In their paper "Proxy Methods for Domain Adaptation," Katherine Tsai, Stephen R. Pfohl, Olawale Salaudeen, Nicole Chiou, Matt J. Kusner, Alexander D'Amour, Sanmi Koyejo, and Arthur Gretton explore the problem of domain adaptation under distribution shift caused by changes in the distribution of an unobserved latent variable that affects both covariates and labels. They introduce a novel approach to adaptation using proximal causal learning - a technique that estimates causal effects when proxies of unobserved confounders are available. This method allows for adaptation to distribution shifts without explicitly modeling or recovering latent variables. The authors consider two specific settings: Concept Bottleneck and Multi-domain adaptation. In the Concept Bottleneck setting, an additional "concept" variable mediates the relationship between covariates and labels. In the Multi-domain setting, training data from multiple source domains with varying distributions over the latent confounder is utilized. To address complex distribution shifts in both settings, they develop a two-stage kernel estimation approach. To validate their approach, they conduct experiments demonstrating its superiority over other methods that explicitly recover the latent confounder. Additionally, they perform a small-scale experiment using chest X-ray data from the MIMIC-CXR dataset for classification tasks related to radiological findings. The results showcase the effectiveness of their method in handling distribution shifts similar to those observed in previous studies. Overall,this research contributes valuable insights into domain adaptation under distribution shift scenarios and presents a promising proxy-based approach for addressing such challenges effectively in various real-world applications.
- - Authors: Katherine Tsai, Stephen R. Pfohl, Olawale Salaudeen, Nicole Chiou, Matt J. Kusner, Alexander D'Amour, Sanmi Koyejo, and Arthur Gretton
- - Problem: Domain adaptation under distribution shift due to changes in the distribution of an unobserved latent variable affecting covariates and labels
- - Approach: Proximal causal learning technique for estimating causal effects with available proxies of unobserved confounders
- - Settings considered: Concept Bottleneck (additional "concept" variable mediates relationship) and Multi-domain adaptation (training data from multiple source domains with varying distributions over latent confounder)
- - Methodology: Two-stage kernel estimation approach developed to address complex distribution shifts in both settings
- - Validation: Experiments demonstrating superiority over methods explicitly recovering latent confounder; small-scale experiment using chest X-ray data from MIMIC-CXR dataset for classification tasks related to radiological findings
- - Results: Effective handling of distribution shifts similar to those observed in previous studies; promising proxy-based approach for real-world applications
SummaryAuthors Katherine Tsai, Stephen R. Pfohl, Olawale Salaudeen, Nicole Chiou, Matt J. Kusner, Alexander D'Amour, Sanmi Koyejo, and Arthur Gretton worked together on a problem called domain adaptation. This problem happens when there are changes in the distribution of something we can't see that affects the information we have and how we label things. They used a special technique to estimate causal effects by looking at other related information instead of the hidden variable directly. They tested their method in different situations where there were extra variables or data from various sources with different patterns. Their approach showed good results in handling these changes and could be useful for real-world tasks.
Definitions- Authors: People who wrote or created something.
- Domain adaptation: Dealing with changes in data distribution caused by unseen factors.
- Causal effects: Effects that one thing has on another due to a cause-and-effect relationship.
- Proxies: Stand-ins or substitutes for something else.
- Confounders: Hidden variables that can affect the relationship between other variables.
Domain adaptation is a crucial problem in machine learning, where the goal is to learn from a source domain and apply that knowledge to a different target domain. However, this becomes challenging when there is a distribution shift between the two domains caused by changes in an unobserved latent variable. In their paper "Proxy Methods for Domain Adaptation," Tsai et al. explore this problem and propose a novel approach using proximal causal learning.
The authors begin by introducing the concept of domain adaptation and its importance in real-world applications. They explain how traditional methods fail to address distribution shifts due to latent variables, which can significantly affect both covariates (input features) and labels (output classes). To overcome this limitation, they propose using proximal causal learning - a technique that estimates causal effects when proxies of unobserved confounders are available.
The main contribution of this research lies in its application of proximal causal learning to adapt models under complex distribution shifts without explicitly modeling or recovering the latent variable. The authors consider two specific settings: Concept Bottleneck and Multi-domain adaptation. In the Concept Bottleneck setting, an additional "concept" variable mediates the relationship between covariates and labels, while in Multi-domain adaptation, training data from multiple source domains with varying distributions over the latent confounder is utilized.
To address these complex distribution shifts effectively, Tsai et al. develop a two-stage kernel estimation approach. In the first stage, they estimate individual kernels for each source domain based on their respective proxy variables. Then in the second stage, they combine these individual kernels into one joint kernel using weights learned through optimization techniques such as gradient descent or cross-validation.
To validate their proposed method's effectiveness, the authors conduct experiments on synthetic datasets with known ground truth values for both covariates and labels. They compare their approach against other existing methods that explicitly recover the latent confounder and demonstrate its superiority in handling complex distribution shifts. Additionally, they perform a small-scale experiment using chest X-ray data from the MIMIC-CXR dataset for classification tasks related to radiological findings.
The results of their experiments showcase the effectiveness of their method in handling distribution shifts similar to those observed in previous studies. They also highlight how their approach outperforms other methods, especially when dealing with complex distribution shifts that cannot be easily modeled or recovered.
In conclusion, Tsai et al.'s research provides valuable insights into domain adaptation under distribution shift scenarios and presents a promising proxy-based approach for addressing such challenges effectively in various real-world applications. Their work opens up new possibilities for adapting models to changing environments without explicitly modeling or recovering latent variables, making it a significant contribution to the field of machine learning.