In a recent Letter to the Editor, authors Bart H. McGuyer, Justin M. Brown, and Hoan B. Dang discuss an intriguing experiment involving the reaction between diet soda and Mentos candies. The authors propose a novel method of producing this reaction by directly immersing a plastic soda bottle in liquid nitrogen. The phenomenon of combining diet soda and Mentos to create an explosive reaction has gained significant attention in popular culture. However, the conventional approach involves dropping Mentos candies into a bottle of diet soda, causing a rapid release of carbon dioxide gas due to the rough surface of the candies providing nucleation sites for bubble formation. In their letter, McGuyer, Brown, and Dang present an alternative method that introduces liquid nitrogen into the equation. By immersing a plastic soda bottle filled with diet soda into liquid nitrogen, they demonstrate that the extreme cold temperature causes a similar reaction as when Mentos are added conventionally. The authors provide evidence supporting their claim by citing previous studies on the effects of temperature on carbonation reactions. They explain that lowering the temperature increases the solubility of carbon dioxide in liquids, leading to enhanced gas release when nucleation sites are introduced. This innovative approach not only adds novelty to an already popular experiment but also provides an opportunity for further exploration and scientific inquiry. By investigating how different factors such as temperature and pressure affect the reaction between diet soda and Mentos, researchers can gain valuable insights into fluid dynamics and chemical reactions. Overall, this Letter to the Editor highlights an exciting variation on the well-known diet soda and Mentos experiment by introducing liquid nitrogen as a catalyst for the explosive reaction. The authors' proposal opens up avenues for further research in understanding carbonation reactions under extreme conditions and encourages scientific curiosity among students and enthusiasts alike. Source: Bart H. McGuyer, Justin M. Brown, Hoan B. Dang (2021). Diet Soda and Liquid Nitrogen. American Journal of Physics, 77(6), 677.
- - Authors propose a new method of creating an explosive reaction between diet soda and Mentos by immersing a plastic soda bottle in liquid nitrogen.
- - Conventional approach involves dropping Mentos candies into diet soda to release carbon dioxide gas.
- - Immersing the bottle in liquid nitrogen causes a similar reaction as adding Mentos conventionally.
- - Lowering temperature increases solubility of carbon dioxide, leading to enhanced gas release when nucleation sites are introduced.
- - This innovative approach adds novelty to the experiment and encourages further research on fluid dynamics and chemical reactions.
- - The authors' proposal opens up avenues for understanding carbonation reactions under extreme conditions.
The authors have a new way to make soda explode by putting the bottle in very cold liquid. Normally, people put Mentos candy in soda to make it fizz. Putting the bottle in cold liquid does the same thing. When the temperature is lower, more gas comes out of the soda when something is added to it. This new idea is interesting and can help us learn more about how things react with each other."
Definitions- Explosive: Something that bursts or makes a loud noise suddenly.
- Reaction: What happens when two things come together and change.
- Immersing: Putting something completely into a liquid.
- Conventional: The usual or common way of doing something.
- Solubility: How much of something can dissolve in a liquid.
- Carbon dioxide: A gas that we breathe out and plants use for food.
- Nucleation sites: Spots where bubbles start forming in a liquid.
The Explosive Reaction Between Diet Soda and Mentos: An Innovative Twist
The combination of diet soda and Mentos candies has become a popular experiment in recent years, with videos of the explosive reaction going viral on social media. However, a recent Letter to the Editor by Bart H. McGuyer, Justin M. Brown, and Hoan B. Dang proposes an alternative method for producing this reaction by using liquid nitrogen.
Conventional Approach
The conventional approach to creating the diet soda and Mentos reaction involves dropping Mentos candies into a bottle of diet soda. The rough surface of the candies provides nucleation sites for bubble formation, causing a rapid release of carbon dioxide gas.
The Alternative Method
In their letter, McGuyer et al. suggest immersing a plastic soda bottle filled with diet soda into liquid nitrogen as an alternative way to produce the explosive reaction. Liquid nitrogen is extremely cold (-196°C) and when introduced to the warm diet soda, it causes a similar effect as dropping in Mentos candies conventionally.
Evidence Supporting the Claim
To support their proposal, McGuyer et al. cite previous studies on temperature's effects on carbonation reactions. They explain that lowering the temperature increases the solubility of carbon dioxide in liquids, leading to enhanced gas release when nucleation sites are present.
Further Exploration and Scientific Inquiry
This innovative approach not only adds novelty to an already popular experiment but also opens up avenues for further research. By investigating how different factors such as temperature and pressure affect the reaction between diet soda and Mentos, researchers can gain valuable insights into fluid dynamics and chemical reactions.
This new twist also encourages scientific curiosity among students and enthusiasts alike by introducing them to extreme conditions that can alter familiar reactions.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the Letter to the Editor by McGuyer et al. presents an exciting variation on the well-known diet soda and Mentos experiment by introducing liquid nitrogen as a catalyst for the explosive reaction. Their proposal not only adds novelty but also provides opportunities for further research and scientific inquiry. This letter highlights the importance of exploring different conditions and factors in chemical reactions, ultimately contributing to our understanding of fluid dynamics and enhancing scientific curiosity.