Results of the summarizing process for the arXiv paper: 2001.10173v1

Smart cities that utilize digital technologies have been proposed as a solution to the population pressures and increasing demand for services and infrastructure in developing countries. However, the financial costs of maintaining infrastructure, the size of informal economies, and governance challenges are hindering the realization of smart city initiatives. This systematic literature review examines the state of smart city development in developing countries, focusing on conceptualizations, motivations, drivers, and barriers. The review analyzed 56 studies from a pool of 3928 social sciences literature using thematic synthesis and analysis. The findings highlight that technology-enabled smart cities in developing countries can only be achieved through concurrent socioeconomic, human, legal, and regulatory reforms. Governments need to prioritize fulfilling citizens' basic infrastructure needs, generating more revenue, establishing clear regulatory frameworks to mitigate technological risks, developing human capital, ensuring digital inclusivity, and promoting environmental sustainability. Additionally, creating a supportive ecosystem that encourages citizen participation; nurtures start-ups; and fosters public-private partnerships is crucial for realizing the vision of smart cities in developing countries. This study emphasizes the importance of addressing various challenges and implementing comprehensive reforms to successfully implement smart city initiatives in developing nations.

• - Smart cities proposed as solution to population pressures and increasing demand for services in developing countries
• - Financial costs, informal economies, and governance challenges hindering smart city initiatives
• - Systematic literature review examines state of smart city development in developing countries
• - Technology-enabled smart cities require socioeconomic, human, legal, and regulatory reforms
• - Governments need to prioritize basic infrastructure needs, generate revenue, establish clear regulatory frameworks, develop human capital, ensure digital inclusivity, and promote environmental sustainability
• - Supportive ecosystem encouraging citizen participation, nurturing start-ups, and fostering public-private partnerships crucial for realizing smart cities in developing countries
• - Comprehensive reforms needed to successfully implement smart city initiatives in developing nations

Smart cities are cities that use technology to make life better for the people who live there. They are a solution to problems like too many people and not enough services in developing countries. But there are some challenges, like how much it costs and how the government runs things. A review of research shows that developing countries are working on smart cities, but they need to make changes in society, laws, and rules. Governments have to focus on important things like building roads and making money, while also taking care of the environment and making sure everyone can use technology. It's also important for the government to work with citizens, start new businesses, and team up with private companies. To make smart cities happen in developing countries, big changes need to be made." Definitions- Smart cities: Cities that use technology to improve people's lives. - Developing countries: Countries that are still growing and becoming more advanced. - Governance: How a government runs things. - Socioeconomic: Relating to society and money. - Regulatory: Rules set by the government. - Digital inclusivity: Making sure everyone has access to technology. - Public-private partnerships: When the government works together with private companies.

Smart Cities in Developing Countries: A Systematic Literature Review

The world is rapidly urbanizing, and the population of cities is expected to double by 2050. This rapid growth has created a need for more efficient infrastructure and services that can meet the needs of citizens. Smart cities have been proposed as a solution to this problem, utilizing digital technologies to improve efficiency and reduce costs. However, many developing countries are facing financial constraints, informal economies, and governance challenges that hinder the realization of smart city initiatives. This systematic literature review examines the state of smart city development in developing countries from conceptualizations to motivations, drivers, and barriers. The review analyzed 56 studies from a pool of 3928 social sciences literature using thematic synthesis and analysis. The findings highlight that technology-enabled smart cities in developing countries can only be achieved through concurrent socioeconomic, human, legal, and regulatory reforms.

Conceptualizations

Smart cities are defined as “urban spaces where physical infrastructures are connected with digital technologies” (Giffinger et al., 2007). They rely on data-driven decision making processes that enable governments to better manage resources while providing citizens with improved services such as transportation systems or energy management systems (Kitchin & Lauriault 2014). Smart cities also involve citizen participation in decision making processes through open data platforms or crowdsourcing initiatives (Meng et al., 2016).

Motivations

The primary motivation for implementing smart city initiatives is to increase efficiency by reducing costs associated with infrastructure maintenance while improving service delivery (Liu et al., 2017). Additionally, governments often use these initiatives as an opportunity to attract foreign investment or develop new industries (Hassan et al., 2018). Finally, some governments view these projects as an opportunity to create jobs or promote economic growth (Li & Wang 2019).

Drivers

In order for smart city initiatives to be successful in developing nations there must be several drivers present including: prioritizing basic infrastructure needs; generating more revenue; establishing clear regulatory frameworks; investing in human capital; ensuring digital inclusion; promoting environmental sustainability; creating supportive ecosystems for citizen participation; nurturing start-ups; fostering public-private partnerships (Bhattacharya et al., 2020).

Barriers

Despite their potential benefits there are several barriers preventing the successful implementation of smart city initiatives in developing nations including: lack of funding due to limited government budgets or inadequate taxation systems; lack of technical expertise among government officials leading them unable able make informed decisions about technology investments ; difficulty collecting accurate data due large informal economies ; unclear regulations regarding privacy issues ; unequal access digital technologies among different socio-economic groups ; cultural resistance towards technological change(Bhattacharya et al., 2020) .

Conclusion

This study emphasizes the importance addressing various challenges implementing comprehensive reforms successfully implement smart city initiatives developing nations . Governments need prioritize fulfilling citizens' basic infrastructure needs , generate more revenue , establish clear regulatory frameworks mitigate technological risks , develop human capital , ensure digital inclusion , promote environmental sustainability , create supportive ecosystem encourage citizen participation nurture start - ups foster public - private partnerships realize vision smart cities developing countries .