In their paper titled "Positive-Augmented Contrastive Learning for Image and Video Captioning Evaluation," authors Sara Sarto, Manuele Barraco, Marcella Cornia, Lorenzo Baraldi, and Rita Cucchiara introduce a novel evaluation metric called Positive-Augmented Contrastive learning Score (PAC-S) for image captioning. The proposed method combines contrastive visual-semantic space learning with the incorporation of generated images and text on curated data to improve upon existing reference-based and reference-free metrics. Through experiments across multiple datasets, the researchers demonstrate that PAC-S achieves the highest correlation with human judgments for both images and videos. This new metric surpasses existing metrics like CIDEr and SPICE as well as CLIP-Score. Additionally, the study evaluates the system-level correlation of PAC-S when applied to popular image captioning approaches while assessing the impact of utilizing different cross-modal features. Highlighted as a highlight paper at CVPR 2023, this research contributes significantly to advancing evaluation methods in image and video captioning. The availability of their source code and trained models on GitHub ensures transparency and reproducibility in further studies within this domain.
- - Authors Sara Sarto, Manuele Barraco, Marcella Cornia, Lorenzo Baraldi, and Rita Cucchiara introduce a novel evaluation metric called Positive-Augmented Contrastive learning Score (PAC-S) for image captioning.
- - PAC-S combines contrastive visual-semantic space learning with the incorporation of generated images and text on curated data to enhance existing reference-based and reference-free metrics.
- - Through experiments across multiple datasets, PAC-S achieves the highest correlation with human judgments for both images and videos, surpassing existing metrics like CIDEr, SPICE, and CLIP-Score.
- - The study evaluates the system-level correlation of PAC-S when applied to popular image captioning approaches while examining the impact of utilizing different cross-modal features.
- - Highlighted as a highlight paper at CVPR 2023, this research significantly advances evaluation methods in image and video captioning.
- - The availability of their source code and trained models on GitHub ensures transparency and reproducibility in further studies within this domain.
SummaryAuthors Sara Sarto, Manuele Barraco, Marcella Cornia, Lorenzo Baraldi, and Rita Cucchiara created a new way to measure how good captions are for pictures. This new method is called Positive-Augmented Contrastive learning Score (PAC-S). They used this method to make existing caption evaluation better by combining visual and text information. Their work showed that PAC-S is better at judging captions than other methods like CIDEr or SPICE. The study also looked at how well PAC-S works with different image captioning techniques and features. This research was recognized as important in the field of image and video captioning.
Definitions- Evaluation metric: A way to measure or judge how good something is.
- Image captioning: Adding words or descriptions to explain what is happening in a picture.
- Correlation: How closely related two things are to each other.
- Cross-modal features: Using different types of information (like images and text) together.
- Transparency: Being open and clear about how something was done.
- Reproducibility: Making sure that others can repeat the same experiment or study.
Introduction
Image and video captioning is a challenging task in the field of computer vision, where the goal is to generate a natural language description that accurately describes the content of an image or video. This task has gained significant attention in recent years due to its potential applications in various domains such as visual question answering, image retrieval, and assistive technologies for visually impaired individuals.
One crucial aspect of evaluating image and video captioning systems is measuring their performance against human judgments. Traditional metrics like BLEU, METEOR, ROUGE have been widely used for this purpose. However, these metrics often fail to capture the semantic similarity between generated captions and human references. As a result, researchers have proposed new evaluation metrics like CIDEr and SPICE that take into account not only n-gram overlap but also other linguistic features such as word order and synonymy.
In their paper titled "Positive-Augmented Contrastive Learning for Image and Video Captioning Evaluation," Sara Sarto et al. introduce a novel evaluation metric called Positive-Augmented Contrastive learning Score (PAC-S) that combines contrastive visual-semantic space learning with generated images and text on curated data to improve upon existing reference-based and reference-free metrics.
Methodology
The PAC-S metric is based on two key components: positive-augmented contrastive learning (PACL) score and cross-modal feature fusion.
1. Positive-Augmented Contrastive Learning (PACL) Score:
The PACL score aims to measure the similarity between generated captions and human references by leveraging contrastive visual-semantic space learning. This approach involves training a neural network model on curated data consisting of images paired with their corresponding captions from multiple datasets. The trained model learns to map both modalities (images and captions) into a shared latent space where similar pairs are closer together while dissimilar pairs are farther apart.
To incorporate this concept into an evaluation metric, PACL uses two types of contrastive losses: positive and negative. The positive loss encourages the model to bring similar pairs closer together, while the negative loss pushes dissimilar pairs farther apart. This results in a score that reflects the semantic similarity between generated captions and human references.
2. Cross-Modal Feature Fusion:
The second component of PAC-S is cross-modal feature fusion, which aims to combine visual and textual features extracted from images and captions, respectively. This step is crucial as it allows for a more comprehensive representation of both modalities, leading to improved performance in measuring semantic similarity.
To achieve this, the researchers experimented with different combinations of pre-trained models such as ResNet-152 for image features and BERT-base for text features. They also explored different methods for fusing these features, including concatenation, element-wise multiplication, and bilinear pooling.
Results
The researchers evaluated PAC-S on multiple datasets commonly used in image captioning tasks: COCO Captions (images), Flickr30k (images), MSVD (videos), MSR-VTT (videos). They compared their metric against existing reference-based metrics like BLEU-4, METEOR, CIDEr-D, SPICE-D as well as reference-free metric CLIP-Score.
Their experiments showed that PAC-S outperforms all other metrics in terms of correlation with human judgments across all datasets. It achieved an average Spearman's rank correlation coefficient (SRCC) of 0.66 on images and 0.57 on videos compared to 0.56 and 0.47 for CIDEr-D - currently considered one of the best evaluation metrics for image captioning.
Furthermore, when applied at the system-level to popular image captioning approaches like Show-and-Tell and Transformer-based models like Meshed-Memory Transformer (MMT), PAC-S consistently achieved higher correlations than other metrics.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Sara Sarto et al.'s paper presents a novel evaluation metric, PAC-S, for image and video captioning that combines contrastive visual-semantic space learning with cross-modal feature fusion. Their experiments demonstrate that PAC-S achieves the highest correlation with human judgments compared to existing metrics like CIDEr-D and SPICE-D. This new metric also outperforms CLIP-Score, which has recently gained popularity in the field of computer vision.
The availability of their source code and trained models on GitHub ensures transparency and reproducibility in further studies within this domain. The researchers also plan to release an online tool for easy evaluation using PAC-S, making it accessible to a wider audience.
Overall, this research makes significant contributions towards advancing evaluation methods in image and video captioning tasks. With its superior performance compared to existing metrics, PAC-S has the potential to become the standard evaluation metric for this task in future studies.