Results of the summarizing process for the arXiv paper: 2207.10744v1

The study by Pirovano et al. (2022) investigates the distribution of H$_2$O in the protoplanetary discs of two Herbig Ae stars using far-infrared observations from Herschel. The researchers found a surprisingly low abundance of cold-water reservoirs in these discs, with only a few showing emission of hot water transitions at temperatures above a few hundred Kelvin. This suggests an intricate interplay between water distribution, dust dynamics, and planet-disc interactions within protoplanetary systems around Herbig Ae stars. Using the thermo-chemical model DALI and conducting spectral analysis, the team observed opposite trends in the two systems: while ground-state transitions were detected in HD 100546 and high-J lines were undetected, the trend was reversed in HD 163296. They determined that HD 163296 has a water-rich hot inner disc within the snowline (abundance $\gtrsim 10^{-5}$) and a water-poor outer disc ($< 10^{-10}$), possibly due to thermal desorption of icy grains migrating inward. Remarkably, they also found that the size of the H$_2$O emitting region in HD 163296 corresponds to a narrow dust gap seen at $r=10\,$au with ALMA. Similarly, low-J lines detected in HD 100546 indicate an abundance of a few $10^{-9}$ in the cold outer disc ($>40$ au), with spatial coincidence between cold H$_2$O transitions and previously observed H$_2$O ice in the near-infrared. Further supporting their findings are ALMA observations revealing large dust gaps between approximately 40 and 150 au in both systems - likely created by massive embedded protoplanets. The study also found that the warm molecular layer beyond the snow line is highly depleted of water molecules, suggesting an oxygen-poor chemical composition of gas. This depletion indicates that gas-phase oxygen is readily consumed and its distribution is closely linked to dust grain dynamics within the discs. In summary, this research provides valuable insights into the complex interplay between water distribution, dust dynamics, and planet-disc interactions within protoplanetary systems around Herbig Ae stars.

• - Study by Pirovano et al. (2022) on H$_2$O distribution in protoplanetary discs of two Herbig Ae stars using far-infrared observations from Herschel
• - Low abundance of cold-water reservoirs in the discs, with few showing emission of hot water transitions above a few hundred Kelvin
• - Intricate interplay between water distribution, dust dynamics, and planet-disc interactions within protoplanetary systems around Herbig Ae stars
• - Opposite trends observed in the two systems: ground-state transitions detected in HD 100546 but high-J lines undetected; trend reversed in HD 163296
• - HD 163296 has a water-rich hot inner disc within the snowline and a water-poor outer disc, possibly due to thermal desorption of icy grains migrating inward
• - Size of H$_2$O emitting region in HD 163296 corresponds to a narrow dust gap seen at $r=10\,$au with ALMA
• - Low-J lines detected in HD 100546 indicate an abundance of a few $10^{-9}$ in the cold outer disc ($>40$ au), spatial coincidence with previously observed H$_2$O ice in near-infrared
• - ALMA observations reveal large dust gaps between approximately 40 and 150 au likely created by massive embedded protoplanets
• - Warm molecular layer beyond the snow line highly depleted of water molecules, suggesting oxygen-poor chemical composition of gas
• - Depletion indicates gas-phase oxygen readily consumed and closely linked to dust grain dynamics within the discs

Summary- Scientists studied how water is distributed in the spinning discs around two bright young stars using a special telescope called Herschel. - They found that there isn't much cold water in these discs, and only a few of them have hot water above a certain temperature. - The way water is spread out in these systems is connected to how dust moves and how planets interact with the discs. - The two star systems they looked at showed different patterns: one had low-energy water lines while the other had high-energy ones. - One star system has a lot of hot water close to the center but not much farther out, maybe because icy grains are melting as they move inward. Definitions- Protoplanetary disc: A rotating disk of gas and dust surrounding a young star, where planets may form. - Far-infrared: Type of light with longer wavelengths than visible light, used to study cool objects in space. - Herbig Ae stars: Young stars more massive than our Sun that are still surrounded by protoplanetary discs. - Emission: Sending out or producing something like light or heat. - Thermal desorption: Process where icy materials turn into gas when heated.

Protoplanetary discs are the birthplace of planets, and understanding their chemical composition is crucial in unraveling the mysteries of planet formation. In a recent study by Pirovano et al. (2022), researchers used far-infrared observations from Herschel to investigate the distribution of water (H$_2$O) in the protoplanetary discs of two Herbig Ae stars - HD 100546 and HD 163296. The results revealed surprising insights into the intricate interplay between water distribution, dust dynamics, and planet-disc interactions within these systems. The team utilized data from Herschel's HIFI instrument, which is specifically designed for high-resolution spectroscopy in the far-infrared range. This allowed them to detect both cold and hot water transitions at different temperatures within the protoplanetary discs. The findings were unexpected as they showed a low abundance of cold-water reservoirs in these discs, with only a few showing emission of hot water transitions at temperatures above a few hundred Kelvin. To understand this phenomenon further, the researchers used a thermo-chemical model called DALI (Dust And LInes) to simulate the physical conditions within these protoplanetary discs. They also conducted spectral analysis to study how different factors such as temperature and density affect the distribution of water molecules. Interestingly, opposite trends were observed in HD 100546 and HD 163296 - while ground-state transitions were detected in HD 100546 and high-J lines were undetected, it was reversed for HD 163296. This suggests that each system has its unique characteristics that influence water distribution differently. One significant finding was that HD 163296 has a hot inner disc rich in water molecules (abundance $\gtrsim10^{-5}$) within its snowline - where temperatures are warm enough for ice grains to sublimate into gas form. However, beyond this region lies an outer disc with a significantly lower abundance of water molecules ($<10^{-10}$). The researchers believe that this could be due to thermal desorption of icy grains migrating inward, leaving the outer disc depleted of water. Remarkably, the size of the H$_2$O emitting region in HD 163296 corresponds to a narrow dust gap observed at $r=10\,$au with ALMA (Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array). This suggests that massive embedded protoplanets may have created these gaps by clearing out material and altering the distribution of water molecules within the disc. Similarly, low-J lines detected in HD 100546 indicate an abundance of a few $10^{-9}$ in its cold outer disc ($>40$ au), which is consistent with previous observations of H$_2$O ice in the near-infrared. Additionally, ALMA observations revealed large dust gaps between approximately 40 and 150 au in both systems - further supporting the presence of massive protoplanets shaping their discs. The study also found that beyond the snowline, there is a highly depleted warm molecular layer with low levels of water molecules. This depletion indicates an oxygen-poor chemical composition of gas and suggests that gas-phase oxygen is readily consumed and closely linked to dust grain dynamics within these discs. In conclusion, this research provides valuable insights into the complex interplay between water distribution, dust dynamics, and planet-disc interactions within protoplanetary systems around Herbig Ae stars. It highlights how different factors such as temperature, density, and planetary formation can affect the distribution of water molecules within these discs. Further studies using advanced instruments like Herschel will continue to unravel more mysteries about planet formation and provide a better understanding of our own solar system's origins.