The National Science Foundation (NSF) Project Scoping Workshop report titled "Towards Precise and Accurate Calculations of Neutrinoless Double-Beta Decay" provides a comprehensive assessment of the current state of calculations for the nuclear matrix elements governing neutrinoless double-beta decay. The workshop aimed to determine if further work is needed in this area and to outline a roadmap for future research. The report highlights recent advancements in effective field theory, lattice quantum chromodynamics, and ab initio nuclear-structure theory as applied to double-beta decay. It also discusses the state-of-the-art in nuclear-physics uncertainty quantification and proposes specific projects in theoretical and computational physics to enhance the accuracy and precision of matrix element calculations. One key aspect of the roadmap is the incorporation of Bayesian Model Mixing for uncertainty quantification, along with an analysis of correlations between double-beta-decay rates and other observables. By delivering accurate matrix elements with carefully assessed uncertainties across all nuclei relevant to experimentalists, these calculations will enable clear conclusions to be drawn from observations or non-observations of neutrinoless double-beta decay, regardless of any new physics that may be at play. The authors acknowledge that while this report focuses on the US context for neutrinoless double beta decay theory, they plan to expand their scope in a forthcoming journal article to include non-US efforts on this topic. They welcome additional input to further refine their text before submission.
- - The NSF Project Scoping Workshop report focuses on calculations for nuclear matrix elements in neutrinoless double-beta decay
- - Recent advancements in effective field theory, lattice quantum chromodynamics, and ab initio nuclear-structure theory are highlighted
- - Proposed projects aim to enhance accuracy and precision of matrix element calculations in theoretical and computational physics
- - Incorporation of Bayesian Model Mixing for uncertainty quantification is a key aspect of the roadmap
- - Analysis of correlations between double-beta-decay rates and other observables is discussed
- - Delivering accurate matrix elements with carefully assessed uncertainties will enable clear conclusions from observations or non-observations of neutrinoless double-beta decay
- - Authors plan to expand scope beyond the US context in a forthcoming journal article
SummaryThe report talks about doing math for a special kind of nuclear change. It mentions new ways scientists are getting better at understanding this math. They want to make the calculations more accurate in physics. They use a special method to measure how sure they are about their answers. They also look at how different things relate to the nuclear changes.
Definitions- Nuclear matrix elements: Numbers used in calculations for certain types of nuclear reactions.
- Neutrinoless double-beta decay: A rare process where some atomic nuclei change without releasing particles called neutrinos.
- Effective field theory: A way of studying interactions between particles in physics.
- Lattice quantum chromodynamics: A method for simulating interactions between subatomic particles using a grid-like structure.
- Ab initio nuclear-structure theory: A theoretical approach to understanding the structure and behavior of atomic nuclei from first principles.
- Bayesian Model Mixing: A statistical technique used to combine different models or sources of information while considering uncertainties.
- Uncertainty quantification: The process of estimating and managing uncertainties or errors in scientific measurements or predictions.
- Double-beta-decay rates: The speed at which certain atomic nuclei undergo a specific type of radioactive decay.
Introduction:
The search for neutrinoless double-beta decay (0νββ) has been a major focus of nuclear and particle physics research for several decades. This rare process, if observed, would provide evidence for the violation of lepton number conservation and could shed light on the nature of neutrinos and their role in the evolution of the universe. However, detecting 0νββ is challenging due to its extremely low probability and requires precise knowledge of the nuclear matrix elements (NMEs) governing this process. The National Science Foundation (NSF) Project Scoping Workshop report titled "Towards Precise and Accurate Calculations of Neutrinoless Double-Beta Decay" provides a comprehensive assessment of the current state of calculations for these NMEs.
Background:
Neutrinoless double-beta decay is a hypothetical radioactive decay process where two neutrons inside an atomic nucleus simultaneously transform into two protons with no emission of neutrinos. This process can only occur if neutrinos are Majorana particles, meaning they are their own antiparticles. While there have been several experimental claims for observing 0νββ, none have been confirmed yet. Therefore, it is crucial to improve our understanding and calculation methods for NMEs to accurately predict 0νββ rates.
Workshop Goals:
The NSF workshop aimed to evaluate whether further work is needed in calculating NMEs for 0νββ decays and to outline a roadmap for future research in this area. The workshop brought together experts from different fields such as effective field theory, lattice quantum chromodynamics (QCD), ab initio nuclear-structure theory, uncertainty quantification, and Bayesian model mixing.
Recent Advancements:
The report highlights recent advancements in effective field theory techniques that allow us to systematically incorporate higher-order corrections into calculations. These techniques have shown promising results in reducing theoretical uncertainties associated with NME calculations.
Additionally, lattice QCD, a powerful tool for studying the strong nuclear force, has been used to calculate NMEs with increasing accuracy. This approach provides a first-principles calculation of NMEs and can be extended to include more complex nuclei.
Ab initio nuclear-structure theory, which uses fundamental interactions between nucleons to predict properties of atomic nuclei, has also made significant progress in calculating NMEs. This approach is particularly useful for light nuclei where experimental data is scarce.
Uncertainty Quantification:
The report discusses the state-of-the-art in uncertainty quantification (UQ) techniques for NME calculations. UQ is crucial in determining the reliability and precision of theoretical predictions. The workshop participants proposed using Bayesian model mixing as an effective method for incorporating uncertainties from different sources into final results.
Roadmap:
The workshop participants developed a roadmap for future research on 0νββ decay calculations. One key aspect of this roadmap is the incorporation of Bayesian Model Mixing for uncertainty quantification, along with an analysis of correlations between double-beta-decay rates and other observables such as neutrino masses and mixing angles.
To enhance the accuracy and precision of matrix element calculations, specific projects were proposed in theoretical and computational physics. These include improving lattice QCD simulations by including dynamical quarks, developing new methods for ab initio nuclear-structure calculations, and exploring new approaches such as machine learning techniques.
Impact:
By delivering accurate matrix elements with carefully assessed uncertainties across all relevant nuclei, these calculations will enable clear conclusions to be drawn from observations or non-observations of 0νββ decay regardless of any new physics that may be at play. This will provide valuable insights into the nature of neutrinos and their role in shaping our universe.
Moreover, these advancements will have implications beyond 0νββ decay studies. Accurate NMEs are essential inputs for other rare processes involving neutrinos such as neutrinoless double-electron capture and neutrinoless double-positron decay. These calculations will also contribute to our understanding of nuclear structure and the strong force.
Future Directions:
The authors acknowledge that this report focuses on the US context for 0νββ theory, but they plan to expand their scope in a forthcoming journal article to include non-US efforts in this area. They welcome additional input from the scientific community to further refine their text before submission.
Furthermore, the workshop participants emphasized the need for continued collaboration between theorists and experimentalists to validate theoretical predictions with experimental data. This will not only improve our understanding of 0νββ decay but also provide valuable insights into other fundamental processes involving neutrinos.
Conclusion:
The NSF Project Scoping Workshop report provides a comprehensive assessment of current NME calculations for 0νββ decay and outlines a roadmap for future research in this area. The advancements highlighted in this report have the potential to significantly impact our understanding of neutrinos and their role in shaping our universe. With continued collaboration and advancements in theoretical and computational techniques, we are one step closer to accurately predicting 0νββ rates and potentially unlocking new physics beyond the Standard Model.