Advisory services are essential encounters between experts and advisees where the empathetic relationship between them plays a crucial role in the success of the interaction. To facilitate this high-touch experience, advisors have developed rituals that emphasize the unique and individual nature of each client and encounter. However, organizations like banks and insurance companies have introduced tools and technologies to standardize the advisory process across branches and advisors, creating a tension between high-touch and high-tech aspects. This manuscript presents a system called LivePaper that aims to bridge this gap by combining high-touch rituals with high-tech collaboration. By augmenting traditional pen-and-paper practices with digital content, LivePaper offers new material performances that align with existing rituals. Through an evaluation in realistic mortgage advisory services, it is shown how mixed reality approaches can be effectively applied in professional settings. The study acknowledges certain limitations such as the interdependence of design decisions and assumptions within the system which may affect its transferability to other domains. Further testing with real clients from different organizations could enhance external validity. The analysis focuses on qualitative descriptions of interactions in LivePaper advisory services but additional experiments with more participants could provide further evidence of its effectiveness. LivePaper addresses the challenge of supporting advisory services without compromising interpersonal relationships by preserving physical rituals while introducing digital elements for enhancement. It combines transparency, client education, and emotional engagement with traditional paper-based practices typical in financial advisory services. Unlike previous research that highlighted negative effects of digitalizing information during advisories' narratives or low involvement from advisees, LivePaper provides tools for fluent storytelling and increased client engagement through dynamic visualizations. Overall, LivePaper demonstrates how incorporating physical rituals into design can successfully combine high-touch and high-tech aspects in advisory services. By considering not only specific performances but also the physical environment and movements involved in interactions, LivePaper offers a comprehensive solution to enhance advisor-advisee relationships while embracing technological advancements.
- - Advisory services are essential encounters between experts and advisees, with the empathetic relationship playing a crucial role in success.
- - Advisors have developed rituals to emphasize the unique nature of each client and encounter.
- - Organizations like banks and insurance companies use tools to standardize advisory processes, creating tension between high-touch and high-tech aspects.
- - LivePaper system aims to bridge this gap by combining high-touch rituals with high-tech collaboration.
- - LivePaper augments traditional pen-and-paper practices with digital content for new material performances aligned with existing rituals.
- - Evaluation in mortgage advisory services shows how mixed reality approaches can be effectively applied in professional settings.
- - Limitations include design decisions affecting transferability and potential for enhanced external validity through testing with real clients from different organizations.
- - LivePaper preserves physical rituals while enhancing them with digital elements to support advisory services without compromising interpersonal relationships.
- - It combines transparency, client education, emotional engagement, and dynamic visualizations for increased client engagement during advisories.
SummaryAdvisory services are important meetings between experts and those seeking advice, where the caring relationship is crucial for success. Advisors have special traditions to show that each client is unique. Banks and insurance companies use tools to make advisory processes more consistent, balancing personal touch with technology. The LivePaper system combines traditional rituals with modern collaboration tools. It helps advisors provide new materials digitally while keeping old customs.
Definitions- Advisory services: Meetings where experts give advice to others.
- Empathetic: Understanding and sharing someone else's feelings.
- Rituals: Special actions or behaviors done in a specific way.
- Standardize: Make something the same or consistent.
- Collaboration: Working together with others towards a common goal.
Advisory services are an essential part of the financial industry, where experts provide guidance and advice to clients on various financial matters. These encounters between advisors and advisees rely heavily on the empathetic relationship between them for success. To facilitate this high-touch experience, advisors have developed rituals that emphasize the unique and individual nature of each client and encounter.
However, with the introduction of tools and technologies by organizations like banks and insurance companies, there has been a tension between high-touch and high-tech aspects in advisory services. This is because these tools aim to standardize the advisory process across branches and advisors, potentially compromising the personal touch that is crucial for successful interactions.
To bridge this gap, a team of researchers has developed a system called LivePaper. The goal of LivePaper is to combine high-touch rituals with high-tech collaboration in order to enhance advisory services without sacrificing interpersonal relationships.
The concept behind LivePaper is simple yet innovative – it augments traditional pen-and-paper practices with digital content. By introducing digital elements into physical rituals, LivePaper offers new material performances that align with existing rituals while also embracing technological advancements.
In their research paper titled "LivePaper: Combining High-Touch Rituals with High-Tech Collaboration in Advisory Services," authors Martin Murer et al. present their findings from evaluating LivePaper in realistic mortgage advisory services. The study demonstrates how mixed reality approaches can effectively be applied in professional settings to support advisory services.
One key aspect highlighted by the authors is that design decisions within LivePaper are interdependent on each other as well as assumptions made about its use within specific domains. This may affect its transferability to other industries or organizations. Thus, further testing with real clients from different backgrounds could enhance external validity.
The evaluation primarily focuses on qualitative descriptions of interactions in LivePaper advisory services; however, additional experiments involving more participants could provide further evidence of its effectiveness.
LivePaper addresses the challenge faced by many organizations in the financial industry – how to support advisory services without compromising interpersonal relationships. By preserving physical rituals while introducing digital elements for enhancement, LivePaper offers a comprehensive solution.
One of the key benefits of LivePaper is its ability to combine transparency, client education, and emotional engagement with traditional paper-based practices typical in financial advisory services. Unlike previous research that highlighted negative effects of digitalizing information during advisories' narratives or low involvement from advisees, LivePaper provides tools for fluent storytelling and increased client engagement through dynamic visualizations.
The success of LivePaper lies in its consideration not only of specific performances but also the physical environment and movements involved in interactions. This holistic approach ensures that all aspects of advisor-advisee relationships are taken into account when designing the system.
In conclusion, LivePaper demonstrates how incorporating physical rituals into design can successfully combine high-touch and high-tech aspects in advisory services. It offers a practical solution for organizations looking to embrace technological advancements while maintaining personal connections with their clients. With further testing and development, LivePaper has the potential to revolutionize the way advisory services are conducted across various industries.