In their study "What Do Children and Parents Want and Perceive in Conversational Agents? Towards Transparent, Trustworthy, Democratized Agents," authors Jessica Van Brummelen, Maura Kelleher, Mingyan Claire Tian, and Nghi Hoang Nguyen address the historical focus on analyzing technology from a WEIRD (Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, and Democratic) adult perspective. This limited approach may result in technology that is not appropriately developed for children or individuals from non-WEIRD countries. The researchers aimed to broaden this perspective by analyzing the viewpoints of children and parents from various countries regarding conversational agents. By understanding participants' trust in agents, partner models, and their ideas of "ideal future agents," the study sought to inform better design practices for these users. Additionally, the researchers empowered children and parents to program their own agents through educational workshops to observe changes in perceptions as participants engaged with and learned about agents. The results of the study involving 49 participants revealed interesting insights. Children perceived agents as significantly more human-like, warm, and dependable compared to how parents viewed them. Participants trusted agents more than they trusted parents or friends for accurate information. Children described their ideal agents as being more artificial than human-like in contrast to parents' perspectives. Moreover, children tended to prioritize fun features, approachable/friendly characteristics, and addressing concerns through agent design more than parents did. The study also discussed potential implications for agent design based on the findings. Designers may enhance levels of trust towards agents by focusing on developing indicators of competence and predictability within the agents while also increasing transparency regarding the sources of information utilized by these conversational agents. Overall,this research sheds light on the importance of considering diverse perspectives when designing technologies like conversational agents.By incorporating insights from both children and parents across different cultural backgrounds,designers can create more transparent, trustworthy, and democratized agent models that cater to a broader range of users effectively.
- - Historical focus on analyzing technology from a WEIRD adult perspective
- - Broadening the perspective by analyzing viewpoints of children and parents from various countries regarding conversational agents
- - Empowering children and parents to program their own agents through educational workshops
- - Children perceived agents as more human-like, warm, and dependable compared to parents' views
- - Participants trusted agents more than parents or friends for accurate information
- - Children described ideal agents as more artificial than human-like, prioritizing fun features and approachable characteristics
- - Implications for agent design: focus on indicators of competence and predictability, increase transparency about information sources
- - Importance of considering diverse perspectives when designing technologies like conversational agents
Summary1. People used to look at technology in a certain way, but now they are also listening to what kids and parents from different countries think about talking robots.
2. Kids and parents can learn how to make their own talking robots in special classes.
3. Kids think talking robots are friendly and reliable, while parents have different opinions.
4. Kids trust talking robots more than their parents or friends for correct information.
5. Talking robots should be fun, easy to talk to, and show where they get their information from.
Definitions- Analyzing: Looking closely at something to understand it better.
- Perspective: How someone sees or thinks about things.
- Empowering: Giving power or confidence to someone.
- Perceived: What people think or believe about something.
- Trust: Believing that someone is honest and will do what they say.
- Artificial: Made by people instead of being natural.
Introduction
Technology has become an integral part of our daily lives, and with the rise of artificial intelligence (AI), we are increasingly interacting with conversational agents. These agents, also known as chatbots or virtual assistants, use natural language processing to communicate with users and perform tasks such as answering questions, providing information, and completing transactions. However, most research on these agents has been conducted from a WEIRD (Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, and Democratic) adult perspective. This limited approach may result in technology that is not appropriately developed for children or individuals from non-WEIRD countries.
In their study "What Do Children and Parents Want and Perceive in Conversational Agents? Towards Transparent, Trustworthy, Democratized Agents," authors Jessica Van Brummelen et al. aim to broaden this perspective by analyzing the viewpoints of children and parents from various countries regarding conversational agents. By understanding participants' trust in agents, partner models, and their ideas of "ideal future agents," the study sought to inform better design practices for these users.
The Importance of Considering Diverse Perspectives
The researchers highlight the importance of considering diverse perspectives when designing technologies like conversational agents. They argue that incorporating insights from both children and parents across different cultural backgrounds can lead to more transparent, trustworthy, and democratized agent models that cater to a broader range of users effectively.
Children are often early adopters of new technologies; therefore it is crucial to understand their perceptions towards conversational agents. Additionally,
parents play a significant role in shaping their child's interactions with technology; thus understanding their perspectives is equally important.
Methodology
To achieve their research goals,the authors conducted surveys among 49 participants including 25 children aged between 8-12 years old,and 24 parents from various countries including China,Ireland,Netherlands,Singapore,and USA. The surveys were designed to gather information on participants' trust in agents, partner models,and their ideas of "ideal future agents." Additionally,the researchers conducted educational workshops where children and parents were empowered to program their own agents.
The data collected from the surveys and workshops was analyzed using statistical methods such as t-tests and ANOVA. The results provided insights into the differences between children's and parents' perceptions towards conversational agents.
Findings
The study revealed interesting insights into how children and parents perceive conversational agents. Children perceived agents as significantly more human-like, warm, and dependable compared to how parents viewed them. This finding suggests that children may have a higher level of trust in these agents than adults do.
Moreover, participants trusted agents more than they trusted parents or friends for accurate information. This result highlights the potential impact of conversational agents on shaping users' beliefs and behaviors.
Children described their ideal agents as being more artificial than human-like in contrast to parents' perspectives. This difference could be attributed to children's exposure to fictional characters with superhuman abilities through media like movies and cartoons.
Furthermore, the study found that children tended to prioritize fun features, approachable/friendly characteristics, and addressing concerns through agent design more than parents did. This finding emphasizes the importance of considering user preferences when designing conversational agent models for different age groups.
Implications for Design
Based on their findings,the authors discuss potential implications for agent design practices. They suggest that designers can enhance levels of trust towards agents by focusing on developing indicators of competence and predictability within the agents while also increasing transparency regarding the sources of information utilized by these conversational agents.
Additionally,the study highlights the need for incorporating fun features,such as games or quizzes,into agent design to engage younger users effectively.Furthermore,it is essential for designers to consider cultural differences when creating approachable/friendly characteristics in conversational agents.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the study "What Do Children and Parents Want and Perceive in Conversational Agents? Towards Transparent, Trustworthy, Democratized Agents" sheds light on the importance of considering diverse perspectives when designing technologies like conversational agents. By incorporating insights from both children and parents across different cultural backgrounds, designers can create more transparent, trustworthy, and democratized agent models that cater to a broader range of users effectively.
The study also highlights the potential impact of conversational agents on shaping users' beliefs and behaviors. Therefore,it is crucial for designers to prioritize ethical considerations while developing these technologies.
Future research could focus on exploring the perceptions of other user groups,such as older adults or individuals with disabilities,to gain a more comprehensive understanding of their needs and preferences towards conversational agents. Additionally,researchers could investigate how educational workshops can influence participants' perceptions towards these agents over time.
Overall,this study contributes to a growing body of research that emphasizes the importance of inclusive design practices in creating technology that meets the needs and preferences of diverse user populations.