argument of Hart that spacefaring life in the Milky Way should be either galaxy-spanning or non-existent, and examine a portion of his argument that we call the “monocultural fallacy.” We discuss some rebuttals to Hart that invok…
-
Bayesian analysis of the astrobiological implications of life’s early emergence on EarthD. Spiegel, E. Turner · 2011 · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America · cited 107 times · Not summarized yet
The Bayesian analysis estimates abiogenesis probability from life’s early emergence on Earth, using probabilistic reasoning about a key uncertain transition.
Abstract
Life arose on Earth sometime in the first few hundred million years after the young planet had cooled to the point that it could support water-based organisms on its surface. The early emergence of life on Earth has been taken as evidence that the probability of abiogenesis is high, if starting from young Earth-like conditions. We revisit this argument quantitatively in a Bayesian statistical framework. By constructing a simple model of the probability of abiogenesis, we calculate a Bayesian estimate of its posterior probability, given the data that life emerged fairly early in Earth’s history and that, billions of years later, curious creatures noted this fact and considered its implication…
-
Scintillation-induced Intermittency in SETIJ. Cordes, T. J. Lazio, C. Sagan · 1997 · The Astrophysical Journal · cited 66 times · Not summarized yet
The study models how interstellar scintillation affects detection and redetection of alien radio signals, a factor relevant to interpreting SETI’s silence.
Abstract
We use scattering theory, simulations, and empirical constraints on interstellar scintillations to discuss the intermittency of radio signals from extraterrestrial intelligence (ETI). The number of ETI sources in the Galaxy has a direct influence on the expected dynamic range of fluxes in a survey, through inverse square-law effects and, equally importantly, by the number of independent statistical trials made on modulations caused by interstellar scintillations. We demonstrate that scintillations are very likely to allow initial detections of narrowband signals, while making redetections extremely improbable, a result that follows from the skewed, exponential distribution of the modulation.…
Papers that cite it
-
Quantifying the information impact of future searches for exoplanetary biosignaturesA. Balbi, C. Grimaldi · 2020 · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America · cited 12 times · Not summarized yet
The paper uses Bayesian analysis to assess what biosignature detections or non-detections reveal about life’s prevalence beyond Earth.
Abstract
Significance The search for life on extrasolar worlds by way of spectroscopic biosignature detection is among the most compelling scientific endeavors of the next decades. This article explores the implications of either discovering or ruling out the presence of detectable biosignatures on planets within a few tens of light years from Earth, a distance within reach of future searches. Using a Bayesian methodology, we show that not detecting biosignatures in such sample volume would bring no added information about the galactic population of life-hosting exoplanets. Conversely, if life arose independently on other planets, even a single detection would imply exobiospheres to be more abundant …
-
Space, the final frontier: In the scientific pursuit of extraterrestrial life away from EarthZion Elani · 2020 · Physics essays · cited 1 time · Not summarized yet
The article surveys the search for extraterrestrial life and intelligence, including SETI and why aliens have not been encountered.
Abstract
For decades we have been searching for an answer to the knotty question, “do aliens exist?.” Other questions in line are: “where are they?,” “are they like us, sophisticated intelligent beings?” or “do they exist in the form of simpler lifeforms?,” “Have they ever visited us?,” “Why haven't we encountered them yet?,” “or have we?” To satiate this curiosity, astrophysicists and astronomers have come up with innumerable theories and ideas, engaged in building facilities and institutes and come up with a planet-wide effort for the search of extraterrestrial intelligence — SETI @ home. This article will take a ride through time, from the first documented idea to look for extraterrestrial beings …
-
On the Likelihood of Observing Extragalactic Civilizations: Predictions from the Self-Indication AssumptionS. Olson · 2020 · arXiv: Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics · preprint, not peer reviewed · cited 3 times · Not summarized yet
The paper estimates the likelihood of observing expanding extragalactic civilizations under anthropic assumptions, addressing the chance of detectable extraterrestrial life.
Abstract
Ambitious civilizations that expand for resources at an intergalactic scale could be observable from a cosmological distance, but how likely is one to be visible to us? The question comes down to estimating the appearance rate of such things in the cosmos --- a radically uncertain quantity. Despite this prior uncertainty, anthropic considerations give rise to Bayesian updates, and thus predictions. The Self-Sampling Assumption (SSA), a school of anthropic probability, has previously been used for this purpose. Here, we derive predictions from the alternative school, the Self-Indication Assumption (SIA), and point out its features. SIA favors a higher appearance rate of expansionistic life, b…
-
Emergence of life in an inflationary universeT. Totani · 2019 · Scientific Reports · cited 18 times · Not summarized yet
The paper considers whether life could emerge in an enormous universe despite low local abiogenesis odds, providing context on cosmic scale and life’s rarity.
Abstract
Abiotic emergence of ordered information stored in the form of RNA is an important unresolved problem concerning the origin of life. A polymer longer than 40–100 nucleotides is necessary to expect a self-replicating activity, but the formation of such a long polymer having a correct nucleotide sequence by random reactions seems statistically unlikely. However, our universe, created by a single inflation event, likely includes more than 10100 Sun-like stars. If life can emerge at least once in such a large volume, it is not in contradiction with our observations of life on Earth, even if the expected number of abiogenesis events is negligibly small within the observable universe that contains…
-
Is Everyone Probably Elsewhere?Jakob Stoustrup, H. Schiøler, P. Hjorth · 2023 · Journal for General Philosophy of Science, Zeitschrift für allgemeine Wissenschaftstheorie · Not summarized yet
The paper uses observer bias to assess whether other universes exist, extending anthropic probability questions beyond extraterrestrial civilizations.
Abstract
It has been widely discussed whether the existence of other universes than the known universe is a purely metaphysical consideration. This paper argues to the contrary that the existence of other universes is a meaningful hypothesis, which can be tested based on observable data. The paper applies the perspective of observer bias as an approach for assigning probabilities to the mutually excluding hypotheses of universe vs. multiverse, i.e., whether the known universe is the only universe, or just one universe in an ensemble of universes, a so-called multiverse. The basic idea of the paper relies on the following consideration. In a multiverse, the vast majority of observers would live in uni…
Go further
How are these papers found?
We compare the title and abstract of this paper with those of every paper summarized on this site, and with the papers Semantic Scholar recommends, those it cites and those citing it (for a much-cited paper, its most recent citations and, from OpenAlex, the most cited ones). Among the prior work and the follow-ups, the papers that use each other in depth, a method it uses and the much-cited follow-ups come a little higher. The levels (very close, close, related) come from the similarity of the texts, not from a judgment of quality; * marks a paper without an abstract, compared by its title. The sentence under a paper is written by an AI from the two abstracts: check it in the papers. A paper marked not relevant by three readers leaves the list.
Updated on 6 November 2026.