Results of the summarizing process for the arXiv paper: cond-mat/9505151v1

In a recent paper published in Physical Review Letters, Gonze et al. challenged the validity of the density functional theory (DFT) in Hohenberg-Kohn formulation for crystalline solids in a homogenous electric field. They proposed an alternative theory, called density-and-polarization functional theory, which they claimed should replace DFT in calculations of long-wave dielectric response. However, Mazin and Cohen have shown that the Hohenberg-Kohn theorem is still valid and that Gonze et al. 's theorem holds in addition to it, rather than instead of it. The Hohenberg-Kohn theorem states that the ground-state energy and electron density of a system are uniquely determined by its external potential, while Gonze et al. 's theorem deals with how this external potential affects the polarization response of a crystal. Mazin and Cohen's findings reinforce the importance of the Hohenberg-Kohn theorem as a fundamental principle underlying DFT and highlight the need for further research to fully understand how electric fields affect crystalline materials.

• - Gonze et al. challenged the validity of density functional theory (DFT) in Hohenberg-Kohn formulation for crystalline solids in a homogenous electric field
• - They proposed an alternative theory called density-and-polarization functional theory
• - Mazin and Cohen showed that the Hohenberg-Kohn theorem is still valid and Gonze et al.'s theorem holds in addition to it, rather than instead of it
• - The Hohenberg-Kohn theorem states that the ground-state energy and electron density of a system are uniquely determined by its external potential
• - Gonze et al.'s theorem deals with how this external potential affects the polarization response of a crystal
• - Mazin and Cohen's findings reinforce the importance of the Hohenberg-Kohn theorem as a fundamental principle underlying DFT
• - There is a need for further research to fully understand how electric fields affect crystalline materials.

Scientists were discussing a way to understand how electricity affects crystals. One group suggested a new idea called density-and-polarization functional theory. Another group said that the original idea, called density functional theory, was still important and could work with the new idea. The original idea says that you can figure out how much energy and electrons are in a crystal by looking at its outside forces. The new idea talks about how those outside forces affect the crystal's ability to respond to electricity. Scientists need to do more research to fully understand this topic. Definitions- Density functional theory (DFT): A way of understanding the behavior of atoms and molecules based on their electron density. - Hohenberg-Kohn formulation: A mathematical framework for DFT that describes how the electron density of a system is related to its external potential. - Ground-state energy: The lowest possible energy state of a system. - Electron density: The distribution of electrons in an atom or molecule. - Polarization response: How a material responds to an electric field by developing an electric dipole moment. - Crystalline solids: Solids made up of repeating patterns of atoms or molecules arranged in a regular structure.

Hohenberg-Kohn Theorem and Density Functional Theory Challenged by Gonze et al.

In a recent paper published in Physical Review Letters, Gonze et al. challenged the validity of the density functional theory (DFT) in Hohenberg-Kohn formulation for crystalline solids in a homogenous electric field. They proposed an alternative theory, called density-and-polarization functional theory, which they claimed should replace DFT in calculations of long-wave dielectric response.

The Hohenberg-Kohn Theorem

The Hohenberg–Kohn theorem is a fundamental principle underlying DFT that states that the ground-state energy and electron density of a system are uniquely determined by its external potential. This means that given any external potential, there is only one possible ground state energy and electron density associated with it. It has been used to great success over the years to accurately predict properties of materials such as their electronic structure and optical properties.

Gonze et al.'s Alternative Theory

Gonze et al., however, argued that this theorem was not valid when applied to crystals in homogeneous electric fields due to their polarization response being affected by these fields. To address this issue, they proposed an alternative theory called “density-and-polarization functional theory” which would be better suited for calculating long wave dielectric responses of crystalline materials under electric fields.

Mazin & Cohen's Findings

However, Mazin and Cohen have shown that the Hohenberg–Kohn theorem is still valid and that Gonze et al.'s theorem holds in addition to it rather than instead of it. In other words, both theories can be used together to accurately calculate properties such as electronic structure and optical properties of crystalline materials under external electric fields without compromising accuracy or precision. This finding reinforces the importance of the Hohenberg–Kohn theorem as a fundamental principle underlying DFT while also highlighting the need for further research into how electric fields affect crystalline materials so we can fully understand their behavior under different conditions.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Mazin & Cohen's findings reinforce the importance of the Hohenberg–Kohn theorem as a fundamental principle underlying DFT while also highlighting the need for further research into how electric fields affect crystalline materials so we can fully understand their behavior under different conditions.