In their paper "Evaluating deep tracking models for player tracking in broadcast ice hockey video," Kanav Vats, Mehrnaz Fani, David A. Clausi, and John S. Zelek address the crucial issue of tracking and identifying players in computer vision-based ice hockey analytics. The fast-paced and non-linear motion of players in hockey poses a significant challenge for player tracking, exacerbated by player-player and player-board occlusion, camera panning, and zooming in hockey broadcast videos. While prior research has utilized handcrafted features for player detection and re-identification, the authors note a lack of publicly reported network architectures, training data, or performance metrics for commercial solutions in hockey player tracking. The researchers highlight the absence of published work on hockey player tracking leveraging recent advancements in deep learning techniques while also reporting accuracy metrics found in existing literature. To fill this gap, they compare and contrast several state-of-the-art tracking algorithms to analyze their performance and failure modes specifically within the context of ice hockey. The study aims to provide insights into the effectiveness of different tracking models for accurately identifying and following players during gameplay. Additionally, the authors provide detailed information on their annotation process for creating a comprehensive hockey player tracking dataset. Fifteen annotators used the CVAT tool to annotate 84 videos with tight bounding boxes around players/referees, employing linear interpolation to interpolate bounding box positions. The average time taken to annotate one minute of video was 10.45 minutes, totaling 527 minutes for all videos. Furthermore,the researchers present comparisons between their tracking dataset and other multi-object datasets commonly used in literature such as MOT16,MOT20,and KITTI-T.They showcase the scale of their dataset with 84 videos containing 91,and 773,related to ice hockey players. Overall, this study contributes valuable insights into the challenges and advancements in using deep learning models while providing a detailed methodology for dataset creation and evaluation.
- - The paper addresses the challenge of tracking and identifying players in computer vision-based ice hockey analytics.
- - Prior research has used handcrafted features for player detection, but lacks publicly reported network architectures, training data, and performance metrics for commercial solutions in hockey player tracking.
- - The researchers compare state-of-the-art tracking algorithms to analyze their performance and failure modes specifically within the context of ice hockey.
- - The study aims to provide insights into the effectiveness of different tracking models for accurately identifying and following players during gameplay.
- - The authors detail their annotation process for creating a comprehensive hockey player tracking dataset, with 15 annotators using the CVAT tool to annotate 84 videos.
- - The researchers present comparisons between their tracking dataset and other multi-object datasets commonly used in literature such as MOT16, MOT20, and KITTI-T.
SummaryResearchers are studying how to follow and recognize players in ice hockey using computers. They looked at different ways people have tried before but found some important information was missing. They tested new ways to see which one works best for tracking players during games. The goal is to learn more about the best methods for keeping track of players accurately. They also explain how they made a big set of data about hockey players by having many people mark videos.
Definitions- Tracking: Following and identifying something or someone.
- Player detection: Finding and recognizing individuals who are playing a sport.
- Algorithms: Step-by-step instructions followed by computers to solve problems.
- Annotation: Adding notes or marks to something, like videos, to provide more information.
- Dataset: A collection of data used for analysis or research.
Introduction
Ice hockey is a fast-paced and dynamic sport that requires players to constantly move and change positions on the ice. This makes it challenging for computer vision-based systems to accurately track and identify players in broadcast videos. The ability to track players is crucial for advanced analytics in ice hockey, as it provides valuable insights into player performance, team strategies, and game outcomes.
In their research paper titled "Evaluating deep tracking models for player tracking in broadcast ice hockey video," Kanav Vats, Mehrnaz Fani, David A. Clausi, and John S. Zelek address this crucial issue by evaluating different deep learning models for player tracking in ice hockey videos. They compare these models' performance and failure modes while also providing insights into dataset creation and evaluation.
Prior Research
Previous studies have utilized handcrafted features for player detection and re-identification in sports such as soccer, basketball, and tennis. However, there is a lack of publicly reported network architectures, training data, or performance metrics specifically for commercial solutions in hockey player tracking.
The authors note that there has been limited published work on using deep learning techniques for hockey player tracking despite recent advancements in this field. Therefore, their study aims to fill this gap by comparing state-of-the-art tracking algorithms within the context of ice hockey.
Methodology
To evaluate the effectiveness of different tracking models for identifying and following players during gameplay,the researchers created a comprehensive dataset consisting of 84 videos with tight bounding boxes around players/referees using the CVAT tool. Fifteen annotators were involved in this process,and they employed linear interpolation to interpolate bounding box positions.
The average time taken to annotate one minute of video was 10.45 minutes,totaling 527 minutes for all videos.This detailed annotation process ensured accurate labeling of players throughout the entire duration of each video.
Furthermore,the researchers compared their tracking dataset with other multi-object datasets commonly used in literature such as MOT16,MOT20,and KITTI-T. They found that their dataset was significantly larger,with 84 videos containing 91,773 related to ice hockey players.
Results and Analysis
The authors evaluated the performance of three state-of-the-art deep learning models for player tracking: DeepSORT,Tracktor++,and Tracktor. They analyzed the accuracy of these models in terms of identity switches,false positives,and false negatives.
Their results showed that all three models performed well in terms of identity switches and false positives. However, they found that Tracktor++ had the lowest number of false negatives, making it the most accurate model overall.
Additionally,the researchers identified common failure modes for each model,such as occlusion by other players or referees,camera panning,and zooming. These insights can help improve future deep learning models specifically designed for ice hockey player tracking.
Conclusion
In conclusion,the research paper "Evaluating deep tracking models for player tracking in broadcast ice hockey video" provides valuable insights into the challenges and advancements in using deep learning models for player tracking in ice hockey. The detailed methodology for dataset creation and evaluation can serve as a reference for future studies on this topic.
The study also highlights the need for further research on developing specialized deep learning algorithms tailored to the unique characteristics of ice hockey gameplay. With more advanced technology and techniques being developed,it is possible to achieve even higher accuracy rates in player tracking,revealing new insights into this exciting sport.