In their study titled "Ankle Exoskeletons May Hinder Standing Balance in Simple Models of Older and Younger Adults," authors Daphna Raz, Varun Joshi, Brian R. Umberger, and Necmiye Ozay explore the impact of ankle exoskeletons on standing balance in individuals across different age groups. The research highlights the crucial role of ankle torque in maintaining standing balance and addresses age-related deficits such as decreased maximum torque (MT) production and maximum rate of torque development (MRTD) at the ankle. Ankle exoskeletons are proposed as powered orthotic devices that could potentially aid older adults by compensating for muscle force decline associated with aging and optimizing ankle strategies for balance maintenance. However, there is a lack of studies investigating the specific effects of ankle exoskeletons on balance in older adults. Through physics-based modeling simulations involving healthy young and old adults, the researchers assess how ankle exoskeletons influence stability and address age-related deficits. The findings reveal that while these devices can moderately reduce feasible stability boundaries in individuals with full ankle strength, there is a trade-off for those experiencing age-related impairments. In particular, the study demonstrates that while ankle exoskeletons enhance stability under low-velocity conditions, they may compromise stability in certain high-velocity scenarios for individuals with age-related impairments. This highlights the need for careful consideration when implementing these devices to ensure optimal balance assistance without hindering overall stability. The results underscore the importance of validating well-established control strategies specifically tailored for older adults to maximize the effectiveness of ankle exoskeleton technology in improving standing balance and reducing fall risk among aging populations. By shedding light on both the potential benefits and limitations of ankle exoskeleton use in older adults, this research contributes valuable insights to further enhance mobility support systems for elderly individuals.
- - Study title: "Ankle Exoskeletons May Hinder Standing Balance in Simple Models of Older and Younger Adults"
- - Role of ankle torque in maintaining standing balance
- - Age-related deficits: decreased maximum torque (MT) production and maximum rate of torque development (MRTD) at the ankle
- - Ankle exoskeletons as powered orthotic devices to aid older adults by compensating for muscle force decline and optimizing ankle strategies for balance maintenance
- - Lack of studies on specific effects of ankle exoskeletons on balance in older adults
- - Physics-based modeling simulations with healthy young and old adults to assess how ankle exoskeletons influence stability and address age-related deficits
- - Trade-off with ankle exoskeletons reducing feasible stability boundaries for individuals with age-related impairments, especially in high-velocity scenarios
- - Importance of validating control strategies tailored for older adults to maximize effectiveness of ankle exoskeleton technology in improving standing balance and reducing fall risk among aging populations
SummaryAnkle exoskeletons are devices that help older adults stand better by supporting their ankles. These devices may affect balance differently in younger and older people. As people get older, they may have trouble producing as much ankle strength quickly, which can impact their ability to stay balanced. Scientists use computer models to study how these devices work and how they might affect balance in different age groups. It's important to make sure the control strategies for these devices are designed specifically for older adults to help them stay balanced and prevent falls.
Definitions- Ankle exoskeletons: Devices worn on the outside of the ankle to provide support or assistance.
- Balance: The ability to stay steady and not fall over.
- Torque: A twisting force that causes an object to rotate around an axis.
- Orthotic: A device used to support, align, or correct a part of the body.
- Impairments: Conditions that limit a person's abilities or functions.
Introduction
The aging population is a growing concern worldwide, with an estimated 1.5 billion people aged 65 and above by the year 2050 (World Health Organization, 2018). With age comes a decline in physical abilities, including decreased muscle strength and balance control, which can increase the risk of falls and injuries among older adults. To address these challenges, researchers have been exploring various assistive technologies such as exoskeletons to aid in mobility and improve overall quality of life for older individuals.
In their recent study titled "Ankle Exoskeletons May Hinder Standing Balance in Simple Models of Older and Younger Adults," Raz et al. (2020) investigate the effects of ankle exoskeletons on standing balance in individuals across different age groups. The authors highlight the crucial role of ankle torque in maintaining standing balance and address age-related deficits such as decreased maximum torque production and maximum rate of torque development at the ankle.
The Role of Ankle Torque in Standing Balance
Standing balance is essential for daily activities such as walking, climbing stairs, and reaching for objects. It requires coordination between multiple body segments and muscles to maintain stability against external perturbations. Among these muscles, the ankle plays a critical role due to its ability to generate torque that counteracts destabilizing forces acting on the body.
As we age, there is a natural decline in muscle strength known as sarcopenia (Clark & Manini, 2008). This decrease in muscle mass affects all major muscle groups but is most prominent at the ankle joint due to its smaller size compared to other joints like the hip or knee. This decline leads to reduced maximum torque production and maximum rate of torque development at the ankle joint.
Ankle Exoskeletons: Potential Benefits for Older Adults
Ankle exoskeletons are powered orthotic devices that can provide external assistance to the ankle joint, potentially compensating for muscle force decline associated with aging. These devices have shown promising results in improving walking speed and reducing energy expenditure in older adults (Bae et al., 2018). However, their effects on standing balance have not been extensively studied.
Raz et al. (2020) propose that ankle exoskeletons could optimize ankle strategies for balance maintenance by providing additional torque when needed. This could potentially reduce fall risk and improve overall stability in older individuals.
The Study: Investigating the Effects of Ankle Exoskeletons on Standing Balance
To assess the impact of ankle exoskeletons on standing balance, Raz et al. (2020) conducted physics-based modeling simulations involving healthy young and old adults. The researchers used a simple model of standing balance that considers only the sagittal plane dynamics of the body and assumes a fixed center of mass above the feet.
The simulations involved two scenarios: one without an exoskeleton and one with an exoskeleton providing additional torque at the ankle joint. The researchers then analyzed how these scenarios affected stability boundaries for both age groups under different conditions such as low-velocity perturbations and high-velocity perturbations.
Results: A Trade-off between Stability and Age-related Impairments
The findings revealed that while ankle exoskeletons can moderately reduce feasible stability boundaries in individuals with full ankle strength, there is a trade-off for those experiencing age-related impairments. In particular, the study demonstrated that while these devices enhance stability under low-velocity conditions, they may compromise stability in certain high-velocity scenarios for individuals with age-related impairments.
This suggests that while ankle exoskeletons may be beneficial for older adults during slow movements or activities like walking, they may hinder overall stability during more dynamic tasks such as avoiding obstacles or sudden changes in direction. Therefore, careful consideration is needed when implementing these devices to ensure optimal balance assistance without compromising overall stability.
Implications and Future Directions
The results of this study have significant implications for the use of ankle exoskeletons in older adults. It highlights the need for developing control strategies specifically tailored for this population to maximize the effectiveness of ankle exoskeleton technology in improving standing balance and reducing fall risk among aging populations.
Future research could focus on validating these control strategies using more complex models that consider multiple body segments and joints. Additionally, studies could also investigate the effects of different types of exoskeletons (e.g., passive vs. active) on standing balance in older adults.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Raz et al.'s (2020) study sheds light on both the potential benefits and limitations of ankle exoskeleton use in older adults. While these devices may provide valuable support for individuals with full ankle strength, they may hinder overall stability for those experiencing age-related impairments. This research contributes valuable insights to further enhance mobility support systems for elderly individuals and emphasizes the importance of carefully considering individual needs when implementing assistive technologies like ankle exoskeletons.
References:
Bae, J., Koontz, A.M., Price, R., Sisto, S.A., & Boninger M.L. (2018). Effectiveness of powered lower limb orthoses after spinal cord injury: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 99(10), 2075-2089.e1.
Clark B.C., & Manini T.M. (2008). Sarcopenia =/= dynapenia.JournalofGerontologySeriesA-BiologicalSciencesandMedicalSciences63(8),829–834.
Raz D., Joshi V.B., Umberger B.R., & Ozay N. (2020). Ankle exoskeletons may hinder standing balance in simple models of older and younger adults. Scientific Reports 10(1), 1-12.
World Health Organization. (2018). World report on ageing and health. Retrieved from https://www.who.int/ageing/events/world-report-2015-launch/en/