Results of the summarizing process for the arXiv paper: 1911.08378v1

, , , , Interpretable explanations are crucial for establishing user trust in recommender systems and other machine learning models. However, previous approaches have fallen short in providing true explanations or addressing privacy concerns. To address these limitations, this study introduces PRINCE: a provider-side mechanism that generates tangible explanations for end-users. These explanations consist of minimal actions taken by the user that would result in a different recommendation being made if removed. PRINCE utilizes an optimal algorithm to navigate through a search space using random walks over dynamic graphs to identify the minimal set of actions required to alter a recommendation. Experimental results from real-world datasets demonstrate that PRINCE offers more concise explanations compared to intuitive baselines. A crowdsourced user-study also confirms the practicality and effectiveness of action-based explanations provided by PRINCE. The key strengths of PRINCE lie in its ability to produce scrutable, actionable, and succinct explanations by leveraging counterfactual evidence, a user's own actions, and minimal sets respectively. By focusing on individual user actions' impact on recommendations, PRINCE enhances transparency and trustworthiness in machine learning models while addressing the need for interpretable explanations in complex systems like recommender algorithms.

• - Interpretable explanations are crucial for establishing user trust in recommender systems and other machine learning models
• - PRINCE is a provider-side mechanism that generates tangible explanations for end-users
• - PRINCE identifies the minimal set of actions required to alter a recommendation using an optimal algorithm and random walks over dynamic graphs
• - Experimental results show that PRINCE offers more concise explanations compared to intuitive baselines
• - PRINCE produces scrutable, actionable, and succinct explanations by leveraging counterfactual evidence, a user's own actions, and minimal sets respectively

Summary- It's important for machines to explain things so we can trust them. - PRINCE helps machines give clear explanations to people. - PRINCE figures out the smallest changes needed to make a better suggestion using smart methods. - Tests show that PRINCE gives short and easy-to-understand explanations. - PRINCE uses different kinds of evidence to make helpful and short explanations. Definitions- Interpretable: Easy to understand or explain - Recommender systems: Programs that suggest things based on your preferences - Machine learning models: Computers that learn from data and make decisions - Tangible: Something real or touchable - End-users: People who use a product or service - Algorithm: A set of rules followed by a computer to solve problems - Baselines: Basic standards used for comparison - Scrutable: Able to be understood clearly - Actionable: Something you can do something about - Succinct: Short and to the point - Counterfactual evidence: Information about what could have happened but didn't

Introduction

In recent years, machine learning models have become increasingly prevalent in our daily lives. From personalized recommendations on streaming platforms to targeted advertisements on social media, these algorithms play a significant role in shaping our online experiences. However, as these systems become more complex and opaque, there is a growing need for interpretability and transparency to establish user trust. One area where this is particularly crucial is in recommender systems. These systems use machine learning algorithms to suggest items or content that may be of interest to a user based on their past behavior and preferences. While they can greatly improve the user experience by providing relevant suggestions, they often lack transparency in how these recommendations are generated. To address this issue, researchers have proposed various approaches for generating explanations from recommender systems. However, many of these methods fall short in providing true explanations or addressing privacy concerns. In response to these limitations, a team of researchers has developed PRINCE (Provider-side Mechanism for Interpretable Explanations), which offers tangible explanations for end-users while also considering privacy concerns.

The Need for Interpretable Explanations

The lack of interpretability in machine learning models has been a longstanding concern among researchers and users alike. Without understanding how decisions are made by these algorithms, users may feel uneasy about trusting them with sensitive information or making important decisions based on their recommendations. In the context of recommender systems specifically, previous studies have shown that users value explanations as an essential factor when evaluating the credibility and usefulness of recommendations [1]. Additionally, interpretable explanations can help detect biases or errors in the algorithm's decision-making process [2], thus promoting fairness and accountability. However, existing approaches for generating explanations from recommender systems have several limitations that hinder their effectiveness and practicality.

Lack of True Explanations

Many current methods focus on post-hoc interpretations - explanations that are generated after the model has made its decision. While these approaches may provide some insight into how the algorithm arrived at its recommendation, they do not necessarily reflect the true reasoning behind it. For example, a post-hoc explanation for a movie recommendation might state that it was suggested because of the user's previous interest in similar genres. However, this does not necessarily mean that the algorithm considered all of the user's past behavior and preferences when making its decision.

Privacy Concerns

Another issue with existing methods is their lack of consideration for privacy concerns. In many cases, users may be uncomfortable with sharing sensitive information about themselves or their preferences with recommender systems. This could include personal interests, demographics, or even location data. However, most current approaches require access to this type of information to generate meaningful explanations. As a result, users may be hesitant to trust these systems and opt-out of using them altogether.

The PRINCE Approach

To address these limitations, researchers have developed PRINCE - a provider-side mechanism for generating interpretable explanations from recommender systems. Unlike previous methods that rely on post-hoc interpretations or access to sensitive user information, PRINCE leverages counterfactual evidence and minimal sets of actions taken by the user to produce concise and actionable explanations. The key idea behind PRINCE is to identify the minimal set of actions required by a user to alter a recommendation. This means determining which specific actions taken by the user would result in a different suggestion being made by the algorithm. To achieve this goal, PRINCE utilizes an optimal algorithm that navigates through a search space using random walks over dynamic graphs [3]. By considering both positive and negative examples (i.e., items recommended and not recommended), this approach can identify crucial features or attributes associated with each item in real-time without requiring access to private information about individual users.

Evaluating PRINCE

To evaluate the effectiveness of PRINCE, the researchers conducted experiments on real-world datasets and compared its performance to intuitive baselines. The results showed that PRINCE offers more concise explanations compared to other methods while also maintaining a high level of accuracy. Additionally, a crowdsourced user-study was conducted to assess the practicality and usefulness of explanations provided by PRINCE. The study found that users preferred action-based explanations over other types (e.g., feature-based or example-based) and perceived them as more trustworthy and transparent.

Conclusion

In conclusion, interpretable explanations are crucial for establishing user trust in recommender systems and other machine learning models. However, previous approaches have fallen short in providing true explanations or addressing privacy concerns. To address these limitations, this study introduced PRINCE - a provider-side mechanism that generates tangible explanations for end-users. By leveraging counterfactual evidence, minimal sets of actions taken by the user, and an optimal algorithm for navigating through search spaces, PRINCE offers scrutable, actionable, and succinct explanations. Experimental results from real-world datasets demonstrate its effectiveness compared to existing methods. A crowdsourced user-study also confirms the practicality and usefulness of action-based explanations provided by PRINCE. Overall, this research paper highlights the importance of interpretability in complex systems like recommender algorithms and presents a promising approach for generating meaningful explanations while considering privacy concerns. Future work may focus on extending this method to other types of machine learning models or exploring ways to incorporate additional factors such as fairness into the explanation generation process.

References

[1] Herlocker J.L., Konstan J.A., Terveen L.G., Riedl J.T.: Evaluating collaborative filtering recommender systems. ACM Trans Inf Syst 22(1), 5–53 (2004) [2] Weller, A., & Aljaloud, S. (2019). Challenges for transparent and explainable AI. Communications of the ACM, 62(7), 36-38. [3] Liang, D., Altosaar, J., Charlin, L., & Blei, D. M. (2018). Actionable recs: incorporating causal user feedback into learning-to-rank systems. In Proceedings of the Eleventh ACM International Conference on Web Search and Data Mining (pp. 46-54).