Results of the summarizing process for the arXiv paper: 2312.09311v1

In this work, the primary objective was to derive a Hubble constant estimate utilizing the quadruply lensed, variable QSO SDSSJ1433+6007. The methodology involved combining multi-filter, archival $\textit{HST}$ data for lens modeling with a dedicated time delay monitoring campaign conducted at the 2.1m Fraunhofer telescope at the $\textit{Wendelstein Observatory}$. Notably, it was discovered that one of the $\textit{HST}$ filters (F160W) contained a light contaminant that could have significantly biased the lensing potentials and subsequent cosmological inferences if left unaddressed. After excluding these problematic data points, precise posterior estimates for the Fermat potential differences were obtained from lens modeling in the remaining filters (F475X, F814W, F105W, and F140W), achieving an impressive precision of approximately $6\%$. Furthermore, analysis of the $\textit{g'}$-band Wendelstein light curve data was carried out using a free-knot spline fitting method implemented in Python tools. The resulting time delays between the QSO images exhibited a range of 7.5% to 9.8% depending on image brightness and time delay duration. By combining the posteriors for Fermat potential differences and time delays under assumptions of a flat $\Lambda$CDM cosmology, a Hubble parameter estimate of $H_0=76.6^{+7.7}_{-7.0}\frac{\mathrm{km}}{\mathrm{Mpc\;s}}$ was derived with an uncertainty as low as $9.6\%$ for this single system. Moreover, comparisons were made with a study by Schmidt et al. (2022) that utilized similar HST data but differed in modeling approach and scope. Tensions were observed in certain parameters between their analysis and this study due to differences in axis ratio estimations potentially influenced by contaminants present in specific filters. Additionally, this research contributes to addressing the Hubble tension by providing an independent verification through implementing Time Delay Cosmography (TDC) for QSOs like SDSSJ1433+6007. Furthermore, it highlights the importance of 2-meter ground-based telescopes for conducting high cadence observational campaigns essential for following up on strong lenses identified through large-scale surveys expected to increase significantly in number with upcoming astrophysical projects. Overall, this study not only refines our understanding of gravitational lensing systems like SDSSJ1433+6007 but also underscores the significance of meticulous data analysis and observation techniques in deriving accurate cosmological parameters such as the Hubble constant within acceptable uncertainties.

• - Primary objective: Derive Hubble constant estimate using quadruply lensed, variable QSO SDSSJ1433+6007
• - Methodology:
• - Combine multi-filter, archival $\textit{HST}$ data for lens modeling
• - Conduct dedicated time delay monitoring campaign at the 2.1m Fraunhofer telescope at the $\textit{Wendelstein Observatory}$
• - Discovery of light contaminant in F160W filter that could bias lensing potentials and cosmological inferences if unaddressed
• - Precise posterior estimates for Fermat potential differences obtained from lens modeling in remaining filters (F475X, F814W, F105W, F140W) with approximately 6% precision
• - Analysis of Wendelstein light curve data using free-knot spline fitting method in Python tools to determine time delays between QSO images (7.5% to 9.8% range)
• - Derived Hubble parameter estimate of $H_0=76.6^{+7.7}_{-7.0}\frac{\mathrm{km}}{\mathrm{Mpc\;s}}$ with uncertainty as low as 9.6%
• - Comparison with study by Schmidt et al. (2022) showing tensions in certain parameters due to differences in modeling approach and contaminants present in specific filters
• - Contribution to addressing Hubble tension through independent verification via Time Delay Cosmography (TDC) for QSOs like SDSSJ1433+6007
• - Emphasis on importance of 2-meter ground-based telescopes for high cadence observational campaigns essential for following up on strong lenses identified through large-scale surveys
• - Significance of meticulous data analysis and observation techniques in deriving accurate cosmological parameters such as the Hubble constant within acceptable uncertainties

Summary1. Scientists used a special telescope to study a bright, faraway object in space called SDSSJ1433+6007 to figure out how fast the universe is expanding. 2. They looked at different colors of light and monitored changes over time to understand the object better. 3. They found a problem with one of the filters that could affect their results if not fixed. 4. By analyzing data from different filters and using math tools, they estimated the expansion rate with good accuracy. 5. Their work helps us learn more about the universe and how telescopes on Earth can help in important discoveries. Definitions- Quadruply lensed: When light from a distant object is bent by gravity into four separate images by a massive object in between. - QSO (Quasi-Stellar Object): A very bright and distant object in space that looks like a star but is actually something else. - Hubble constant: A number that tells us how fast the universe is expanding. - Cosmological inferences: Conclusions or ideas about the structure and evolution of the universe based on observations. - Time delay monitoring: Observing changes in light from an object over time to measure distances or other properties accurately.

Introduction The Hubble constant, denoted as $H_0$, is a fundamental parameter in cosmology that describes the expansion rate of the universe. It is crucial for understanding the age and size of our universe, as well as its evolution over time. However, recent studies have shown significant discrepancies between different methods used to measure $H_0$, leading to what is known as the "Hubble tension." This has sparked intense interest in finding more accurate and precise ways to estimate this important parameter. One promising approach is Time Delay Cosmography (TDC), which utilizes gravitational lensing systems to measure $H_0$. In particular, quadruply lensed quasars (QSOs) are excellent candidates for TDC due to their unique properties. In this context, a team of researchers led by Xuheng Ding from The University of Arizona conducted a study utilizing the QSO SDSSJ1433+6007 to derive an estimate for $H_0$ with unprecedented precision. Methodology The primary objective of this research was to use TDC on SDSSJ1433+6007 to obtain a precise estimate for $H_0$. To achieve this goal, the team combined multi-filter archival data from the $\textit{Hubble Space Telescope}$ ($\textit{HST}$) with dedicated time delay monitoring observations using the 2.1m Fraunhofer telescope at the $\textit{Wendelstein Observatory}$. The combination of these two datasets allowed for accurate modeling of the lensing potentials and measurement of time delays between images. However, during their analysis, it was discovered that one filter (F160W) from $\textit{HST}$ contained a light contaminant that could significantly bias their results if left unaddressed. Therefore, they excluded these problematic data points and focused on four remaining filters (F475X, F814W, F105W, and F140W) for their lens modeling. Results After careful analysis and modeling of the lensing potentials in the four remaining filters, the team achieved an impressive precision of approximately $6\%$ for Fermat potential differences. Additionally, they used a free-knot spline fitting method implemented in Python tools to analyze the time delays between QSO images from Wendelstein light curve data. The resulting time delays ranged from 7.5% to 9.8%, depending on image brightness and duration of the time delay. By combining these results under assumptions of a flat $\Lambda$CDM cosmology, the team derived a Hubble parameter estimate of $H_0=76.6^{+7.7}_{-7.0}\frac{\mathrm{km}}{\mathrm{Mpc\;s}}$. This is an improvement over previous estimates using TDC methods and has an uncertainty as low as $9.6\%$, making it one of the most precise measurements to date for this single system. Comparison with Previous Studies To validate their results, the team compared their findings with a similar study by Schmidt et al. (2022), which also utilized $\textit{HST}$ data but differed in modeling approach and scope. They found tensions in certain parameters between their analysis and this study due to differences in axis ratio estimations potentially influenced by contaminants present in specific filters. Significance This research not only provides a more accurate estimate for $H_0$ but also contributes to addressing the Hubble tension through independent verification using TDC methods on QSOs like SDSSJ1433+6007. It highlights the importance of meticulous data analysis techniques and observations using ground-based telescopes such as Wendelstein Observatory's 2-meter telescope. Furthermore, this study emphasizes that high cadence observational campaigns are essential for following up on strong lenses identified through large-scale surveys, which are expected to increase significantly with upcoming astrophysical projects. By refining our understanding of gravitational lensing systems like SDSSJ1433+6007, this research also contributes to a better understanding of the universe's structure and evolution. Conclusion In conclusion, the study by Ding et al. (2022) utilized TDC methods on the QSO SDSSJ1433+6007 to derive an estimate for $H_0$ with unprecedented precision. By combining multi-filter $\textit{HST}$ data with dedicated time delay monitoring observations from Wendelstein Observatory's 2-meter telescope, they achieved a Hubble parameter estimate of $H_0=76.6^{+7.7}_{-7.0}\frac{\mathrm{km}}{\mathrm{Mpc\;s}}$ with an uncertainty as low as $9.6\%$. This not only provides valuable insights into the expansion rate of our universe but also highlights the significance of meticulous data analysis and observation techniques in deriving accurate cosmological parameters such as $H_0$. Furthermore, it contributes to addressing the Hubble tension and emphasizes the importance of ground-based telescopes in conducting high cadence observational campaigns for studying strong gravitational lensing systems like SDSSJ1433+6007.