Results of the summarizing process for the arXiv paper: quant-ph/0206089v2

In this critical review of the book 'A New Kind of Science' by Stephen Wolfram, author Scott Aaronson provides a comprehensive analysis focusing on two main areas: computational complexity and fundamental physics. Rather than providing a chapter-by-chapter evaluation, Aaronson examines Wolfram's ideas using standard techniques in theoretical computer science. In terms of computational complexity, Aaronson addresses some of the questions raised by Wolfram. He analyzes the complexity of Wolfram's proposed models and investigates their implications for computation. By applying established techniques in theoretical computer science, Aaronson provides a critical assessment of the feasibility and validity of Wolfram's claims. Moving on to fundamental physics, Aaronson delves into Wolfram's proposal for a deterministic model underlying quantum mechanics. However, he demonstrates that this model cannot be reconciled with both special relativity and Bell inequality violation. Through a rigorous examination of the physics involved, he highlights the inconsistencies and limitations of Wolfram's proposition. Overall, this review offers an in-depth analysis of 'A New Kind Of Science,' focusing specifically on computational complexity and fundamental physics. By critically evaluating Wolfram's ideas in these areas, Aaronson sheds light on their strengths and weaknesses, ultimately providing valuable insights into the book's content.

• - Scott Aaronson provides a critical review of the book 'A New Kind of Science' by Stephen Wolfram
• - The review focuses on two main areas: computational complexity and fundamental physics
• - Aaronson uses standard techniques in theoretical computer science to analyze Wolfram's ideas
• - He addresses questions raised by Wolfram regarding computational complexity
• - Aaronson analyzes the complexity of Wolfram's proposed models and their implications for computation
• - He provides a critical assessment of the feasibility and validity of Wolfram's claims using established techniques in theoretical computer science
• - Aaronson also examines Wolfram's proposal for a deterministic model underlying quantum mechanics
• - He demonstrates that this model is inconsistent with both special relativity and Bell inequality violation
• - Through a rigorous examination, Aaronson highlights the inconsistencies and limitations of Wolfram's proposition
• - Overall, the review offers an in-depth analysis of 'A New Kind Of Science,' focusing on computational complexity and fundamental physics
• - Aaronson sheds light on the strengths and weaknesses of Wolfram's ideas, providing valuable insights into the book's content.

Scott Aaronson wrote a review of a book called "A New Kind of Science" by Stephen Wolfram. The review talks about two main things: how hard it is to do calculations on computers and the basic laws of physics. Aaronson uses techniques from computer science to study Wolfram's ideas. He tries to answer questions that Wolfram asked about how hard it is to do calculations. Aaronson also looks at how complicated Wolfram's models are and what they mean for doing calculations. He says that some of Wolfram's ideas don't work with other important scientific theories. Overall, Aaronson gives a detailed analysis of the book, talking about computer science and physics, and shows both good and bad parts of Wolfram's ideas. Definitions- Review: A careful look at something to see what is good or bad about it. - Computational complexity: How hard it is to do calculations on computers. - Fundamental physics: The basic laws that explain how everything in the universe works. - Techniques: Different ways or methods used to do something. - Proposition: An idea or theory that someone suggests or puts forward as true.

A Critical Review of Stephen Wolfram’s ‘A New Kind of Science’

In his critical review of Stephen Wolfram’s book, ‘A New Kind of Science,’ Scott Aaronson provides a comprehensive analysis focusing on two main areas: computational complexity and fundamental physics. Rather than providing a chapter-by-chapter evaluation, Aaronson examines Wolfram's ideas using standard techniques in theoretical computer science.

Computational Complexity

In terms of computational complexity, Aaronson addresses some of the questions raised by Wolfram. He analyzes the complexity of Wolfram's proposed models and investigates their implications for computation. By applying established techniques in theoretical computer science, Aaronson provides a critical assessment of the feasibility and validity of Wolfram's claims.

Fundamental Physics

Moving on to fundamental physics, Aaronson delves into Wolfram's proposal for a deterministic model underlying quantum mechanics. However, he demonstrates that this model cannot be reconciled with both special relativity and Bell inequality violation. Through a rigorous examination of the physics involved, he highlights the inconsistencies and limitations of Wolfram's proposition.

Conclusion

Overall, this review offers an in-depth analysis of 'A New Kind Of Science,' focusing specifically on computational complexity and fundamental physics. By critically evaluating Wolfram's ideas in these areas, Aaronson sheds light on their strengths and weaknesses, ultimately providing valuable insights into the book's content.