The paper discusses the use of postcolonial feminist theory to critically investigate gender data initiatives for development policy and practice. Mainstream development institutions have invested heavily in these initiatives, but there is a lack of critical empirical and theoretical investigations into their effectiveness. This study presents findings from a participatory action research project with young women involved in a gender data for development project in Bangladesh known as 'DataGirls'. The project was an international government-funded intervention designed by a UK-based multinational NGO and delivered in partnership with an implementing Bangladeshi NGO. The 'DataGirls' were recruited and trained to become smartphone-based digital data collectors, collecting data on three different topics for five other multinational NGOs engaged in work with girls in Bangladesh. They were paid for their work and awarded a Market Research Society qualification in digital research. However, they had concerns that the data was being extracted from their communities representing external NGOs' priorities more than their own. Through collaborating to develop and deliver community events on child marriage with the 'DataGirls', this research demonstrates that participatory approaches can address postcolonial feminist criticisms of (data for) development by ensuring that gender data is enacted by and for majority world women rather than Western development institutions. The 'DataGirls' wanted the findings of the data returned to them but also felt it was important for the wider community to have access so they too could be aware of it. This study highlights how participatory research can enable participants rather than researchers to take the lead while addressing postcolonial feminist concerns about development projects targeting women in majority world countries. By involving local communities in gathering and sharing gender-related data, these initiatives can be more effective at addressing gender inequality issues specific to those communities. Overall, this paper contributes to ongoing discussions about how best to collect and use gender-related data for development purposes while taking into account perspectives and priorities of those most affected by gender inequality.
- - The paper discusses the use of postcolonial feminist theory to critically investigate gender data initiatives for development policy and practice.
- - Mainstream development institutions have invested heavily in these initiatives, but there is a lack of critical empirical and theoretical investigations into their effectiveness.
- - Findings from a participatory action research project with young women involved in a gender data for development project in Bangladesh known as 'DataGirls' are presented.
- - The 'DataGirls' were recruited and trained to become smartphone-based digital data collectors, collecting data on three different topics for five other multinational NGOs engaged in work with girls in Bangladesh.
- - Participatory approaches can address postcolonial feminist criticisms of (data for) development by ensuring that gender data is enacted by and for majority world women rather than Western development institutions.
- - By involving local communities in gathering and sharing gender-related data, these initiatives can be more effective at addressing gender inequality issues specific to those communities.
- - This study highlights how participatory research can enable participants rather than researchers to take the lead while addressing postcolonial feminist concerns about development projects targeting women in majority world countries.
Summary: The paper talks about how we can use a special way of thinking called postcolonial feminist theory to look at gender data initiatives. These initiatives are when people collect information about girls and women in different countries to help make things better for them. Some big organizations have spent a lot of money on these initiatives, but not enough people have looked at whether they actually work or not. The paper tells us about a group of young women in Bangladesh who were trained to use their phones to collect data for other organizations working with girls in their country. By involving local communities like this, we can do a better job of helping girls and women.
Definitions:
- Postcolonial feminist theory: A way of thinking that looks at how power and inequality affect people differently based on things like race, gender, and where they live.
- Gender data initiatives: When people collect information about girls and women in different countries to help make things better for them.
- Empirical: Based on evidence from real-world observations or experiments.
- Participatory action research: A type of research where the people being studied are also involved in designing and carrying out the study.
- Majority world: Another term for developing countries or countries that are not as wealthy as others.
- Western development institutions: Big organizations from rich countries that try to help poorer countries develop.
Postcolonial Feminist Theory and Gender Data Initiatives for Development Policy and Practice
Gender inequality is a major issue in many parts of the world, particularly in majority world countries. In recent years, development institutions have invested heavily in gender data initiatives to address these issues. However, there has been a lack of critical empirical and theoretical investigations into their effectiveness. This article will discuss the use of postcolonial feminist theory to critically investigate gender data initiatives for development policy and practice. It will draw on findings from a participatory action research project with young women involved in a gender data for development project in Bangladesh known as 'DataGirls'.
Background: Gender Data Initiatives
Gender data initiatives are projects designed to collect and analyze gender-related information that can be used to inform decision making about policies or programs related to gender equality. These initiatives typically involve collecting quantitative or qualitative data through surveys, interviews, focus groups, or other methods. The goal is to provide evidence-based insights into the causes and consequences of gender inequality so that effective interventions can be developed and implemented.
Mainstream development institutions have invested heavily in these initiatives but there is still much debate about how best to collect and use this type of data for development purposes while taking into account perspectives and priorities of those most affected by gender inequality. Postcolonial feminist theory provides an important framework for understanding how power dynamics between Western donors/institutions (the ‘colonizers’) and majority world communities (the ‘colonized’) shape the design, implementation, evaluation,and impact of such projects.
The 'DataGirls' Project
This study presents findings from a participatory action research project with young women involved in a gender data for development project in Bangladesh known as 'DataGirls'. The project was an international government-funded intervention designed by a UK-based multinational NGO (non-governmental organization)and delivered in partnership with an implementing Bangladeshi NGO (non-governmental organization). The 'DataGirls' were recruited and trained to become smartphone-based digital data collectors who collected three different topics related to girls' rights from five other multinational NGOs engaged in work with girls across Bangladesh. They were paid for their work as well as awarded Market Research Society qualifications upon completion of the training program.
Despite being compensated fairly well for their efforts, some members of the group had concerns that the extracted data was not necessarily representing their own community's priorities but rather external NGOs' priorities more than theirs instead . To address this concern , they collaborated together on developing community events focused on child marriage which allowed them take ownership over what kind of information was being collected . Through this process , they also felt empowered enough that they wanted both themselves as well as wider community members access to any findings generated from their work .
Conclusion: Participatory Approaches & Postcolonial Feminist Criticisms
This study highlights how participatory approaches can enable participants rather than researchers take lead while addressing postcolonial feminist criticisms regarding certain types of development projects targeting women living within majority world countries . By involving local communities gathering sharing relevant information concerning them , it ensures that any form gendered -data collected reflects actual needs wants those most affected by inequalities instead simply reflecting agendas imposed externally . In addition , when given opportunity share results gathered back within same communities where it originated , it helps ensure greater accountability transparency overall initiative itself .
Overall , this paper contributes ongoing discussions about best way collect utilize gendered -related material purpose improving lives those facing disparities due unequal treatment based solely sex identity . By recognizing importance incorporating perspectives voices individuals directly impacted decisions made surrounding such matters , we can better understand implications our actions ultimately strive create fairer societies everyone regardless race class sexual orientation etcetera .