This paper, titled "Toward Ethical AIED," presents the key conclusions from the forthcoming edited book on The Ethics of Artificial Intelligence in Education: Practices, Challenges and Debates (to be published by Routledge in August 2022). The paper highlights the diverse perspectives presented in the book, both from within and outside the field of AI in Education (AIED), as a means of achieving a broad perspective on key ethical issues for AIED. Chapter 6 of the book, authored by Holstein and Doroudi, provides a detailed map of stakeholder perspectives that are crucial to gaining a better understanding of questions that need to be asked about AI in Education operating within larger socio-technical settings. This chapter emphasizes the need for transparency and precision in declaring whose perspective is being emphasized since different perspectives may lead to different conclusions. Other chapters in the book highlight how too often, learners' diverse needs and perspectives are invisible to curriculum designers and AI system developers. The authors also discuss grand challenges for AIED with respect to ethics and ethical practices within the field. They argue that there is a need to view AIED as an applied ethics field where ethical considerations are integrated into all aspects of research, development, deployment, and evaluation. Additionally, they call for increased collaboration between researchers across disciplines such as computer science, education, philosophy, law, sociology, psychology, and neuroscience. Overall, this paper provides valuable insights into current debates surrounding ethics in AIED. It highlights the importance of considering diverse stakeholder perspectives when designing AI systems for education while emphasizing the need for transparency and precision regarding whose perspective is being prioritized. Furthermore, it underscores how ethical considerations must be integrated throughout all stages of research and development if we are to create fairer AI systems that serve learners' diverse needs effectively.
- - The paper presents key conclusions from the forthcoming edited book on The Ethics of Artificial Intelligence in Education
- - Diverse perspectives are highlighted, both from within and outside the field of AI in Education (AIED)
- - Chapter 6 provides a detailed map of stakeholder perspectives that are crucial to gaining a better understanding of questions that need to be asked about AI in Education operating within larger socio-technical settings
- - Other chapters highlight how learners' diverse needs and perspectives are often invisible to curriculum designers and AI system developers
- - There is a need to view AIED as an applied ethics field where ethical considerations are integrated into all aspects of research, development, deployment, and evaluation
- - Increased collaboration between researchers across disciplines such as computer science, education, philosophy, law, sociology, psychology, and neuroscience is called for
- - Ethical considerations must be integrated throughout all stages of research and development if we are to create fairer AI systems that serve learners' diverse needs effectively.
The paper talks about a book that will come out soon about how we should use robots in school. The book has different ideas from people who know a lot about robots and people who don't. One chapter talks about how important it is to listen to everyone's opinions before using robots in school. Other chapters say that sometimes the people who make the robots forget that kids are all different and need different things. We need to think carefully about how we use robots in school so that they help all kids learn fairly. It's important for lots of different types of experts to work together when making decisions about using robots in school.
Definitions- Ethics: thinking carefully about what is right and wrong
- Artificial Intelligence: when computers or machines can do things that usually need human intelligence, like learning or problem-solving
- Perspectives: opinions or ways of looking at things
- Curriculum designers: people who decide what students should learn in school
- Collaboration: working together with other people on a project
Toward Ethical AIED: Exploring the Ethics of Artificial Intelligence in Education
The field of Artificial Intelligence in Education (AIED) is rapidly evolving, and with it, so too are ethical considerations. In order to ensure that AI systems are designed and implemented responsibly, there must be a better understanding of the ethical issues surrounding their use. The forthcoming edited book on The Ethics of Artificial Intelligence in Education: Practices, Challenges and Debates (to be published by Routledge in August 2022) provides valuable insights into current debates surrounding ethics in AIED. This paper presents key conclusions from the book as a means of gaining a broader perspective on these issues.
Stakeholder Perspectives
Chapter 6 of the book, authored by Holstein and Doroudi, provides an important map for considering stakeholder perspectives when discussing questions about AIED operating within larger socio-technical settings. It emphasizes the need for transparency and precision when declaring whose perspective is being emphasized since different perspectives may lead to different conclusions. For example, if one were to consider only developers' perspectives when designing an AI system for education, they might overlook learners' diverse needs or fail to account for potential biases that could arise during implementation.
Invisible Learners
Other chapters in the book highlight how too often learners' diverse needs and perspectives are invisible to curriculum designers and AI system developers. This can result in systems that do not serve all learners equally or fairly due to lack of consideration for their individual backgrounds or experiences. As such, it is essential that those developing AI systems take into account multiple stakeholders’ views throughout all stages of research and development if we are to create fairer systems that serve learners’ diverse needs effectively.
Grand Challenges
The authors also discuss grand challenges for AIED with respect to ethics and ethical practices within the field. They argue that there is a need to view AIED as an applied ethics field where ethical considerations are integrated into all aspects of research, development, deployment, and evaluation processes rather than simply as an afterthought tacked onto existing projects at completion stage.. Additionally they call for increased collaboration between researchers across disciplines such as computer science, education philosophy law sociology psychology neuroscience etc., which will help foster greater understanding among stakeholders regarding what constitutes responsible design practices when creating artificial intelligence systems intended for educational purposes .
Conclusion
Overall this paper provides valuable insights into current debates surrounding ethics in AIED It highlights importance considering diverse stakeholder perspectives when designing artificial intelligence systems while emphasizing need transparency precision regarding whose perspective prioritized Furthermore underscores how ethical considerations must integrated throughout stages research development if we create fairer serve learner's diverse needs effectively