Data as Infrastructure for Smart Cities: Linking Data Platforms to Business Strategies

AI-generated keywords: Fragmented nature Cross-domain city data Smart cities initiatives Business-model-driven framework Data infrastructures

AI-generated Key Points

Fragmented nature of city infrastructure systems
Potential for integrating cross-domain city data to create smarter cities
Limitations of current smart cities initiatives, focusing on technology and overlooking stakeholder input and data needs
Proposal of a business-model-driven framework for designing large and interconnected data infrastructures supported by multiple stakeholders
Consideration of aspects such as service, technology, organization, value, and governance requirements in the framework
Use of exemplary scenarios and decision-making processes to design data infrastructures
Sub-scale pilots/demonstrators and examples of fragmented and "deprived" data re-use provide further context
Discussion on two prevailing approaches in the provision of city data and sample of London's city data landscape
Emphasis on integrated approaches adopting local, national, and international standards for effective implementation of data infrastructures
Importance of establishing a Data-Driven Value Network (DDVN) in the organization domain
Categorization of stakeholders into platform keystone, structural partners, contributing partners, and supporting partners based on their power within the value network
Information on architecture aspects of different datasets in terms of structure, real-time capabilities, and architecture type.

Also access our AI generated: Comprehensive summary, Lay summary, Blog-like article; or ask questions about this paper to our AI assistant.

Authors: Larissa Romualdo-Suzuki, Anthony Finkelstein

arXiv: 2005.11414v1 - DOI (cs.CY)

License: CC BY-NC-SA 4.0

Abstract: The systems that operate the infrastructure of cities have evolved in a fragmented fashion across several generations of technology, causing city utilities and services to operate sub-optimally and limiting the creation of new value-added services and restrict opportunities for cost-saving. The integration of cross-domain city data offers a new wave of opportunities to mitigate some of these impacts and enables city systems to draw effectively on interoperable data that will be used to deliver smarter cities. Despite the considerable potential of city data, current smart cities initiatives have mainly addressed the problem of data management from a technology perspective, and have disregarded stakeholders and data needs. As a consequence, such initiatives are susceptible to failure from inadequate stakeholder input, requirements neglecting, and information fragmentation and overload. They are also likely to be limited in terms of both scalability and future proofing against technological, commercial and legislative change. This paper proposes a systematic business-modeldriven framework to guide the design of large and highly interconnected data infrastructures which are provided and supported by multiple stakeholders. The framework is used to model, elicit and reason about the requirements of the service, technology, organization, value, and governance aspects of smart cities. The requirements serve as an input to a closed-loop supply chain model, which is designed and managed to explicitly consider the activities and processes that enables the stakeholders of smart cities to efficiently leverage their collective knowledge. We demonstrate how our approach can be used to design data infrastructures by examining a series of exemplary scenarios and by demonstrating how our approach handles the holistic design of a data infrastructure and informs the decision making process.

Submitted to arXiv on 22 May. 2020

Ask questions about this paper to our AI assistant

You can also chat with multiple papers at once here.

AI assistant instructions?

Results of the summarizing process for the arXiv paper: 2005.11414v1

Comprehensive Summary
Key points
Layman's Summary
Blog article

The existing summary discusses the fragmented nature of city infrastructure systems and the potential for integrating cross-domain city data to create smarter cities. However, it also highlights the limitations of current smart cities initiatives, which mainly focus on technology and overlook stakeholder input and data needs. To address these issues, the paper proposes a business-model-driven framework for designing large and interconnected data infrastructures supported by multiple stakeholders. This framework considers various aspects such as service, technology, organization, value, and governance requirements. The paper demonstrates how this approach can be used to design data infrastructures through exemplary scenarios and decision-making processes. In addition to the existing summary, there is further context provided in the form of sub-scale pilots/demonstrators and examples of fragmented and "deprived" data re-use. The paper also discusses two prevailing approaches in the provision of city data and presents a sample of London's city data landscape. It emphasizes that integrated approaches adopting local, national, and international standards are necessary for implementing data infrastructures effectively. Furthermore, it highlights the importance of establishing a value network called a Data-Driven Value Network (DDVN) in the organization domain. This network consists of various actors with their own strategies, goals, resources, capabilities, influence, and requirements. These actors' value activities are orchestrated in a value chain that enables co-opetition in providing city data and services while fostering innovation and value creation. The paper categorizes stakeholders into four basic types: platform keystone, structural partners, contributing partners, and supporting partners based on their power within the value network. It also provides information on the architecture aspects of different datasets in terms of structure (semi-structured or structured), real-time capabilities (near-real-time or non-real-time), and architecture type. Overall,this refined detailed longer summary provides a comprehensive overview of the paper's content by incorporating additional context from sub-scale pilots/demonstrators to London's city data landscape and discussing the importance of standards, value networks, and stakeholder roles in designing data infrastructures for smarter cities.

- Fragmented nature of city infrastructure systems
- Potential for integrating cross-domain city data to create smarter cities
- Limitations of current smart cities initiatives, focusing on technology and overlooking stakeholder input and data needs
- Proposal of a business-model-driven framework for designing large and interconnected data infrastructures supported by multiple stakeholders
- Consideration of aspects such as service, technology, organization, value, and governance requirements in the framework
- Use of exemplary scenarios and decision-making processes to design data infrastructures
- Sub-scale pilots/demonstrators and examples of fragmented and "deprived" data re-use provide further context
- Discussion on two prevailing approaches in the provision of city data and sample of London's city data landscape
- Emphasis on integrated approaches adopting local, national, and international standards for effective implementation of data infrastructures
- Importance of establishing a Data-Driven Value Network (DDVN) in the organization domain
- Categorization of stakeholders into platform keystone, structural partners, contributing partners, and supporting partners based on their power within the value network
- Information on architecture aspects of different datasets in terms of structure, real-time capabilities, and architecture type.

The city's infrastructure systems are not connected and work separately. Integrating different types of data can make cities smarter. Current smart city projects focus too much on technology and don't listen to what people need. A new framework suggests that many different groups should work together to create better data systems for cities. When designing these systems, we need to think about things like services, technology, organization, value, and rules. Definitions- Fragmented: When something is broken into many separate parts. - Integrating: Combining different things together. - Initiatives: Projects or plans. - Framework: A plan or structure for doing something. - Stakeholder: Someone who has an interest or involvement in a project or decision. - Infrastructure: The basic systems and structures that a city needs to work properly. - Data: Information that is collected and used by computers. - Smart city: A city that uses technology to improve how it works and helps its residents.

The Need for Integrated Data Infrastructures in Smart Cities

The concept of smart cities has gained significant attention in recent years as urban populations continue to grow and the need for efficient and sustainable city management becomes increasingly crucial. A key aspect of creating smarter cities is the integration of various city infrastructure systems, such as transportation, energy, water, and waste management. This integration allows for better coordination and optimization of resources, leading to improved services and quality of life for citizens. However, current smart city initiatives often focus solely on technology solutions without considering the input and data needs of stakeholders involved in managing these infrastructures. This fragmented approach can lead to inefficiencies and missed opportunities for innovation. To address this issue, a research paper titled "Designing Large-Scale Data Infrastructures for Smarter Cities: A Business-Model-Driven Framework" proposes a framework that takes into account various aspects such as service, technology, organization, value, and governance requirements.

The Limitations of Current Smart City Initiatives

The paper highlights the limitations of current smart city initiatives by discussing two prevailing approaches in providing city data – top-down (government-led) or bottom-up (citizen-driven). While both approaches have their merits, they also have drawbacks that hinder effective implementation. For instance, top-down approaches may overlook local context and stakeholder needs while bottom-up approaches may lack scalability and standardization. Moreover, the paper presents examples from sub-scale pilots/demonstrators that demonstrate how fragmented data re-use can result in deprived datasets with limited potential for cross-domain integration. These examples highlight the need for a more integrated approach to designing data infrastructures in smart cities.

The Importance of Standards

One crucial aspect emphasized by the paper is the importance of standards when it comes to implementing integrated data infrastructures. Local standards are necessary to ensure compatibility with existing systems within a city, while national and international standards enable interoperability between different cities. Without these standards, data sharing and integration become challenging, hindering the potential for smarter cities.

The Data-Driven Value Network (DDVN)

The paper introduces the concept of a Data-Driven Value Network (DDVN) in the organization domain as a crucial element in designing effective data infrastructures for smart cities. This network consists of various actors with their own strategies, goals, resources, capabilities, influence, and requirements. These actors' value activities are orchestrated in a value chain that enables co-opetition – cooperation and competition – in providing city data and services while fostering innovation and value creation.

Stakeholder Roles in Designing Data Infrastructures

To better understand the roles of stakeholders within the DDVN, the paper categorizes them into four basic types: platform keystone, structural partners, contributing partners, and supporting partners based on their power within the value network. Each type plays a critical role in ensuring successful implementation of integrated data infrastructures.

Data Architecture Aspects

The paper also provides information on the architecture aspects of different datasets in terms of structure (semi-structured or structured), real-time capabilities (near-real-time or non-real-time), and architecture type. This information is essential when designing data infrastructures as it determines how easily datasets can be integrated with other systems.

Designing Large-Scale Data Infrastructures through Exemplary Scenarios

The paper demonstrates how its proposed framework can be applied to design large-scale data infrastructures through exemplary scenarios. These scenarios showcase decision-making processes involved in selecting appropriate technologies and governance models to support cross-domain integration of city data. One such scenario involves integrating transportation and energy infrastructure systems to optimize traffic flow by using real-time energy consumption data from electric vehicles. The framework helps identify necessary data sources, stakeholders, and technologies required to implement this scenario successfully.

London's City Data Landscape

The paper also presents a sample of London's city data landscape to provide further context on the challenges and opportunities in designing integrated data infrastructures for smart cities. The city has a diverse range of datasets from various domains, such as transportation, energy, environment, and health. However, these datasets are often fragmented and lack standardization, making it challenging to integrate them for smarter city management.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the research paper "Designing Large-Scale Data Infrastructures for Smarter Cities: A Business-Model-Driven Framework" highlights the need for integrated approaches in designing data infrastructures for smart cities. It emphasizes the importance of considering various aspects such as service, technology, organization, value, and governance requirements while also highlighting the crucial role of standards and stakeholder involvement. By adopting this framework and establishing a Data-Driven Value Network (DDVN), cities can effectively design large-scale data infrastructures that enable cross-domain integration and lead to more efficient and sustainable urban management.

Created on 09 Feb. 2024

Assess the quality of the AI-generated content by voting

Score: 0

The previous summary was created more than a year ago and can be re-run (if necessary) by clicking on the Run button below.

Look for similar papers (in beta version)

By clicking on the button above, our algorithm will scan all papers in our database to find the closest based on the contents of the full papers and not just on metadata. Please note that it only works for papers that we have generated summaries for and you can rerun it from time to time to get a more accurate result while our database grows.

Disclaimer: The AI-based summarization tool and virtual assistant provided on this website may not always provide accurate and complete summaries or responses. We encourage you to carefully review and evaluate the generated content to ensure its quality and relevance to your needs.