Results of the summarizing process for the arXiv paper: 2304.08126v2

In their paper titled "Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy beyond linearity and stationarity - a critical review," authors Noël Hallemans, David Howey, Alberto Battistel, Nessa Fereshteh Saniee, Federico Scarpioni, Benny Wouters, Fabio La Mantia, Annick Hubin, Widanalage Dhammika Widanage, and John Lataire delve into the realm of electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) with a focus on nonlinear and time-varying impedances. EIS is a commonly used experimental technique for studying materials and electrode reactions by analyzing their frequency-dependent impedance. The traditional approach to EIS assumes that the electrochemical process behaves as a linear time-invariant system. However, real-world electrochemical processes such as metal substrate corrosion and Li-ion battery cycling are inherently nonlinear and evolve over time. The authors highlight that classical EIS methods provide models that are linearized at specific operating points, limiting their applicability in capturing the full complexity of these dynamic systems. Over the past decade, researchers have developed solutions to estimate nonlinear and time-varying impedances, leading to more comprehensive models. In this critical review,the authors explore the concept of impedance beyond linearity and stationarity and present various methods for estimating these complex impedances from measured current and voltage data. A key emphasis is placed on frequency domain approaches using multisine excitation techniques. Through mathematical discussions and practical examples involving impedance estimation for a Li-ion battery under different conditions (resting and charging), the authors showcase the importance of considering nonlinearity and time variation in electrochemical systems. By pushing the boundaries of traditional EIS methodologies,this review contributes to advancing our understanding of complex electrochemical processes and paves the way for more accurate modeling techniques in this field.

• - Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) is a technique used for studying materials and electrode reactions by analyzing frequency-dependent impedance.
• - Real-world electrochemical processes are often nonlinear and time-varying, such as metal substrate corrosion and Li-ion battery cycling.
• - Traditional EIS methods assume linearity at specific operating points, limiting their applicability in capturing the full complexity of dynamic systems.
• - Researchers have developed solutions to estimate nonlinear and time-varying impedances, leading to more comprehensive models over the past decade.
• - The paper explores impedance beyond linearity and stationarity, presenting various methods for estimating complex impedances from measured current and voltage data.
• - Frequency domain approaches using multisine excitation techniques are emphasized in the exploration of nonlinearity and time variation in electrochemical systems.
• - Mathematical discussions and practical examples involving impedance estimation for a Li-ion battery under different conditions highlight the importance of considering nonlinearity and time variation.
• - By challenging traditional EIS methodologies, this review contributes to advancing understanding of complex electrochemical processes and improving modeling techniques.

SummaryElectrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) is a way to study materials and reactions by looking at how they respond to different frequencies. Real-life electrochemical processes, like metal rusting or batteries charging, can change over time and are not always simple. Some older methods for studying these processes assume things stay the same at certain points, which doesn't always work well for dynamic systems. Scientists have found new ways to estimate more complex changes in these processes, making their models better. They use special techniques to send signals at different frequencies to understand how things change over time. Definitions- Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS): A method used to analyze how materials and reactions behave when exposed to different frequencies. - Nonlinear: Refers to situations where the relationship between variables is not proportional or straightforward. - Time-varying: Describes processes that change or evolve over time. - Impedance: The measure of opposition a material offers to the flow of an alternating current. - Frequency domain approaches: Techniques that focus on analyzing signals in terms of their frequency components.

Introduction

Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) is a powerful experimental technique used to study the electrical properties of materials and electrode reactions. It involves measuring the frequency-dependent impedance of a system by applying an AC voltage or current signal and analyzing the resulting response. EIS has been widely used in various fields, including corrosion studies, fuel cells, batteries, and sensors. Traditionally, EIS assumes that the electrochemical process under investigation behaves as a linear time-invariant (LTI) system. This means that the system's behavior does not change over time and can be described by linear equations. However, many real-world electrochemical processes are inherently nonlinear and evolve over time due to factors such as aging, degradation, or changes in operating conditions. These complexities cannot be captured by traditional LTI models. In their paper titled "Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy beyond linearity and stationarity - a critical review," authors Noël Hallemans et al. delve into this topic with a focus on nonlinear and time-varying impedances. They highlight the limitations of traditional EIS methods and present various approaches for estimating these complex impedances from measured data.

Background: Traditional EIS Methods

The traditional approach to EIS involves applying small sinusoidal perturbations around an operating point while keeping other parameters constant. The resulting current response is then analyzed using equivalent circuit models to estimate the system's impedance at different frequencies. This method works well for systems that behave linearly within a specific range of operating conditions. However, it fails to capture nonlinearity when the system deviates from its operating point or when multiple processes occur simultaneously at different timescales. To overcome these limitations, researchers have developed alternative methods for estimating nonlinear and time-varying impedances from measured data.

Frequency Domain Approaches

One promising approach for estimating nonlinear and time-varying impedances is through frequency domain analysis using multisine excitation techniques. Multisine signals are composed of multiple sinusoidal waves with different frequencies, amplitudes, and phases. By analyzing the system's response to these signals, it is possible to estimate its frequency-dependent impedance without assuming linearity or stationarity. The authors discuss various methods for generating multisine signals and extracting impedance information from the resulting data. These include Fourier-based methods such as harmonic distortion analysis (HDA) and periodic steady-state (PSS) analysis, as well as model-based approaches like Volterra series analysis.

Practical Examples

To demonstrate the effectiveness of these methods, the authors provide practical examples involving EIS measurements on a Li-ion battery under different conditions. They compare traditional LTI models with more advanced nonlinear and time-varying models estimated using multisine excitation techniques. Their results show that traditional LTI models fail to capture the full complexity of the battery's behavior under different operating conditions. In contrast, nonlinear and time-varying models provide a much better fit to the measured data and can accurately predict system behavior over a wider range of operating conditions.

Conclusion

In their critical review, Hallemans et al. highlight the importance of considering nonlinearity and time variation in electrochemical systems beyond traditional EIS methodologies. By exploring various approaches for estimating complex impedances from measured data, they contribute to advancing our understanding of dynamic electrochemical processes. This review also emphasizes the potential for using frequency domain techniques with multisine excitation signals in future research on electrochemical systems. By moving away from linear assumptions towards more comprehensive models that account for nonlinearity and time variation, we can improve our ability to accurately model complex electrochemical processes in various applications. Overall,this paper provides valuable insights into current research efforts aimed at pushing the boundaries of traditional EIS methods and opens up new possibilities for future studies in this field.