In the study of mass definitions for asymptotically flat spacetimes in general relativity, it is observed that the precise definition of mass within an arbitrary spacetime remains elusive. However, various proposed definitions have been explored to address this issue. Research by Dan N. Vollick delves into eight different masses and reveals that they correspond to either active gravitational or inertial mass. For example, the ADM mass aligns with inertial mass while the Møller mass corresponds to active gravitational mass. It is noted that these two types of masses do not generally equate. Additionally, it is found that if a spacetime is vacuum at large distances (r), the Einstein equations dictate that both inertial and active gravitational masses must be equal. Similarly, if any matter extending out to large distances adheres to weak, strong, or dominant energy conditions, the masses are forced to be equivalent as well. The study also examines how these different types of masses contribute to various phenomena within spacetime such as gravitational redshift, light deflection, Shapiro time delay, precession of perihelia, and the motion of test bodies. By analyzing a time-dependent spacetime metric and considering conservation laws related to inertial and active gravitational masses through pseudotensors like Møller and Einstein pseudotensors respectively; it is postulated that conservation laws correspond to the preservation of active gravitational and inertial masses respectively. Overall,this research sheds light on the complexities surrounding mass definitions in general relativity for asymptotically flat spacetimes and highlights how different types of masses play crucial roles in understanding fundamental aspects of gravitation within these contexts.
- - Precise definition of mass within an arbitrary spacetime remains elusive
- - Various proposed definitions explored to address the issue
- - Eight different masses identified by Dan N. Vollick, corresponding to active gravitational or inertial mass
- - ADM mass aligns with inertial mass
- - Møller mass corresponds to active gravitational mass
- - Inertial and active gravitational masses do not generally equate, unless spacetime is vacuum at large distances (r) or matter adheres to energy conditions
- - Different types of masses contribute to phenomena such as gravitational redshift, light deflection, Shapiro time delay, precession of perihelia, and motion of test bodies
- - Conservation laws related to inertial and active gravitational masses through pseudotensors like Møller and Einstein pseudotensors correspond to preservation of these masses
Summary- Mass is a measurement of how much stuff is in something, but it can be tricky to define exactly in different places.
- Scientists have come up with different ways to explain what mass is and how it works.
- There are eight types of mass identified by Dan N. Vollick, which relate to how things move because of gravity or their own weight.
- Some types of mass match up with each other, like ADM mass with how heavy something feels and Møller mass with how gravity affects it.
- Mass helps us understand why things like light bending, time slowing down near big objects, and planets moving the way they do.
Definitions- Mass: A measure of how much matter is in an object or substance.
- Spacetime: The combined concepts of three-dimensional space and one-dimensional time into a four-dimensional continuum where events occur in relation to each other.
- Inertial mass: The resistance an object has to changes in its motion when a force is applied.
- Active gravitational mass: The property that causes objects to attract each other due to gravity.
- Conservation laws: Principles stating that certain properties of a system remain constant over time unless acted upon by external forces.
Introduction
In general relativity, the concept of mass plays a crucial role in understanding the behavior of spacetime and its interactions with matter. However, defining mass within an arbitrary spacetime has proven to be a challenging task. This is due to the fact that there are various proposed definitions of mass, each corresponding to different physical interpretations and implications.
In this research paper by Dan N. Vollick, titled "Mass Definitions for Asymptotically Flat Spacetimes in General Relativity", eight different masses are explored and their relationships with active gravitational and inertial masses are examined. The study sheds light on the complexities surrounding mass definitions in general relativity for asymptotically flat spacetimes and highlights how different types of masses play crucial roles in understanding fundamental aspects of gravitation within these contexts.
The Eight Masses
The first step in understanding mass definitions for asymptotically flat spacetimes is to examine the eight different masses proposed by Vollick. These include:
1) ADM (Arnowitt-Deser-Misner) Mass
2) Bondi-Sachs Mass
3) Komar Mass
4) Møller Mass
5) Einstein Pseudotensor Mass
6) Landau-Lifshitz Pseudotensor Mass
7) Papapetrou Energy-Momentum Complex
8) Bergmann-Thomson Superpotential
Each of these masses corresponds to either active gravitational or inertial mass, which are two distinct concepts in general relativity.
Active Gravitational vs Inertial Mass
Active gravitational mass refers to the source of gravity itself - it is the property that determines how much an object will accelerate when subjected to a given gravitational field. On the other hand, inertial mass refers to an object's resistance to changes in motion when acted upon by external forces.
It is important to note that these two types of masses do not always equate. In fact, the study reveals that only the ADM mass aligns with inertial mass while the Møller mass corresponds to active gravitational mass.
Relationships between Masses
The research paper also examines how different types of masses relate to each other and how they contribute to various phenomena within spacetime. For example, it is found that if a spacetime is vacuum at large distances (r), the Einstein equations dictate that both inertial and active gravitational masses must be equal.
Similarly, if any matter extending out to large distances adheres to weak, strong, or dominant energy conditions, the masses are forced to be equivalent as well. This highlights the interplay between different types of masses and their implications for understanding gravity in asymptotically flat spacetimes.
Contributions to Phenomena
The study also delves into how these different types of masses contribute to various phenomena within spacetime such as gravitational redshift, light deflection, Shapiro time delay, precession of perihelia, and the motion of test bodies. By analyzing a time-dependent spacetime metric and considering conservation laws related to inertial and active gravitational masses through pseudotensors like Møller and Einstein pseudotensors respectively; it is postulated that conservation laws correspond to the preservation of active gravitational and inertial masses respectively.
This further emphasizes the importance of understanding different mass definitions in general relativity for asymptotically flat spacetimes in order to fully comprehend these fundamental aspects of gravitation.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Vollick's research sheds light on the complexities surrounding mass definitions in general relativity for asymptotically flat spacetimes. The study highlights how different types of masses play crucial roles in understanding fundamental aspects of gravitation within these contexts.
By examining eight different proposed definitions for mass and their relationships with active gravitational and inertial masses, the research provides valuable insights into the interplay between these concepts. It also demonstrates how different types of masses contribute to various phenomena within spacetime, further emphasizing the importance of understanding mass definitions in general relativity.
Overall, this research paper serves as a significant contribution to the field of general relativity and provides a deeper understanding of mass definitions for asymptotically flat spacetimes.