The development and deployment of AI-based medical devices require thorough evaluation of their safety, efficiency, and usability. Estimating the test performance of such devices under distribution shifts is crucial to ensure their robustness and trustworthiness in clinical settings. However, acquiring large amounts of labeled medical datasets for this purpose is challenging due to regulatory constraints. Therefore, in this study, the authors propose a "black-box" test estimation technique based on conformal prediction that predicts the test accuracy of an arbitrary black-box model on an unlabeled target domain without modifying the original training process or making any distributional assumptions about the source data. To evaluate their proposed technique, the authors compare it with other methods on three medical imaging datasets (mammography, dermatology, and histopathology) under several clinically relevant types of distribution shift (institution, hardware scanner, atlas, hospital). They find that their method outperforms other techniques in terms of accuracy estimation while being practical and effective for black-box models. The problem of identifying and rectifying performance degradation under new data populations has been extensively studied as distribution shift, out-of-distribution detection, and domain generalization. Recent works have begun to investigate techniques and frameworks for estimating test performance on unlabeled domain-shifted distributions. Deng & Zheng (2020) introduced the notion of predicting performance on an unlabeled test set using feature vectors from models trained under different distribution shifts. Garg et al. (2022) proposed a simpler technique that estimates accuracy on an unlabeled target distribution by selecting a confidence threshold using accuracy on a source dataset. In conclusion, this study contributes to promoting practical and effective estimation techniques for black-box models used in medical device software. The authors hope that these standardized evaluation procedures will improve the robustness and trustworthiness of clinical AI tools. This paper was presented at ICML Workshop on Principles of Distribution Shift (PODS) 2022.
- - Development and deployment of AI-based medical devices require thorough evaluation of safety, efficiency, and usability.
- - Estimating test performance under distribution shifts is crucial to ensure robustness and trustworthiness in clinical settings.
- - Acquiring labeled medical datasets for this purpose is challenging due to regulatory constraints.
- - "Black-box" test estimation technique based on conformal prediction predicts test accuracy of an arbitrary black-box model on an unlabeled target domain without modifying the original training process or making any distributional assumptions about the source data.
- - Proposed technique outperforms other methods in terms of accuracy estimation while being practical and effective for black-box models.
- - Recent works have investigated techniques and frameworks for estimating test performance on unlabeled domain-shifted distributions.
- - Standardized evaluation procedures will improve the robustness and trustworthiness of clinical AI tools.
1. AI-based medical devices need to be checked for safety, efficiency, and ease of use.
2. It's important to test these devices under different conditions to make sure they work well in real-life situations.
3. Getting enough data to test these devices can be difficult because of rules and regulations.
4. A new technique called "black-box" testing can estimate how accurate the device will be without changing how it was made or assuming anything about the data used to train it.
5. This new method works better than other ways of testing and will help make sure medical AI tools are reliable.
Definitions- AI: Artificial Intelligence - when machines can do things that normally require human intelligence, like learning from experience or recognizing patterns
- Robustness: The ability of something to work well even when there are changes or problems
- Trustworthiness: How much people can rely on something being true or accurate
- Distribution: How often different things happen in a group or population
- Labeled dataset: A collection of information where each piece is marked with what it represents (like pictures labeled as "dog" or "cat")
- Black-box model: A type of machine learning algorithm where we don't know exactly how it works inside, but we can see what it does with input and output
Evaluating AI-based Medical Devices with Distribution Shifts
The development and deployment of artificial intelligence (AI)-based medical devices require thorough evaluation of their safety, efficiency, and usability. Estimating the test performance of such devices under distribution shifts is crucial to ensure their robustness and trustworthiness in clinical settings. However, acquiring large amounts of labeled medical datasets for this purpose is challenging due to regulatory constraints.
In this article, we discuss a research paper presented at ICML Workshop on Principles of Distribution Shift (PODS) 2022 that proposes a “black-box” test estimation technique based on conformal prediction for predicting the test accuracy of an arbitrary black-box model on an unlabeled target domain without modifying the original training process or making any distributional assumptions about the source data. We will also compare it with other methods and discuss its implications for improving the robustness and trustworthiness of clinical AI tools.
Background: Distribution Shift & Out-of-Distribution Detection
The problem of identifying and rectifying performance degradation under new data populations has been extensively studied as distribution shift, out-of-distribution detection, and domain generalization. In recent years, researchers have begun to investigate techniques and frameworks for estimating test performance on unlabeled domain-shifted distributions.
Proposed Technique: Black Box Test Estimation
Deng & Zheng (2020) introduced the notion of predicting performance on an unlabeled test set using feature vectors from models trained under different distribution shifts. Garg et al.(2022) proposed a simpler technique that estimates accuracy on an unlabeled target distribution by selecting a confidence threshold using accuracy on a source dataset. The authors propose a “black box” approach which predicts the test accuracy without modifying the original training process or making any assumptions about the source data. To evaluate their proposed technique they compared it with other methods on three medical imaging datasets (mammography, dermatology, and histopathology) under several clinically relevant types of distribution shift (institution, hardware scanner, atlas hospital). They found that their method outperforms other techniques in terms of accuracy estimation while being practical and effective for black box models used in medical device software.
Implications & Conclusion
This study contributes to promoting practical and effective estimation techniques for black box models used in medical device software which can improve their robustness and trustworthiness in clinical settings. The authors hope that these standardized evaluation procedures will help reduce errors caused by unanticipated changes in data distributions when deploying AI tools into real world applications such as healthcare systems where accurate predictions are essential for patient safety concerns .