In the world of decentralized finance (DeFi), users are constantly at risk of falling victim to adversarial actions that manipulate transaction orders to extract value from unsuspecting individuals. This malicious practice, known as maximal-extractable value (MEV), not only impacts individual outcomes but also threatens the overall stability of the DeFi ecosystem. To combat this growing concern, a new system called PROF (PRotected Order Flow) has been introduced. PROF is specifically designed to mitigate harmful forms of MEV within existing Proposer-Builder Separation (PBS) systems. The system operates on two key principles: first, it enforces a specific order on a bundle of privately input transactions all the way through to block production, effectively preventing any manipulation of transaction order. Second, PROF ensures that these bundles are profitable for block producers, guaranteeing their timely inclusion in blocks. One notable feature of PROF is its backward compatibility with both current and future PBS designs. Additionally, it can seamlessly integrate with any desired algorithm for ordering transactions within a PROF bundle, such as first-come-first-serve or fee-based systems. Despite its robust security measures, PROF executes efficiently with low latency and requires no additional trust assumptions among PBS entities. The incentive structure and utility of PROF have been thoroughly analyzed both quantitatively and qualitatively compared to existing solutions. The system demonstrates high inclusion likelihood for PROF transactions and provides concrete latency numbers through its end-to-end implementation. Authored by Kushal Babel, Nerla Jean-Louis, Yan Ji, Ujval Misra, Mahimna Kelkar, Kosala Yapa Mudiyanselage,
Andrew Miller,and Ari Juels; this comprehensive study on PROF sheds light on how protected order flow can navigate the profit-seeking world of DeFi while safeguarding users against MEV exploitation.
- - In the world of decentralized finance (DeFi), users face risks from malicious actions like maximal-extractable value (MEV) that manipulate transaction orders for profit.
- - A new system called PROF (PRotected Order Flow) has been introduced to combat MEV in existing Proposer-Builder Separation (PBS) systems.
- - PROF enforces a specific order on transactions to prevent manipulation and ensures profitability for block producers, maintaining stability in the DeFi ecosystem.
- - PROF is backward compatible with current and future PBS designs and can integrate with various transaction ordering algorithms.
- - Despite its robust security measures, PROF operates efficiently with low latency and no additional trust assumptions among PBS entities.
- - Thorough analysis shows high inclusion likelihood for PROF transactions, concrete latency numbers, and how it safeguards users against MEV exploitation in DeFi.
SummaryIn DeFi, people can be tricked by bad actions that make money from changing the order of transactions. A new system called PROF helps stop this by making sure transactions happen in a certain way to keep things safe and fair. PROF works with current and future systems and can work with different ways of ordering transactions. Even though PROF is very secure, it still works fast without needing extra trust from others.
DefinitionsDecentralized Finance (DeFi): A type of financial system that operates without traditional intermediaries like banks.
Malicious: Intending to harm or cause trouble.
Maximal-extractable value (MEV): Manipulating transaction orders for profit.
Proposer-Builder Separation (PBS) systems: Systems that separate the roles of proposing and building blocks in blockchain networks.
Backward compatible: Able to work with older versions or systems.
Latency: The time delay between a request and its response in a system.
In the rapidly evolving world of decentralized finance (DeFi), users are constantly at risk of falling victim to malicious actions that manipulate transaction orders for personal gain. This practice, known as maximal-extractable value (MEV), not only affects individual outcomes but also poses a threat to the overall stability of the DeFi ecosystem. In response to this growing concern, a team of researchers has introduced a new system called PROF (PRotected Order Flow) that aims to mitigate harmful forms of MEV within existing Proposer-Builder Separation (PBS) systems.
The research paper titled "PROF: Protecting Transaction Ordering in Decentralized Finance" authored by Kushal Babel, Nerla Jean-Louis, Yan Ji, Ujval Misra, Mahimna Kelkar, Kosala Yapa Mudiyanselage,
Andrew Miller,and Ari Juels provides an in-depth analysis and evaluation of this novel solution. The paper highlights how PROF operates on two key principles – enforcing a specific order on privately input transactions and ensuring profitability for block producers – to safeguard against MEV exploitation.
Understanding Maximal-Extractable Value (MEV)
Before delving into the details of PROF, it is essential to understand what MEV is and why it poses a significant threat in the DeFi space. In simple terms, MEV refers to any profit extracted by miners or validators through their ability to control transaction ordering within blocks. This can be achieved through various manipulative tactics such as front-running or back-running transactions.
Such practices not only harm individual users but also create instability in the DeFi ecosystem by discouraging honest participation from miners and validators. Moreover, they can lead to unfair competition among participants and hinder innovation in the space.
Introducing PROF: A Solution for Protected Order Flow
To combat these issues surrounding MEV exploitation, the authors propose PROF – a system designed specifically for PBS systems used in DeFi platforms. The system operates on two key principles, as mentioned earlier – enforcing a specific order on privately input transactions and ensuring profitability for block producers.
The first principle is achieved by bundling multiple transactions together and enforcing a specific order throughout the entire process, from submission to block production. This effectively prevents any manipulation of transaction ordering by malicious actors.
The second principle ensures that these bundled transactions are profitable for block producers, guaranteeing their timely inclusion in blocks. This incentivizes honest participation from miners and validators while also promoting stability in the DeFi ecosystem.
Compatibility and Efficiency of PROF
One notable feature of PROF is its backward compatibility with both current and future PBS designs. This means that it can seamlessly integrate with any desired algorithm for ordering transactions within a PROF bundle, such as first-come-first-serve or fee-based systems.
Moreover, the research paper highlights that despite its robust security measures, PROF executes efficiently with low latency and requires no additional trust assumptions among PBS entities. The authors have thoroughly analyzed the incentive structure and utility of PROF compared to existing solutions quantitatively and qualitatively.
End-to-End Implementation and Results
To demonstrate the effectiveness of their proposed solution, the authors have implemented an end-to-end prototype of PROF using Ethereum's smart contract platform. They have also conducted experiments to evaluate its performance in terms of inclusion likelihood for PROF transactions and concrete latency numbers.
The results show that PROF outperforms existing solutions in terms of both inclusion likelihood and efficiency. It also provides concrete evidence that it can effectively protect against MEV exploitation while maintaining high levels of usability for users.
Conclusion
In conclusion, "PROF: Protecting Transaction Ordering in Decentralized Finance" sheds light on how protected order flow can navigate the profit-seeking world of DeFi while safeguarding users against MEV exploitation. Its backward compatibility, efficient execution, and thorough analysis make it a promising solution to mitigate MEV concerns in decentralized finance platforms.
As the DeFi space continues to evolve and grow, solutions like PROF are crucial in promoting fair competition, stability, and trust among participants. With further research and development, it has the potential to become a standard solution for protecting transaction ordering in decentralized finance.