, , , ,
The study on building Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) systems for technical documents revealed the significant impact of chunk length on retriever embeddings. It was also noted that relying solely on similarity scores to augment the generator may not always be reliable. The use of abbreviations and a large number of related paragraphs were found to be particularly relevant for long-form Question Answering (QA) in technical documents. As part of future work, the researchers plan to incorporate RAG metrics proposed by Es et al. and Chen et al. to inform retrieval strategies and develop effective methods and evaluation metrics for addressing follow-up questions within the RAG framework. The experiments conducted focused on IEEE Wireless LAN Medium Access Control (MAC) and Physical Layer (PHY) specifications, as well as the IEEE Standard Glossary of Stationary Battery Terminology. By examining the influence of chunk length, keyword-based search, and rank of retrieved results in the RAG pipeline, the researchers aimed to gain a better understanding of factors affecting retrieval performance in technical document QA. Observations from the study showed that sentence embeddings become less reliable with increasing chunk size, as evidenced by a Kernel Density Estimate plot displaying high similarity scores for longer sentences. The distribution of higher similarities for larger lengths suggested spurious similarities, which were manually validated for accuracy. Additionally, it was highlighted that when both query and queried document exceeded 200 words, similarity distributions exhibited a bimodal nature. Overall, this research provides valuable insights into optimizing RAG systems for technical documents by addressing key challenges such as chunk length impact on retriever embeddings and reliability issues with generator augmentation strategies based on similarity scores. Future work will focus on leveraging advanced RAG metrics and developing innovative methods to enhance question answering capabilities within technical document contexts.
- - Chunk length has a significant impact on retriever embeddings in RAG systems for technical documents.
- - Relying solely on similarity scores to augment the generator may not always be reliable.
- - Abbreviations and a large number of related paragraphs are relevant for long-form Question Answering (QA) in technical documents.
- - Future work includes incorporating RAG metrics proposed by Es et al. and Chen et al., developing effective methods, and evaluation metrics for addressing follow-up questions within the RAG framework.
- - Experiments focused on IEEE Wireless LAN Medium Access Control (MAC) and Physical Layer (PHY) specifications, as well as the IEEE Standard Glossary of Stationary Battery Terminology.
- - Observations showed that sentence embeddings become less reliable with increasing chunk size, leading to spurious similarities that were manually validated for accuracy.
- - When both query and queried document exceeded 200 words, similarity distributions exhibited a bimodal nature.
Summary- The length of chunks (parts) is very important for finding information in technical documents.
- Just looking at how similar things are might not always give the right answers.
- Shortened words and lots of related paragraphs are useful for answering long questions in technical documents.
- In the future, they want to use new ways to measure success and find better methods for answering follow-up questions in a specific system.
- They did tests on some technical document topics and found that longer chunks can make it harder to find good matches.
Definitions- Chunk: A part or piece of something, like a section of text in a document.
- Embeddings: Representations of data or information in a different form, often used for organizing or searching through content.
- RAG systems: A type of system used for finding and generating answers from large amounts of text data.
- Abbreviations: Shortened forms of words or phrases used instead of writing them out fully each time.
Introduction
Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) systems have gained significant attention in recent years for their ability to improve question answering performance. These systems combine the strengths of both retrieval and generation models, allowing for more accurate and comprehensive answers to complex questions. However, there are still challenges in developing effective RAG systems for technical documents, which require specialized knowledge and understanding.
In this research paper, titled "Building Retrieval Augmented Generation Systems for Technical Documents," the authors explore the impact of chunk length on retriever embeddings and the reliability of using similarity scores as a basis for generator augmentation. The study focuses on technical documents from IEEE Wireless LAN Medium Access Control (MAC) and Physical Layer (PHY) specifications, as well as the IEEE Standard Glossary of Stationary Battery Terminology.
Background
The use of RAG systems has been shown to significantly improve question answering performance compared to traditional methods that rely solely on retrieval or generation models. However, these systems face unique challenges when applied to technical documents due to their specialized language and structure.
One key challenge is determining the optimal chunk length for retriever embeddings. Chunking refers to dividing a document into smaller sections or chunks before feeding it into a model. In RAG systems, these chunks are used by the retriever model to retrieve relevant information from a large corpus of documents. The authors note that longer chunks may result in spurious similarities between sentences, leading to unreliable retrievals.
Another challenge is relying solely on similarity scores as a measure of relevance between retrieved results and query questions. This approach may not always be reliable since it does not take into account other factors such as keyword-based search or rank of retrieved results.
Methodology
To address these challenges, the researchers conducted experiments using two different datasets: IEEE Wireless LAN MAC/PHY specifications and IEEE Standard Glossary of Stationary Battery Terminology. They used a pre-trained RAG model and varied the chunk length, keyword-based search, and rank of retrieved results to examine their impact on retrieval performance.
The experiments focused on two main metrics: retriever embeddings' similarity scores and the distribution of higher similarities for larger lengths. The researchers also manually validated the spurious similarities observed in the distributions.
Results
The results showed that chunk length has a significant impact on retriever embeddings' reliability. As chunk size increased, there was a decrease in similarity scores between query questions and retrieved sentences. This was evident from a Kernel Density Estimate plot displaying high similarity scores for shorter chunks compared to longer ones.
Furthermore, when both query questions and queried documents exceeded 200 words, the distribution of higher similarities exhibited a bimodal nature. This suggests that longer chunks may lead to spurious similarities between sentences, which can affect retrieval performance.
Discussion
Based on these findings, it is clear that chunk length plays a crucial role in determining the reliability of retriever embeddings in RAG systems for technical documents. Longer chunks may result in unreliable retrievals due to spurious similarities between sentences.
Moreover, relying solely on similarity scores as a measure of relevance may not always be reliable since it does not consider other factors such as keyword-based search or rank of retrieved results. This highlights the need for more advanced metrics and methods to improve question answering capabilities within technical document contexts.
Conclusion
In conclusion, this research provides valuable insights into optimizing RAG systems for technical documents by addressing key challenges such as chunk length impact on retriever embeddings and reliability issues with generator augmentation strategies based on similarity scores. The study also highlights the importance of developing advanced metrics and methods to enhance question answering capabilities within technical document contexts.
Future work will focus on incorporating RAG metrics proposed by previous studies and developing innovative methods to address follow-up questions within the RAG framework. This will further improve retrieval performance and enhance the overall effectiveness of RAG systems for technical documents.