The study "Short Answer Grading Using One-shot Prompting and Text Similarity Scoring Model," conducted by Su-Youn Yoon, developed an automated short answer grading (ASAG) model that provides both analytic and holistic scores. This approach enhances the interpretability of the scoring system and enables actionable feedback for students to improve their learning process. By utilizing a large language model (LLM)-based one-shot prompting technique and a text similarity scoring model with domain adaptation using a small manually annotated dataset, this research addresses challenges in constructing datasets with manual annotations. The ASAG model achieved an accuracy of 0.67 and a quadratic weighted kappa of 0.71 when evaluated on a subset of the publicly available ASAG dataset, showing significant improvement over the majority baseline. This study highlights the potential benefits of incorporating analytic scoring methods in automated short answer grading systems and emphasizes the importance of providing detailed feedback to enhance student learning outcomes. The innovative use of advanced language models and text similarity scoring techniques demonstrates promising results in improving the efficiency and effectiveness of assessing short answer responses in educational settings.
- - Study developed an automated short answer grading (ASAG) model providing analytic and holistic scores
- - Approach enhances interpretability of scoring system and enables actionable feedback for students
- - Utilized large language model (LLM)-based one-shot prompting technique and text similarity scoring model with domain adaptation
- - ASAG model achieved accuracy of 0.67 and quadratic weighted kappa of 0.71 on subset of publicly available dataset
- - Significant improvement over majority baseline observed
- - Emphasizes benefits of incorporating analytic scoring methods in automated short answer grading systems
- - Importance of providing detailed feedback to enhance student learning outcomes highlighted
- - Innovative use of advanced language models and text similarity scoring techniques shows promising results in assessing short answer responses
Summary1. A study created a computer program that can grade short answers and give scores.
2. This program helps teachers understand how students did and gives advice to improve.
3. They used a big language model and special techniques to make the program work well.
4. The program was accurate in grading answers on a test dataset.
5. It is important to use this kind of technology to help students learn better.
Definitions- Automated Short Answer Grading (ASAG): A computerized system that grades short written responses automatically.
- Analytic scoring: Evaluating answers based on specific criteria or components rather than just overall impression.
- Holistic scoring: Evaluating answers based on overall impression or general quality rather than specific components.
- Language model: A type of artificial intelligence system that understands and generates human language.
- Text similarity scoring: Comparing written text to see how similar they are in content or meaning.
The Study: "Short Answer Grading Using One-shot Prompting and Text Similarity Scoring Model" by Su-Youn Yoon
In recent years, there has been a growing interest in developing automated systems for grading short answer responses in educational settings. This is due to the increasing demand for efficient and effective assessment methods, as well as the availability of advanced technologies such as natural language processing (NLP) and machine learning. However, one of the main challenges in constructing these systems is obtaining accurate and reliable scoring results.
To address this issue, Su-Youn Yoon conducted a study titled "Short Answer Grading Using One-shot Prompting and Text Similarity Scoring Model." The aim of this research was to develop an automated short answer grading (ASAG) model that provides both analytic and holistic scores. This approach not only enhances the interpretability of the scoring system but also enables actionable feedback for students to improve their learning process.
The Methodology
The ASAG model developed by Yoon utilizes two key techniques - large language model (LLM)-based one-shot prompting and text similarity scoring with domain adaptation using a small manually annotated dataset. Let's take a closer look at each technique:
Large Language Model-Based One-Shot Prompting
One-shot prompting is a technique used to generate prompts or questions from existing data without requiring additional human input. In this study, Yoon utilized LLMs which are pre-trained models on large amounts of text data. These models have shown impressive performance in various NLP tasks such as question answering and text generation.
By utilizing LLM-based one-shot prompting, the ASAG model can generate diverse prompts for different types of questions without relying on handcrafted features or templates. This not only reduces manual effort but also improves generalizability across different domains.
Text Similarity Scoring with Domain Adaptation
The second technique used in the ASAG model is text similarity scoring with domain adaptation. This involves comparing the student's response to a reference answer and assigning a score based on their level of similarity. To improve accuracy, Yoon incorporated domain adaptation techniques that adapt the scoring model to different domains by using a small manually annotated dataset.
The Results
To evaluate the performance of the ASAG model, Yoon tested it on a subset of the publicly available ASAG dataset. The results showed an accuracy of 0.67 and a quadratic weighted kappa of 0.71, which are significant improvements over the majority baseline.
These results demonstrate the potential benefits of incorporating analytic scoring methods in automated short answer grading systems. By providing both holistic and analytic scores, this approach not only improves interpretability but also allows for more detailed feedback for students to enhance their learning process.
Implications for Education
This study highlights the importance of providing detailed feedback to students in educational settings. With traditional manual grading methods, it can be challenging for teachers to provide timely and specific feedback to each student. However, with automated short answer grading systems like ASAG, teachers can focus on interpreting and analyzing scores rather than spending time on manual grading.
Moreover, by utilizing advanced language models and text similarity scoring techniques, these systems can efficiently assess large volumes of responses without compromising accuracy or reliability. This not only saves time but also enables teachers to identify common misconceptions or areas where students may need additional support.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Su-Youn Yoon's study "Short Answer Grading Using One-shot Prompting and Text Similarity Scoring Model" demonstrates promising results in automating short answer grading processes in educational settings. By utilizing LLM-based one-shot prompting and text similarity scoring with domain adaptation techniques, this research addresses challenges in constructing datasets with manual annotations and improves the efficiency and effectiveness of short answer assessment. The incorporation of analytic scoring methods also highlights the potential benefits of providing detailed feedback to enhance student learning outcomes. This study serves as a valuable contribution to the field of automated short answer grading and emphasizes the importance of incorporating advanced technologies in educational assessments.