Results of the summarizing process for the arXiv paper: 2002.02855v1

The Payment Card Industry (PCI) involves various entities such as merchants, issuer banks, acquirer banks, and card brands. To ensure security for all entities that process payment card information, the PCI Security Standards Council requires compliance with the PCI Data Security Standard (DSS), which specifies a series of security requirements. In this study, researchers developed an e-commerce web application testbed called BuggyCart to systematically evaluate the PCI DSS certification process for e-commerce websites. The testbed can flexibly add or remove 35 PCI DSS related vulnerabilities. The researchers used the testbed to examine the capability and limitations of six approved scanning vendors (ASV) and found that none of them were fully compliant with ASV scanning guidelines, issuing certificates to merchants that still had major vulnerabilities. To further examine the compliance status of real-world e-commerce websites, they built a new lightweight scanning tool named PciCheckerLite and scanned 1,203 e-commerce websites across various business sectors. The results showed that 86% of the websites had at least one type of vulnerability that should have disqualified them as non-compliant according to PCI DSS standards. The study highlights a significant gap between the security standard and its real-world enforcement in terms of vulnerability screening capabilities of ASVs and rigor of certification processes. The researchers argue that similar research efforts could make a positive impact on the PCI community by producing high-quality open-sourced tools and customizing non-intrusive versions for testing production websites in the context of PCI DSS compliance. They also suggest designing minimum-footprint black-box scanning methods as future work. In addition to website scanning, proactive threat measurements using honeypots can assess attackers' behaviors or defenders' capabilities while physical card frauds occur due to stealing payment card information during physical transactions or cloning magnetic stripe cards while digital card frauds happen online due to flaws such as skipping SSL/TLS certificate validation or using insecure cryptographic primitives. The study's findings can help improve the enforcement of PCI DSS in practice and enhance the security of payment card information processing.

• - The Payment Card Industry (PCI) involves various entities such as merchants, issuer banks, acquirer banks, and card brands.
• - PCI Security Standards Council requires compliance with the PCI Data Security Standard (DSS) to ensure security for all entities that process payment card information.
• - Researchers developed an e-commerce web application testbed called BuggyCart to evaluate the PCI DSS certification process for e-commerce websites.
• - Six approved scanning vendors (ASV) were examined using the testbed and none of them were fully compliant with ASV scanning guidelines.
• - A new lightweight scanning tool named PciCheckerLite was built and used to scan 1,203 e-commerce websites across various business sectors.
• - 86% of the websites had at least one type of vulnerability that should have disqualified them as non-compliant according to PCI DSS standards.
• - The study highlights a significant gap between the security standard and its real-world enforcement in terms of vulnerability screening capabilities of ASVs and rigor of certification processes.
• - Similar research efforts could make a positive impact on the PCI community by producing high-quality open-sourced tools and customizing non-intrusive versions for testing production websites in the context of PCI DSS compliance.
• - Proactive threat measurements using honeypots can assess attackers' behaviors or defenders' capabilities while physical card frauds occur due to stealing payment card information during physical transactions or cloning magnetic stripe cards while digital card frauds happen online due to flaws such as skipping SSL/TLS certificate validation or using insecure cryptographic primitives.
• - The study's findings can help improve the enforcement of PCI DSS in practice and enhance the security of payment card information processing.

Summary: The Payment Card Industry (PCI) involves different groups like stores, banks, and card brands. They have to follow rules called PCI Data Security Standard (DSS) to keep payment information safe. Some people made a test website called BuggyCart to check if other websites are following the rules. They found out that many websites had problems that should have stopped them from being allowed to take payments. This means there is a big difference between the rules and how well they are being followed. Definitions- Payment Card Industry (PCI): A group of companies involved in processing credit and debit card payments. - Merchants: Stores or businesses that accept payment cards for purchases. - Issuer banks: Banks that issue payment cards to customers. - Acquirer banks: Banks that process payment transactions for merchants. - Card brands: Companies like Visa and Mastercard that provide payment cards and set rules for their use. - PCI Data Security Standard (DSS): Rules created by the PCI Security Standards Council to ensure security for all entities involved in processing payment card information. - E-commerce: Buying or selling goods online through a website or app. - Approved scanning vendors (ASV): Companies authorized by the PCI Security Standards Council to perform security scans on websites and report any vulnerabilities. - Vulnerability: A weakness in a system's security that could be exploited by attackers. - SSL/TLS certificate validation: A process of verifying the authenticity of a website's secure connection using digital certificates issued by trusted authorities. -

Exploring the Payment Card Industry (PCI) Data Security Standard (DSS)

The Payment Card Industry (PCI) involves various entities such as merchants, issuer banks, acquirer banks, and card brands. To ensure security for all entities that process payment card information, the PCI Security Standards Council requires compliance with the PCI Data Security Standard (DSS). This standard specifies a series of security requirements to protect customer data from theft or misuse.

Testing Compliance with BuggyCart

In order to evaluate the effectiveness of this standard in practice, researchers developed an e-commerce web application testbed called BuggyCart. This testbed can flexibly add or remove 35 PCI DSS related vulnerabilities so that they can be tested against six approved scanning vendors (ASV). The results showed that none of them were fully compliant with ASV scanning guidelines and issued certificates to merchants that still had major vulnerabilities.

Assessing Real-World E-Commerce Websites

To further examine the compliance status of real-world e-commerce websites, researchers built a new lightweight scanning tool named PciCheckerLite and scanned 1,203 e-commerce websites across various business sectors. The results showed that 86% of these websites had at least one type of vulnerability which should have disqualified them as non-compliant according to PCI DSS standards.

Improving Enforcement of PCI DSS in Practice

This study highlights a significant gap between the security standard and its real-world enforcement in terms of vulnerability screening capabilities of ASVs and rigor of certification processes. The researchers suggest designing minimum footprint black box scanning methods as future work in order to improve enforcement of PCI DSS in practice and enhance the security protection for payment card information processing. In addition to website scanning, proactive threat measurements using honeypots can assess attackers' behaviors or defenders' capabilities while physical card frauds occur due to stealing payment card information during physical transactions or cloning magnetic stripe cards while digital card frauds happen online due to flaws such as skipping SSL/TLS certificate validation or using insecure cryptographic primitives.