Running summarizing tools on a new article

Check the paper below, then start its synthesis.


Environmental fate and ecotoxicological parameters differentiate between low-risk pesticides, candidates for substitution and conventional chemicals

Sofia Tsaloumi (University of Thessaly), Mark Swaine (University of Thessaly), Aggeliki D. Tsaboula (Aristotle University of Thessaloniki), Zisis Vryzas (Aristotle University of Thessaloniki), Dimitrios Georgios Karpouzas (University of Thessaly)

Environmental Sciences Europe
DOI: 10.1186/s12302-025-01247-x (Environmental Science)
License: CC BY-NC-ND

Abstract: The European Union (EU) promotes the use of plant protection products with lower environmental and human health risks. Low-risk active substances (LRAS) are proposed as alternatives to conventional synthetic chemical compounds (ScC) and substances considered candidates for substitution (CfS). However, we are still lacking solid science-based evidence for assigning pesticide compounds into these categories. We aimed to identify whether specific data used in environmental risk assessment can be used as effective descriptors of the three different pesticide categories. To achieve this, we conducted a meta-analysis based on environmental fate (DT 50 soil and water/sediment) and ecotoxicological data (EC₅₀ and LC₅₀ values for algae, higher plant, aquatic invertebrate and fish) collected from peer-reviewed regulatory documentation of chemical pesticide active substances currently approved in the EU. Our meta-analysis showed that LRAS exhibited the shortest median DT 50 values in soil (1.78 days) and water/sediment (7.23 days) and the highest median toxicity thresholds for aquatic organisms, particularly for P. subcapitata (EC 50 = 10.3 mg/L) and L. gibba (EC 50 = 100 mg/L), compared to ScC (DT 50 19.74 days, EC 50 1.094 mg/L and 1.1 mg/L) and CfS (DT 50 80.93 days, EC 50 0.147 mg/L and 0.154 mg/L). The latter showed significantly higher persistence and ecotoxicity from LRAS and ScC in most cases supporting the regulatory decision for withdrawal from the EU market. Overall ecotoxicological threshold values like EC 50 values for algae and aquatic plants were good indicators distinguishing LRAS with conventional chemical compounds (ScC and CfS). Our findings constitute a first significant step that upon enrichment with more input data on LRAS, as more products from this group are coming in the market, and chronic ecotoxicity threshold values could establish a set of indicators that could support early-stage identification of new LRAS and extend to prioritize pesticide authorizations, streamline renewal or amendment procedures with reduced data requirements, and facilitate extension requests for existing approvals by focusing on LRAS.

Published on 21 Nov. 2025